Noakes, Raymond Brian v J. Harvey Holmes & Son [1979] FCA 75

{4

Execution - Judgnent debt - Registration of judgment

in Norfolk Island ~ Application to set aside transfer of shares py debtor to his wife - Summons not served on company or wife - Whether transfer voluntary and fraudulent - Whether void - Rights of creditors - Validity

of consequential orders ~- 13 Eliz. c.5,

RAYMOND BRIAN NOAKES v. J. HARVY HOLMES & SON

No. VG 15 of 1978

CORAM: Brennen, Dcane and Fisher JJ.

% August 1979.

Melbourne.

IN «THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA GENERAL DIVISION No. VG 15 of 1978 )

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF NORFOLK ISLAND

BETWEEN : RAYMOND BRIAN NGACES

Apoellant (Second Defendant)

AND : J. HAaRVY HOLMes & SON

Respor.dent (Plaintiff)

ORDER

The Court orcers that :-

1. The order of the Supreme Court of Norfolk Tsland made at Melbourne on the 23rd day of December 1977 be varied by -

(1) deleting Paragrephs 3, 5, 6 and 7(b) of che sald order; (it) deleting paragraph 4 of the said order and by

inserting 14 lieu tnereof the following:-

"And 1t 1s declared that the transfer of

the 9,991 shares in the capital of Transworld Trading Limited from the second defendant to his wife Sheilagh Julia Noakes 1s frauduzent and void es against the creditors of che plaantiff."; and

? (221) deleting ~he number and letter "7(a)" and inserting in i1eu thereof the words: "Ané 1t is further

orcered!,

i

2. Otherwise the appeal be dismissed.

3. The appellant pay to the respondent its costs of

this appeal to be taxed.

rs ' - '- ' ' m4 1 . i att \ . . i , 1 ' - woe an . so owt se ' cnoleae , . : ' bay . t- ' ' d > . ' ' 1 ' . . : t ~ - 4 * "oo . . ' ian . ' . an itis : ane) Vee hy hte ' hoe WR . ' ' fee oh oo 1 ' a ' . . bonne | . \ nn so : . 'Le Bue 2 - oy 4 . . ' . way - a ' a . > > . . ° wet 0 , 7. » + ' ' . n L ' td mo . ' we roy uy ' oo t . . 'oye -

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA