Parker Pen (Australia) Pty Ltd v Export Development Grants Board [1984] FCA 62

CATCHWORDS

Administrative law - Administrative Appeals Tribunal - appeal from single judge on question of law - eligibility for export development grant ~ whether manner in which expenditure paid relevant in determining purpose of expenditure - promotional expenditure paid to related company ~ more than one purpose - primary and principal purpose of expenditure not stipulated purpose as in legislation.

Export Market Development Grants Act 1974 s. 4(1), (5) Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s.44

PARKER PEN (AUSTRALIA) PTY. LIMITED v. EXPORT DEVELOPMENT GRANTS BO

No. G 122 of 1983

Coram: Toohey, McGregor and Morling Jv. 30 March 1984

Sydney. 7

tty ") yee " ry Al i 7 'Yt ol vi $i ry] . 1] ral tf 13 ) a 3} ot os mm 1 n rH ! et 1 "y 14 ly tee ia M a | » $4 i] 3) ' ry Shy y) rt ' el wv oH . 4 ' ha . a) 5 - ry F . 4 a ' us n s st 13] a ' . tr fo ' ote u iI 1) tr! On soto mi op . aD Sip 0D nt ry 4 OV ne rd Oy ord Ww si nm x | uw rs) > $3, ad fa] os 0 4 Daal a ve fr BY ms a ah vad (1 iB] q et th It ca alo ost ig] fu " a Oo} i O1 Qs bh 0 ad £1 v Ae mm wm rl G hl ! ny . iy ' ' ef ad , : - ay oe o oe q ne) by $4 ' ben Sr ; ms fx] YD np c) tn?) fan ny t Ww a) fon. 4 : " t fas) Br HI =| Fa Piety | | . Ht =| en or) | mq o) q =) . . Eh i] by *, wy Ww Q ja at kt i al ey fa tq 2, Wy of ite) Ln) en © |

(ae) td wd —y ha

if i G H

[gal Ky

it E [onl Pe hey Pa ra ¢ r

t

t

' t

' A

fy ig] nad we t 1 Ics +

a ti Rg H [jo] ia az ies,

i

¥. MCGREGOR and MORLINS oJ. 30 Macch 1924

Q oO tu iy a ie °a Oo he a]

EASONS FOR JUDGMENT?

njag

THE COURT: Parker Pen -(Australia) Pty. Limited ("the

apreilant") manufactures and distributes in Rustcsiia

> : - : te writing instruments, including the well mown 'Parses" ren.

BO a number of countries, ortncivaliy ain che Bzzan and Pacific region. It is a whelivy cwnea sussiciary ar a Unitad