AOMINTOTEATIVG Lat - Gee ame sere Lea Sam te kb re vat eclarariorn "over eat a zo peore } cart etrber ore de 7 G8 "gure 20ers Teele aearches and gear ro > - tnethst GQ .abe nd cose. 7 Mesa tt. MASTIMS AUT = f. lla ome clase Sake Ge oe tate err ordas 3.514 = ottme thet Mori Fb oy. get scare 1iore F oyilloaw.iy Hi = whether femeeccsip pce ceed sly EVIDENCE - sear+h warrant Aehloe fll ratly oft. nia 2yiaence momsemt obo sare 2 chebrey Cd a es Oe Sh he ota PLrcumsTarcer - vtetae, Fost ber hoe ttt de ry ley liy cytsaiaes TUDCE MARIUS Gr whe , UETE OF OPomR Ps an le CUUE'T moots ta. 1 mio we der Does aad . le: a bate es as can ~ Lo. ' vs i ad ey) CHR OP QUEENA LAL SENTRAL_L BLORCEL, Me TT Sh Teas se el eye Ll tae tha OO oudlacttal Pevieny act G97 wnteh, av oan-rdea, 73eh 7 17 review tne serra Ter combat dd retentacr ar s.r qr, trekicles They Were settee? and meta ren, url are Ve sat, EwTius7 a balret Ll: part of the rea-ewr dear. i ee ee) oo -ik opetaqre that one ecartc vil]! rae rou Che wag Lovee Sear oo Puar wa fark ora. es rs aa Fame oyprsesty me of San Te A 2 pada ot delivered an 7) ana ft truer i Tre CPA Ord Fel ke et tole, "ne Qo othe apelievant: ovbe 'oadat al TE lla, Tac te haat beep Ae me at sherecoy eviten: et Garand volne eeedimchoben ss Sure eu ims the cmeorertaTtian af proses diel Tah tae fous BET mn SPARC, i A ee en Cee ' Se Ce ee 0 a ew a Th one unlat ful 2D oTtas os : respondent wa 12! a metentilen, the rest "PARTS Teuge res ola that the cehicies had been oar suoqe ct ood ie ofa ae esentatian -baut reise, muh ott aedaptrerer cme aseclicarty use woed that oom the evident] add cmb oom ttere bach fre vette len tado@ fart bean avitée The tv apondentes TY wie gat ety be such deciarafron, subenioriid that under tre rele ran) cram ote ons admimieical ive pay eleatate se tan be Cabrel le aide 'oa rhb ert omy a mba? rebate Meet Ta ed PR ER tee he Tabs APT, . monverien fa veut ah otc retant Peco Pie WAL W TF, 0, Lend ot the ope speomdonte, baoe pouch 8 oa Ts. tw} "a FLT bo, orc TT ar ua ter le orb. So terrasse pio foe Ee tT es mm get es Petbeantn sa, ver pemteseh yy 2s Larh of bal Ll. ras es oe , TV tra laches ae Ded asf ako a ee rt es oum@tr oa taboos Pf lee Gotta egw eth, Tosetoom the rele varh sages uele. TCL Om ot APR oder Prk a eee GL Lee lew 24 rrogrect of a Jectsien, theo Clue7™ Te, ds rts Pome Toa, MAK, th oh out bore pad deena Leu, eadest COMMS. T here ap che ja tmatrerc, ne 2 » bh a 1 eke bat pocctay lar oor Ere iaue with them, 2) LIL rag oler Woacn Eh mT TM orespe 1 detrei bal Pre ofthe 7 cere Ve hee le pF - Loamy sta ocr a ob eetrta ee ---- en yo i cr ton MAL = 7 . rro oof ac fot loutbo. 7 halo" rot cme 1st mel oro arr teh fay phe 2s. hfotit Tau et thas ome eecaa thie Oy bak ile Liles Sm PF Th oat ach oon tae Poe bot eg ye here case Ltd oa Pag' scaly "ayy se Cetre d, trh ot rs been one int ela lr oF oe eTone fhe lta ir ors aprtasno a decTatarourn un bial cas, 4 Veo epimt Tater verge produced a remit. ab7e@ quantity Tn ce 6 ed question whether om vehicles vere unla Turis pmproes ca Thor 1s mae a@ ope s co pee, obey bom tat fmm! oe ee te Or hoard aloall, So the bas ander. pec dtp 20 Sammsb be Ll sacred a5 oP wet admin. stb tk ae Ce FS mee lore lew per Sorta on waht oe FRE petpeme sah, Sa pbasecr re sf ee a mg osub ste oral wlee, wat queccare ts oan othe Wrst the oenmcesactl. a aT a tae pe Pron tos Tere SIND TT tor teroe. «loess. ree fe Qu ule fF \ lem 'rcs, 17 qe eaid Ly Pal Leer ide 5 im law hls te ha applicants. pamely tit tar ts TASS E Gt Tbe ee ns 15 "aroveecmecr af abo ravyd.l FD ou. an base cet. aon ve ares! Zeer wala, bP Tae aT a hr eta don le ey trorsspe lc. oof ma we tri lati: Sy Fy ita fap he ms Buyjes! wales cue oa Matrow 2 sadace Le Joie tots wii.. The genefada GPher Tae Pad weshl ar bee ate Tt od re S.iecr idl. , apes wes ociuther cd tu omy celmbeta, 9F 73 ey en tr Shee Gore or ag VFL en etary lata ht ot tae ep]licanta, Ma, Tbe ry out ee i Tor ea 7 a als a CA 0 Coe a oe 2 rete Lal met say rr pry 2m lavPub Teta eet 7 Fe to Pa oe DLEDGRt1on Lf weethe) J ele iru Be. te ay Sed a tae Masa s Parts Lazio lap at The rp vr a . Iz Seeme tleave Shit We ete ET ete od Wd oT the roermenlem|en.s 70 mt cits my ae Tos 72 5 vlba/it LA | a r sop ears Fas nos "aor "epee op pean my the YLT acc FASe, A F aus FLAT TMELE a3 Fl Pru 2) Jeound cer untewanqdacrenrrsn ot "he AVEEZ Tl ote ine. ao ost Th. QL oNeveabe . Aprsitation . thar the CFR. ett be Tipu Le, -Towt la AP LM laste Ty Wet an Toles Far Thos. Sete. Per louallrarc atten, mot merely hoor densa FR ue, weer ft rit Fou. 7+ date of Poe senmures om and Toca sae ue berson Sy cua ene the on (use7 whether Wii cece cr ro hte pevrins Gf sha dee error ac to declaratory 1s cf the proceedings. That point recemes apse , ld walbss 30m ot the mast iumper fant mvyidence in Fhe which Decam? avartlabic toa th ANY li Mos Tyas, 7 decide the rate et 77 pas ce bow tas Evid ae es ram 22 ue bats when iProanss Taam oes dimer TL TO Ae inturmavien available oat Fhe Tommentaie 7 TP tne aial Led, TP propa oe Pde In cat Coltisze Toyir2 ar motes Poe rorto, encttee , my fandiss ir Fh ceeyi tartans eile ae Ths 8 8 BS IDs wena Phe Cireiode yt Fb Re haba ir fuesbions wash chet be reseiy ao eealt with oot late seckians ari oun. ment1e cearenram The fve to am emiestronm cn ble ye erm hee Lore Poweqt ar 19823 und, mow Tarn Valero nmave tebe OP, car alk To Tree grambo. af ties L9RE. The exetircants cp chated Che ab mares temge des Form Herman Morse. LL a@ Mote: Aes eer gi ona ct pee Wee, CL tat 2 'Fo purluas?, the vehicss are wororsebeo, 2 of Val, an Toronado, whacth Lo shall call osimpt., uv Teranodo, 2. Tadticac Seyilte (ths Seve lied, a Vata lon Fae eleer ad fame Pheetwout? aa an Oldemerhiis Curl sg cob i watlas aoe bagiweate F-sec ety) ve at these vthitizs a zt ceareablios; woh wevecm 4, ku. -= Li. fa to be a l@7o sode!, sich a tertain bLieem 7 jankes, Sitint samen, chassis number and Taian. ceustaeantroooy 20" Garnay r fi - ys ed oT ee a Va ? ha * as appears "hoa LFohed py Gerri Macor3 on Ll Naycnbase be ys ame tet ees tec rab yp vst, least ano fart, oF Ldlege tpheg let 2 ot, bat mo lout "tact avidenee of wayweth cP ary , abo ml mre oy Fah Per pe Dose 's appears ie move aAetetd ocelce, toe keoccocne 4s . dmportatizn, am uj: Wee. elovehlete Eeushp, t's 2M a, oie the -nhyjee r $2202 certraty tr the sm at Sy B,at carca la farina 7 146) Yowaver, five hh pris cae te s7 7, by tome barep Fo Sh cut ASLO,710, waatn figure 2 Thewn in a cer teams ome tne wales applicent, a oecop ost sagch 1s Bab loan C'obta the 32 Norl Pateack 'lhu.e midtoain Tone 1738. ine peice ows Wad PALt Br byo sleqeaohal rramso st. Wye Fuss T wes poral Ae the amplicarta' Mage ale U/ TITS aateat to laruasy LeS. in a stu cf ASGIS2LiS, cung.rting, wot! mone? aveseonenr, BADE eR, Coe The secand ceymert was Maaco ev the apolieancs inser NO. FT an" mated FT? Taraace 'Ged ay ckue sere AS Fla oF Teel tL used Toc a "TL ay.prie cransret oearing vith come adjustment fa AnSen,ror, requisition Being sart ol Uubibas Cb" ba " Here, ay in CkIL. oa tie Cs er ee Oe " cely to sree oesbon sm the elPatarit a UE. Str ty eed whe PXaMbn aon Heag roma a lobby fb sobs Uo. . ee ee 2 re 2. the sum et 6 FS Liywuet Was yi, La Flto, nealty kee woultis, webweer the om cralt ana lehsr lr is ete oe stil ad Tolite uc arrest desumentacy surpach Pak That feat t Gt rae me to oa mile aotlieant surk opthee rea eb uibert CR) amet bs ob ct ye Fubcs The malo agplriad: rangnt Pooeiplaum oar yp ehe Tact cat Cnere weer to a rae eathoourapien (BOM lt omy statis taseh ae Fiem "as QV omits ate be ote Fo lee cae rls eo li Mruth poerccwa wa co erste Con: The to vat rt tar. ch geaboce ed Soat sty, 7, Poe Ate ANP Fresate Leet icd ec latam fu Ie . nh) a oe ogee m.gtaulls orhe + elas Ta F 2.45 reeenbec tg oe eee hate FNL Lo Stee a eT Tae rert eo sTe anpre Ped wae. oF £2 2 Ltt vyfed d MSt, Rovere all tre tr lt 2 Te, racer ght, forge Dor RST, 000 Gt smeet im baat sorte cat, The Teh oy at, thal lh "WAS tude Tua Sadar fs I Tewstbooa ke " ror U a cs re VeSnsier Vi. lee fhe ac eee tl, (97 Pt so eapa pls daeccd at peer cat Tet Some ma Be Eethactete OM Dad OP tO Avani. Tone DOO af tri .t Ly the 2espomauert at boubepwerdy Gao BL ate aid et PTR AT ET tel TOE PHT TE TT ae. or ap thee 2 tte ie. tee cade cde ata fhe a eet Pap mh eta Tle cane conpist sales cant)a.t* Mav 1984 as use 4 only, = be prertaced S1Ch IT seized, oe ees earn rola difterert man Frooany Woe, they wf. 1 1 Che derat cot - gars | iT ~" t musty an a Let nett ' ,~ ona atae laa 1? fe care tee fa nq mS DL c Mave The eorsctid, .: Fel, "Lb Vs La co ae ma toe ELE rte rath ot MoM et boas ; u tL 7s Rot. webeg Mob at wl ae 1? mood ' Lie arth eu at you teat mow TL 2M auggye Teh to LPOTS eXAULNAEITT atoearced £ Laney @rsee3, andocrak tut mot pute tae ape lairant so! ta Lea c OU pomed comm LT be lame Enpee velibe Teo taper ue Tee st bios vohwet aiter ameactariren, tur that aA complroarioa wiaich "aso. were mot he Low Seamer F413 emmtena cts ef othe ct onl oo qaint weet BES Le ab ta. om Lip ee mruLp at ot, Which 23 {he mle ApeE)ica , cers ow Thea, WEES imice ed aa mide mares ake ih tlie aul t en Ce i aid tt rtf a ie aol Pettis ys, Lotte te tat ob Voth aye out, Week ete port ott wl DoorRS= yen ni acer ol, ' ror Tog ok Livy a a a " mo ry ou ot Phe oo450 nr ace Qcbope od Crem acceet cng Tha art es homer ala Foo Thiet ' troo4 Cee etiect ras t Thabo wy 2. 2 le tr Sate nd be Roepe Gt wtb enaarl doin ter te Em ob oat ee oT the no ot ow kb owt aeden oc or taba amet "od .- 2 i toate corer "115 Ae doussated verre on hn eingesnming whe Tochi white, 2G Ft 4 ra 1°? i 7r i fa att la Tot Lor. in Lt Ia Ve 2~lotlais " Le. German Motors. Accordsana te his eviaeirie, "18 demtumenk se Ps car under three taolurmis headed tesyreitively "Tt, ci" ar NU" cree estamated focaio os tt oof eae veloc dli. cleat ie epAedea, ok rrice agréecd ta se GaLld 27 Tee ma Mate re acd the roster oectciuedy the vehtole luc. Reeve, 7 TatiLsirt hose exuwple., ve to che F ¢:t wehicle weretaiom@. un ove: tneer, wescrircd as * 'Fe Vean= 1a" mndee "UN trl flat the Flot ot, lt, oma IE ye ,inds 24,3 ° ane under 'f' Se PL Mr Cae te rwthe Peet ofme iat To utes gas given 2O hur o-oo cran tose: at the cs7 parc wus ow aolng Erne Necessary work 9m tine von .1e av apa Remy feces ' Deltove Fat vie sion et frees Tamer chute Pease, Tos lt because ¢ 2 Soemwents feem or Vir lual ost emeitoone ld ansove 14 Neng Vong ester Sloven. w-7 acter er lla rhe cl es- 240 saci, eS to each, tin cure af ema b sorts eur rasp ondary to Sak amcedt my COD OT ce nearer (ee ere a Oe Peete. la Peg Meiey lovumenhi 8 ciatira too FR tomate Tea AN am pespec. of wha Pecember Lond, Cher. osip xy, on 4a00, Q 7-1es 7 ne Showind a poile We bad, oe, a cecard, anda Less grerafte elatti Teor peajgecting "Meo fae ceo BVIdere o Paese threo sehoelss 35 lhat LT fomwd hit sturey a5 Queen tu peanvinting: warle ob as, a0 doubt, aurts possible tuaqt a buyee or ovehitles from and averse a3 vendor weula obtain tae vende 2 8 Famace er tye cast if bectLaramy each verte ie co first lass tan. ther, on Mc Paarec = own eyidenrte the twta geven waa qatl > pies auale That iw ab le rao be inferred ltem nie atarenu it Tero peau pir amg tesrr oun Nong Fong ate very, Ve ov, orpencee 8. oe loi me. Tha be Tot age wd, Ce yr Rote To Le | oDarm gt "orpetig row mMucn Une care for sale", ft hou, 2 PR tnt bebe taat 20 ""veay, yery, sxvensive' Mong sent weteme 2 ved tae] Sts SB aay axactly, Simpl Ue tel ore suber tt Tl TRte vet 17> wttkea enmoue leat anonq@ fmt, +tetntly, Ueaiket. fnat the Hes Tena vyenive coald oave giver otuw avr mune Teale oe fT 1 the cast OF be ccoreartiom one. There FF sbeb Teaktars 2 oo ' Behabrt Jo owiten, Toomey meta, beaded ogy oul stag ampli tiune 3 Puro fe metoomece-sary le ae orc ia Fam our a 'ao:, fxare they ari un lesser apport ari 7 um Tronb a tk Peat te se te a at ose stage Lo admit, thal wen oasfzec ama far bared os Totmaas "Tt, TE and "b" ky tae 2 Pf vters, le J donot cay explanation advancaa to me. Turther, Muere was oviden- ehice T accept) that whem whe aiacy eeontaining Brovhir Townr bLom.red Mp Fearce wes releetont bo Give Lo ous An l Uppeabe a Pee ine ack Tf appears cnako oa so atlir Set of retes eomeeening money Bums assocrakbad wvibw wehacles Let Be Prot, agai, ace furd. sume get to oboun chre@ ¢ otuamas oper the laden Li be ebton on furthee war ere J tne dvFterencs Leta ct the Flos at ce. we d:fftculty oof aacisfacter, cee lonaty moowt fie oe Tomes ois hevahrerwe ober the Falt tha' Ta ouch ot ae ez orte othirve, Balt =, Fequre bLe-n che 7 thes pay "ao Bed ata ys This tot Pearce dave 4 2 bebas rep darshan, tale Tooth. thee raver li rhe fhard coltmr wae "re cupurtigueed, react ocr ark papain at. lie gas unahle Tl @xplain woy the - ele Phe Ld oa Luma asin = 4 degcribed as "ras" Flog, 3 wwe, Oo A gar sthor own -thee th- costs wer? bo) rl Bas ss rn Mey th tb aa a se pLrocminege "|. This ewrtry, tou 1 ae Vo Th ARP sab bo te Lr manmsie Fant with fue . - athe syspow Soars overated, cle moon hes "TP. aired ne tea Pee h Pye thevye vero to Li filrs, tat Tle Gh oe [ee a i oe cerfaedals, weoraes alo ci ate treulb tl os temagt he fhe tp tev etn the version divi responiernbls, ae tle thartebreiny oof the A Toa La WLI fs] maten to some Str. ius .zank- moun bors Peng Me piome and DPiicparert+. fac entangle, in "uch % thers ert eaentem Fo Corvetre, alu emds te VADem $l a FT agtye U MD rt red Ce "aPo UN Wath Rest asec, Pod tr ttt et re ha peepeet or a Ul. cel 8. STaLa., 27 2tw to deo wens shower a banccir Mask Boab ty imo ce rte oF al yur, Sor sb oa bas ware cokamn 15 ac Parnre rn hs ee Tatil atlime, .c, wmvspecteu an Maas Fond, @ larita "Tay adler: Chose flues madab co ARR Nut Toad eed Sate le eT mt er tenant MIPGELIAQ FS whe ve. Th Vatance tPF fer pepe Lt tes dae LPitatare. af fee Cages 5 Moo Te one CO Luar a cn Rosato) anl S aseposrbe various malts 6 Po weaehte yc ae AT, TU Pe ass nelieave 1t The os ary Fala hy tHe Feupee eoperaedoupe 1 17s Boing Geclveved that .omsiceranl>? Sunt, TE roycnerel]ly, 1 tole sree fo Bey tee VET TTR de te ete he saleib eo orditicn The Lette foow Ch Peace 2 oat bcc, oan bt Iu) rage The ne hs ere a) venicies. Of chee one lerr do ba Gey.atrh ay loam (oon, Lotus nu American, yol Mr Learce wetld turer Le thee, cm Sie ake, each required Fa heave Bere wm LS VOW hoe uF Up pre to a te peice, to bring 70 init saloabbe condocicn "ay thee, So liaye miro, matrer wh th din om. fat Ie opetatt a co 7ectsya1 af arog well vac that wp Enmibikt & he ' whe To rahe fla Gi ot Le veliweics had ao 'ruken winwscsier, toaat FF Fat us that the vwaondsecrecn wrerte cn UM slrebi a war cater EBay rs Yoog Preis Tu se2m2 sre tee sum obist Qe "eae prod wren ot tnat wehslle cas oulb Ske ere' of een eooabh, deer on atdaboein © orice. api tant the wioesc cea was retest dew Because The ve iets oe ir Le Oe ee gm ome. conan ed Ss ok LL TRoooas oo remter dec oa ptm bo oor soe yp Piet thac hoy mracweses of séatth ura o81tt ce toe ahem bt oe ee uwriblavtul, rat qurtewatics urcttemtd ev timer om, les 2sG +t it15 fo "tainted" and cuit mer Boost adage: tiigm ami tha. ne documents sululd .]2 be tecurctet, bvowmwalune wroeoa thro Tell oe SUBMISSIONS, Lio is Necessery TSO Feb Lr Te Teh take oat te Customs off tcers wt iivesetastbang the mifler pL By Teer, GM TPs oho vat ion dnftormation relaroua to waea, "FALL e- fiom Horg hang. Thal print oul was, ace the respeutents, grovaced From ergulracs AND T'S wu Pope wee 6 anak] olaperte re. sho avraale¢ te Le bringing cars un af comask bar lew FoLte to ha be sdertilisk JE- amperbance ln bye pensent cise was tuk, ATCO, aieg te thie evidence, It was The yitiai Founder lim cl the imv-:utystiucn, 7s far ay The applieoet 7 ae] wenete tad Se Getper Soe the apedacaays c.atliegw Tue! fue eeint watt, tomsidertd vi toe beak cf the &eidenoc diven an rel alae ty , ould mob nav2 vin rp othe On-ta : 23NS2 TC Reh again st tne applicants. "2. made RR w.avhar our our. ae tems ot Lt, fr oT 'chich was Trab it fae Wa rbeal crcinaer 2s antic t rea bl shee what was te SCcr1PoO. eo Bt fb avce ee T- Le tre! wea "dcr .nate" Tor each vehicle mentrics om el. Lome omeap then boo tre aasag yg te jealoain deta wih Tee Pas Comm be dt aris of anf othe watlecztal ae tise meg The soup Puasvicr Tou.ve@ eure te Filcge oviceys hadicetrn given the Vastioms hy toe aye. s. al ft, Lt CcUll net Alo ue A Ab. ee Mant lol rok A lotwit sGtr Ube s.2kk, whien sayt meviird apt euapi tut The Mw. omr ci battre med opeat at Mi7 2f442 WV: av css bu arv Geate otvallree, ta Siprert out line inf agma Lom. tt sey abe cS an a! en oemat ee oct too Mas atrodar Foc aat Ty Late a lk ate ra che reir comur ole rad Gc aracle . hea Para ae Lpvawteo peoacbatl ds eo Voz tens ay Clete 2 Gok to motor vebrciez iamperbedo oy them sacce) purchase berirte? chat t Q were under-stated"., The wunfurratiaon ti swore undies g.514 af tne eel To thal Mp Vooper was aetormam ura rm orbe ou tece FRO pm Lae Tt was oentat.ucd oa cwearpo wit oar oars py oem we Ne we e-a lieet reasonable cauie fs ee Teeter. we naticnwe whal the cecticm sis. The oct maar must cimnah Frm eli ce Sweating tnart acs s hay ces UVewritt. sept bed wr whato -2s fhe alleratior 2.8. 'vn ae MTR, oe Leeer ra clas tide, mereivy a watbter ti tn> mode uo Capeoeseion uniawfully amperted wy br- app daeaaco, oa alleg -1en Tere ote 1. 99sen, the intecm occa vas vats that 1, at was neces. a,y Teak the Ucllectoe te given sileemation ci sal Tee aecavimr av brat eeneltvton T wave been te iitiecs ie teomatterea. 2 otaor obee tb) Say hue ote ote semi tel be ag 2S 4st ovartaancs, "te? eto State} cmmidsarcei 7 upon clings repuresd se todo ap rie Ioib-rte. peedace ait eet ove." a tat documents. There 2ioa brocsor and it centemplatet riat iG rs oe G27 7 Cavs ban tyniawrully percr bad, timdto maine ah, tah eer Tie gaity ha? with snall be cperified. Tia: slapper coe baw hae only - yu-pataive allegavisr eboueibe ont tutta tab a Le "oo Lave wll da ard tnrat a mers general ofiominl a, la vcxer fteons, saliouct Secondiy, I am oyelaimesca Dy the Lem yn roual al censequepres oF the orife mitaen may bo, Toe tet Lhaver, bathe onerous and dtascte. Tr the emu, tre anfie)ema gon nay ba the basis of a fereas oe' |chay oy Custou., aittcers "ato oanmy Same ar - day of signet" to enasle onem ora Lock fos dacumonic., Hwevie, Lo agave al lorem ea oe basis foe cha goctacr abiwn, To ostsby ca.) 1h wha areeare to me ta be its Lateral om Ghl .tcaien. Poem omsr cuerpo, TL, abo F 2 Taw ines bed 1 7) fase toa validity of late. sheer, Sr toe bec es a wracumudl ona, cequirement in "orm oo? woud. Toy. ot led chat ot ey snoulid have shabed tue wit ot i. Sebago retro baer, bre a ly ror. Tua oapostes To me cs Taacel tee te oF eal lity Pie relevant ragrlatics a: Mo. oe? 2 whee ecaae a. ta) iuws "Natice to prod. Macuae nts art. c7 2.214 ore che "urteme Act LOe) Teta shall be cr. soncernings the ert i acy of cebo tan AL oomelianee wirkh the ve pub vk dees nec rence Lhe foe tT 1 Br zacints To ist ec Nae h tyre ENR, FT them ob cera oc ab dee f, oan to ooverloon thee ehlt son ro Tare the het bere eegquicnrer: wa tae welovary. seed rua Rta let Lom Fle mesaee enough: Lf ie nw ecer Fesbla utarc cic Lifraratc oy macc 7 de: che agode ad wet tT led. 77 fb 5 aA gemre loo "Lleraica -F tae, erate the plilt oot cniecth Pie Liar rb 2 otabe Par roy se ot ue rad Taye oemby moars oF ides abe abate plyeres dost TAR Bt ey an? LAG, ln my VLev. a3 257° ral ee ee Oe Me TEtavy CT mont. uae What pretieton ce FAahe mo-d Le stare a, or fe ta c1a-- vhetre 25 encush 3 -'3 7S clates betectrn which rls event? conplatned eccurr]d; € loavt Fo ac qoenciar tide de ftsiwes Thal Cae .eqerreteat ss 290 Moan CL och ch zssued, Bar svetedly ain ce wade ay A TL, See Lack wt yportiferabrer oF tre dvbe., ar. bormbs be mR dee eased mm A vlad looser ater Pho evavdenc? some that Cu tact Priests, a. ube lates of bre 3s T14 oarfs matron t have wepkjcied, cided 2] anpilc nto te search "ur adoeuments cro oo duly PI7b, the orfic ot invalved ava oulynia, me {hese ortivrers three went ts S remoo Soria Fwo (house lash named) worl ot9 the aprpltiaats hash. Mla 3 arg cantemplated By s 2)4 1s That vuer ap aint lrmabeonm un wes tina 117 heen Givon, ami the To bleeta, uas meas Aor leper er eh oun ecw that 23 fo de served oop tin mwaer fodo.t de gets rok corrly 2 oan OT. lece GA eldine A warrant oon aint r ae —4 ~ - Ack omar rayls Tt tioua J Lo mud? an legaisdatar 2 tit orch ormtend thal tee erase at cee tee ise dowel ome "Qt preeorPame sy oo bat or be Sa cat roes, Fare Free "ammecliabeiy" does net arent ercl. mut ia! Tree lames tuaet te tustars, For yaa on Rhas cy 2 ta che ucat owt loan tase words a! May fake some Sista bames ote beooatiomele the welevarns doe uments. Soe of TFr ab yw ot ade lt toe iirely to ue rassen-d opp the vasaeresc Lies catavact fecme "> 2 have sainted out. Fart ol wiles me provirian fal wfeytuticacien in the qoods, except by + Lo bre aatloo or unl albedatrby alleg -. Since the requctemont on Porm €1 inclune. che Wuedang over of all Books and ascumlnhr eslacuna 1 nea tee suhe ast allegation, one could Bive wMtadhe thar Peye soc lima en Cf oul roquaremond mignt rave a fiaht ho ok req. in yaestien are, sur rs sank ttap. we alsa 'howe ee, That 4a dogressias, Vna gurant loo taat the veut tr wanes Clot me ny at gatekie a. EeSTLA1 2 , Lo bare ry ead ee Cee re ee | croco-Szaminabyies oF che Susrcms OFep oy. that car uplasact a were met sungce cea Te Cho obrov dork Frabate nah mob nmawels Sect as wt Fae Cerri oo etn Oe cs by oan CPR. LL y wT Dap hae te Hh ablacth- pete e@ tr be qire. his tMpressiov Ta ass tc Gen ct tase besa mn 2 ost uae umiatled kiacm te rear che ah 2h doy. Ma FM oat te ecagende 7 daceint, wid tne lteme Wr folde 7. can .v aut 1 Lb: waerant uate 27 a ae pe eye Loaf falluce Ee Le tr Me officers are wenl tee c2- Lar! Bnd 7 LL pede Luere a ccmairev-en? whith oon ary veev wa: inerroeltrvs, aol being "hh OE aie cr a r w = al y Be itpa fi ~ Be a a a o <i a fc Gq n ~ ancressca 2 = These at vent tu Lhe appliacancs cremsgc3 cureneél Phere ung obtained aonainber cf tnt applicen Lo tes mers, acd oy wick acc referrcen 6 wus wh S esas alee Fe Th Dl oo ba atat to cotain "Eis femc tros ca via petepaya rt tee r204 regilramert ues, a an Ceo A OT Thar ho ectnere ce wl on geud, wecwiss 7- = dei, mire. Poqe, aoe. Pevm clo oc lccag, foe relevant ore ilk om tt wl ber owt Doe ey be FD ate fb ee ae WlLeOw the Dat "PQ. Cue 7 - 7 "Sobre | TL hd toe Te Te Nevertheless, wide Poe ata 7 eb ge ak Far Mire ee rel some Lear a a res On oth a es Ori! subseyuenct, - om tore eat of Teh eta ato hal ges consiageradsl: upc tance, pee trculriy ve cee et ratncta Te sabre paymence oar otm- wrel vart roa Tet re | ne i to the Custaems, ard oud ano bbl owrrct bi eplican' awotr cc od - Tonubeeuod riots, Te tne true peice. On TP 7 ats "a7 3d ee tvaal Tp att oT ' oP yile, Theos hook alsa 7 ens Kw obocoums wifact+s ai Mr oectres G2 biol ote: i ois ra oo ee wT am Laat co rtaslta pal. 7 "Lett eet ane Quer 7 Thoope foo tp bar t (ue > 1 aU ee 2S amd thet wb Foe ee SIM LV Tecaws ee are tne TQ och tree event ob ma iedat efie. 0, For be ua ft rs es erie ee TU te Fate de ew ast ae en Fa va gel to the Belsoane eo tate price VLeL a Gab ec. bow Deter ae re vohioles Todo nee Phot o2e mo r2shae7 La cr aut che lovaile shat Those List' em itecned; tusor Lupo ear cc 1s € or One oacic Jute? 27 Tule 7594 ere M0. me cteoned uboso. AB Lhal ven ge Veet. Cle ler pars 7b Toma p ua, BQ exercised oytoan tnaemurty ve oooh oP bee aye ticuatas. sail! regy1 ce sontenbt cr the Acts Interprerv ia ASE, lpistte Erovision 13 in the "alloc na - bows che Lamers C an fhe Livdbas ss Jt is clear eneuan fhe ata At Vet oa" foepth Pant, aa the 1s whether they had to. seceum Tedlas Poe Customs cays inat grads art rereeaq unde: 3 J95 tnere must be served a ninticze in vet ind: Temp udoubairyhug cae qucis, (bh) statirg that wne gorge have Lega heated Hee oy. LO ana sme7liytms oie 2 aso for Phe seitarc: ie SGCting ouc tne TSsrmo 7 the ora .silims Ssno- 2.08), (a) specifying, ani serring «ar the addperi of, AD ACP ope lara melo aid statang teat any notre umdrt sab a. woo Fe vyisren to thar Ror gen ¢ Acte Toteeren tation fork BLT bt aks Lay. Terbunal, boas uy gece Mande FoF Al probe 21 Lor Uh; The fttsirs .a8 10 eM ry ate hy 7 wt, TR an action. Counsel curtha, Fevyres cia, morc. gE waco tt Fel wes were allewal oon tl toad orkat tt oval i met omer alnbe boo tar e.79T(2, wnt feuds as Tolliew OL ary In my view it etest ram talliil ao teeth avec erapta. nt They were tarreitn mods, thay vers alse cea tishis Loiiew cota be 30, 1n the lLiget oof the Turekest uit bball sable aa come ante informitin On D4 Tate Lleae there apoltcantc, timer, zelicito Meee, adel Sat heml Fare oc. re purpose of the intervie > wee TO Se OMA TD oaece kek. an a columns hearea "7, "Tham. TD. es oe a Ss ae Tave tne cypLant. LeU sti t 7 Was wo 7 romp, rime J revo Lu ras fhe figire gs rer le hie as the bene eh WD Tea TC ee tu put th. ventebe 27 GuiGhil lh Ste aba eV teet aor. Ce Lee ek ergdew chat rm Uist oat 'Ho a Ce) Wulawluliy rtqusrcd at wers tu bee Te Fed the caonrcary The Yun sere yn rol a ce apolicat on G. sew bee oi Phe vores ah pote e haute. thors Me De abc aa-weetd a eet7 at Ss ee cnr s EVITEUs CO persuade cae leet. chan fl. veeties Fes- Lay amporctea, rat bea. ar tm etasyvel trac ot So oreb ges bl ou offeuce Yn dhol ecrat bau, ened serene abo tlie bo 28 or My Carlin, oor po ae Pllc tffleer , Tmt tale mutes vehicier:, the Tlier.cou, sae Vublass cud 'tne oovalis ir '> affiaavit Mo Peqecc ct halwea thar. "NS pf casing 7 Moye releate vb there veniucige aid 2 teow Bp ce uc dt Rhe statevent, wade by me a. ton, rasiule Form tits '4, 'loo, 2 argued that "~p Turv'u asked te, tle siar curt Mo BS amo, <tles Fy M LURTLP 2 aw ct len, aecordance vilen the surry-ctun cf if), Voorger, tiuat Me Curfaun ruily recained has suspleicns wart Eespeltkh ote the ima lato trot three vehicles im -ysaestirin roweyer crear mar be, Me beau ce signed a statement ac ecm se ad, fantivnrar 'the accurate oF rnc above particulars" ard statin wme: "Foe Que Sect Ace SKUs and accurate surevhase price . true rr tla tase, Vere tpesneden di Ee acgua ifyar out au noovemig ee arose ry Paagg ret fran mu 'douvle-rayment' Fas agen cad". Loy faeiw, tim oh el amp war false but To oar clt stiusf eed ea. 1. mist 1 Cll oa rin. Mie FeSULT OL 1ts cPiag ctl. ber, howe ee, ote othe ure TANI vehielec were cle rad. tie a a oS July 1os4 [ee ue Faboer cs lio Emar .t wise. 3zed re7 ee avuer En? headit ay ""e.tarvet" LS eS eS SO Yo Le Customs sree ra Pea, ane whoa tang puyeri oa. show -te md ts wontabln d2.atle af enyicias teoaane shh? an peepee oF ythirtes apart Fr Masti, Ol 3 a Pr? OF aT Oe sek Gob what megun fe enilec foe mame coat, ere ocremeakle gover APA ceue® wert TF A stam e UF moron vw Lites rus ouae et Le. rhe applicant? toom Oe wav 'ot oa rv 42 for rhe Ligne jeans Lt nat documer spe Mee aes teh Pe heey Loot citastived Phat wb ase. wk TG, Age Tat eee Vb tla oa ac Me core S21sel8t By ier srqsmors eo po tia oo. tec, tee. ehh 6a Porpfrac) val was vue toh Se rool a a rise cE Toes nat Lersuc it boo owstum s, wet mitaas areec ft Vola Tow Che a2 ob Lc yeliclet wig lroa w2ema.v.le7 megcbt oy Bray WNL oye Co oeevs wally riken away. TE waco st yooh St awe ih Steer Cad Enact Tate oboe bo so? eKoirt Ol which he souks bec. adeeonte pe, mut Po oo4 moat crit vol ty Fa As the wCurcharmy 2c 83, oe 7 al a7 Rh > Tes Gg om the infertatpen ana Pera TL, Yea ot ear ra Pett, 3 hor bate Toat tae searcues and Feria es AP vlotmlcl wie. oull h Tiuamte. Counsei fa, the appliearts cvet Flo- Vel Eo tage ae Tout Sart os ects. bho svar ch 3 ut tht 7 -. tu. 27 Me Poor oy co gaerle ¢ 1 'he omy ae ane | eit, fg Lastoms Beewioe falpe or else oete toil sy Tmt wal tig oe one of the pessoas me that me wil ats tea Lecomte, FO. ack wey, hy anskher rongiasratacei, mantiy "hat be trauogle das be fo chaise we 5 et Oe ae ied ee a OL Tut 2 ti tatada eine ob tas a 7b ion? appear fom 'ary fa elect eo witlh aan, nhecr mertaiyc. "OE T LT to Mp Deable, whoo tr ae ri er pel aS bo oe ak he saa a Warr wnt, Mr Bat? Cate war omc reid sor Fhaz Orn same occasion, "eo east, ws OfLerod cae the ott acess booms heme, where the deciuments tec, vers relay wre leva Wan he attenced ato the stir. ol Lhe alie Ga ot ST om oor wud, "a Fea Fad, oe Tara Rb late Th det fee L Frnowant wee togmrilt gather Chat onad ceen un. drawer in earerciny U5 tui ineident, tatu 'arsic.conally mp llaen. les 7olubhvetred Purtne ccument? which ere missei oy your oe ers" ana Fo Thane ra wert ""volunteeréd' 13 avails The wort also applies to Mr Pearce 5 actions at bis huure mek tals 1984 who. te Gaye stbstantsal as3zistam 2 ta Fh afro. fs . tle Peates waac 1t clear bhar nt nalno ocycthien 1 vets HSMN pete as at Lhe bank. Whee Ms Wynne, who tad hoo ott shy en FD Ot tan fanding cf A rsa se cm tle tact cz ™ rears. to at least arpear fo help as tee al tessisie. itorer ll. lis, -b was arquen, in lus basis of authcerteeas waaen Torhet. mentacr, thar chere wis at Frue corseie, Cases rreod in kebait aiothe apmilteanes sag esr mnik, even where the wccumie. af the pret cert tne subqecc ca the gearehs has mo objeetatyp co ik, tam 32.90m 30 arn amaver Fo an allegation that the scarin was ailegal, ceovids a bo at the parr s3 were unaer thi vam ef con Fiat 2 was ro" tng. 2, tarbeot autserity suggest aig thar "Fo osalb Lisi ole ome Gearr. lt ot fe ue. no inauceid EY an ouppechens1rm hie hale 7 Surg teu eat sive e132 te a tspilzien oF ematl, crs @ Li 87 omar Leia Penne y MPL, with whem tho stnie omeivers 7 the Ton * cf Crheel agra ce said ip his cudemenco oad Ghonpov. fetes Te 1 0.5 bo odoee pe OS - modbsce 8 ume pascepert anl lerta> Me Lene ted ronseat This Tne emphasis 15 added cv nwe-. " 2 eb OD mao MAY weed [Somyrsrtlace ic Mus vr fo a TOV line Pas scqnie Ti thal Le 5s arocvk: ue Ught." Ope mig' op duce ceem tac: stetulcnmzel. 71 Pee. Tam kon binding conieme The prrssam oats el ta have vem om oo oa tinder tne inp re@sobet toa. foe TBAlun as ne Oe carried ome witouser oomogar. fuer . ~ may tc deve Vv. feres thar if ot ere st oa cc eect ta tta.. * Fro. 2 Thvir cvs ONG IN auvTlorl 7. wovlvarea bya lesare 7 oT ee fia ho batt ap ming even Wooauoacrtts, the for tsuk ar pepo.luart forts that hak OG. am cle. Tos tase Tired ab og 1 jack TT Same ccxem lt récts char, vases Sa ee TEVEN In aeretel undet oh be wil Fhe aud Mvlude ar udadewccaydirg erties oth Cie tonmrent maarr cc dene owned the pee 7 Phat o"uis fa given by of "Nn oe determining witht cher Wab Sueeh oo ou arofes sat Fb tee requirements <7 rthhoocLre ves "hata 2 wey wall wave fe Mabe To a8 47h tiene ta me way 22 kl mae leat, ft vias hatota Comoent maou me be. le erst Beton mgt ml oatal ta yc ad tla the perso the foyer th oh Pres acouparely "iowa dom. rights of Tusto FP discike am ota abre cue ff ciressane, ar Cal 7. held. Tha' Ars ky of wt sk wit ead cll leiden ue sabttoti-a. ff, Pacha, Fatman ur ae rstare ing, a Pertun weep ct 135 propos.ad to sealur -akss the weelant ac 2@ad amt .ip vais aeriLety to aetis oo, ue ho be ay getkbeeniooocr wuldiet oi wiv wan, then TF tend 2 ee Fac las tomse ms etna mooescdavily be uLer tur ded. 7. Ti pb Oe OULe appoat st 7 i heon siacen oth sar =. TL may ef] a uml abe That the viata oc. ore wha TENAVeS Ln oi STO CO 2 cc dagsrisned, wear -ie writh ¢ rer lr tat 15 Nide a onstructive, yer To uoanak on tie whole, Fin' ibe Bearte did, navina the authorrey er . verte, abr 3 a Prue cenrtent. ot. ab oe Hecadoe, de i a ees Le ee ne ao 0 titerasts Lo waive Tar%r1.ui-s ana Fs Wake 4 srorp oo co operabkion. tain lee Cocument >: whoeh reveal -a me te oe arn rte av if nme saw Fit, of unre rmars "nr "asteags orticers lier he Pcie; ia theiy sea chimgy He rd omit di oca stlohnzr moa ote bayer forth came 7 ob 22 cult when they eociccel. NTSCrr Tam veluctant, eno vo clo rc Late a conserhto oon rhe races oe ' - .easche- C2 tol Sltyucee OF Garis £9, bl cedPoes ly bat tee th ua tr tine ere 1S a distretlon FO Salt rede y Lh the ape oye Ti ois, however, necessary bay ae a Pov tw bee tts tCirstiv, tier is ng Guest ron of the rank' s haete gs Soc ap oume 2o1 ea. astacer, Me Waters, made Jt clea ooo on. aceon thac Lt dad mor evaneaac cn penalf of tine back ard rerucei fa mara evap aa Locument = until ne received are erroreousis a. S have utia, ta vblrae wt | my _ ' ~ ac So. sr 5 sel ys -- =n er Le ae he rogl, Sree Weld Chl Liebe ro he some teom Fre hantl vas uectrpaceio owecr sich wt Tiesality a. ots gastary Lele Team of . "Vides L TPT sn. Ip as-4, , eTseg7 Llc t che wveder tim ye ta mo ys Lama y Fett tarabs. Theor. 1l Subsocaneia autmeoraty bop the veew cat dip Vit Civds. JAR F, ae Acre t pan ce ote? pevlevar.e cycuane + a7 oF exressively proctuaicial "xiud, oF evitderce impree iy obLasnid. , ' ' c ea sor And Raye) : ' + Tr v.G.R. LS, leoss oon Doaudendes cind Sus etl t ma eed. Tc appears rem Stocarleth ve De admission "Was irposed upon teed iv Slane lous "4 Mor duress, he wlll mob be Pourd be it! Tical @ces om rence, however, etooLte imitisGn er tt green of any Soratmtp ub bOvautal fl keen ar as of sha cot ent 3, ce. the gr werd thas Te yo soba. ly clrcumstances waking rine wltlss1on oie te rr. Both che Ancteissan worl tut tide ecee ee Kt sete copy tone wet jw ouegyi, ality ou! wh i" Valo sau fa TS et dat ob Devan = Flas .é eon tne qecumad that of aes. oth eect ly mr ced " ta on extreme 2am le wooone 0 Grefprals Te pelyevo that oir cick proceedings there cole be to dboere be Leelee, bt pele JCOuNAS, aM] selena chracnat violence ch U7 38als of ' ldlence Trott Caste, 3 ofr tlles bai extractea the dacuseccr tlen Mr Pearres fy tet catciutna t Divesr Ram, um Deraar tee ams Ui Lae Qoeaterit . Lela g adarchcd Therd 1s, delpa7vs ine Of Cath wey ot Bagier dd ob wot reiaa Lappe ana lea sreave, Theres must sauce ff Le a d -s ia on ed to exclude tach eriteria aos Tree Pomme at te Cleag Wh coteide rat beams Fo ote ben, oc 8 eb oe Loa Te ta pavourable ca the tarmescouun ou. Sa ae a Or a a a Cavib malicers than an crivlnal ma tore "ad eb) ee pe 2d oT oe served an tue Foruer mis be te vial tr mer outdo tn. ner a peosecutien ccutliy has ro leasr ett oer loll edule factticr However, 2t ternot sr ocnefas. to the wat atenbs tl sect oa admisson cf (19 ct 1denoe, assumed to rl ouniawiilily s.ccane dl, a.. fF trey BLOM aLecrerticn 3. i a OD Applying those tetty aur liso. of ti. appaacauts, loam vlege.ir Lf the view that tae trscrects snout] be eve, alec auphapraple i. cette 438, Teeth The rererred, are mentren don the alevrsens of the Veg Mourn on Bunning v. (1lyB2) S57 ALT.dI.P. OLE. Aickir Jd. toint out that: ' ache ote arerrpriace Fa teeat atcide, Gti reu-ccmpliance wink. as §'Oa0inNe "oO inadmissintiyes when oc. thers very d a aa = Te rt eEM Tn Cleland 3.brs ou. fue De Re. ee rated ab pli? thar tree ny hoy. mO og etal orudes hat The tart rn 2 ree me dagen ty vileyally -rtairnei a, the lork aes, che bey. Gat .onfesoiwal evidenie for bonis raason so! ome i7 : us, Murphy 7. theugnt that "Dvieeroe aotatte sy nbewrul co umprie. ¢ conduct should be LIMosk aueonab. calls Seedy aor Fe tTALE ae winet Offences, Fut gtheswrre a wena 2 Fo. Phe owasc ravice- erimes." Reith Deans 3. anu Davser Jo, ak Lic ad tacie Henours Srpmatesan AR 1 for cer at oem in Sasa OE ervcluding ¢@.1iinte mlewuliyv Tat ot ee Ter et uneocuradinyg sich tornagact ome felminy ots save out. Dobe 12 unlawful eciduct, as aaa ob Fhe Lari, na oyaite bo .ave cetcoe rd above, e@nfoccing Tac peciterticn 7 dor ents araer Alar ee ' ' - Tinn-@EiTStenk mimoud let , TIRES, oe re hoes carr © peor yt " derree of careélessnes. ain faijing ts ene sta "a amen powers truly aid exist. Tre rehlevank foweb sy abn 4 Dowel, watt all yespact th the oceafosmin, bo BF oetntadee a. Too at ts carelessiay draw. omrcovitiams, Fo: eiamrys, these as a elaign sick or correspondanzie batuern the oF urations arpused oho tn. owrer by s.el3(]) and the p2i:ynts at che Cuscoms under s.tit sid. fh 1s tame surprising that attempts on the pork al 2 Musto, coffers be enforce such crovascaons should be riddied witl a}reqatarities but on tne whole 1 am oatisfied that they aid net conecicusiv beeak Che law of conseisusly aemarna Enan they theughnt che law entitled then 22 It dots r7t apreac vO m€ A soaid eters Bo oce Alger can co ituclude the evidencs, ain those circumstancer, despite the irad¢tisnal reluctatce of courts tu permit Searches aud 3artuess Wang ayord Tne sre act requirements ef statute meee Counsel fur tne aprlicant= strengly ctged upom m= tue view that, as t> tht three venteles cleated om 2° Coly 19ti, awh dm consequence of the signing Ff Phe shatcmer > os 2b Tui al rR if) Le) tspu rt above, 1b must ne acealLad cia been paid. Mr Curtin aave evidence Ehoar he acttp. 22 'he statement given rv Mr ceaeee Chott the seascica cert ccerer ay valued Fut Cam por persuaded taah thar re 39; formal wreprana there wav have Leon, sui at dzer rot apeeae So owe Likely cnat % Curtin was rpthary wopyvinces. which v'.2 a° J have heia La further ain view of fhe statement ceenwe ier degsire ta help Mr to me quite unlik convinced, Vouwisel tugg-sten that gcc. paca ines She vennor - 1f they ars .Lear wl by "usrome, abo ote ws af orl fas rete 22 noe procured by wrorer ssernratior. 7 band that the O. comet crus rs who decidei 72 cicar the three vehtoies per osuanme ote bbe decviaratron aooy Mr rroarce om lo Tuay thea titi hi cught thar che vehitlur hud veen unlawfully aaportey. Tr vas sent char. sn those tircumelareces, Tre vy. Bar (977 ALO, O30 1p auarecA a coneiusieon in favycuy cf the apeticants. Thr resparlents ¢9 that appeal had bean convicted of Pek ge 2eoughe mess the Ussies hanadom Customs ound Peer ie Act oof brnewitady ued oth pitlent ro defraud dealing wit fe Etaln ot sds The (suse ct Err. , cn C48 around lon unansmousiy Pela them pot tt be ogectt Mand hoe although duty haw been charged on A sai which wat oniv a fraction of the value, cuat iad gooveb ed wervhen Vy Td see ES sen Tt dees not appear, Towever, Chat The 1 undayion or tle deec.licr in the Tan case was cletppsl ah aie, ve ot came ty a Gemcecrauct ion wat of the Englieh statute, Loam cy me mena temper ed ona, tides the Australian Act, Tloarance nas trat .inal effearck which Law's case attributes «cs sleararce 'uve tts Pnolboan Fab. ho r Fartucular, there uptears tO se oe pruvil2an 2 Enziant correspending with o.i6lo, to wrien fie Toone. very properly drew attention, ara which ' e.mics A cevilw T4 Geterrmon.! .on?t C7 tite within Le months in the Aus*ral A.L.T.R. 2272, on which ct lianee 13 placed, which asi ists the applicants towards 2 finding oT cotupper. Te ois tocrerb., ve ercunseh slbmitted, trail we was the duty of the Custors is deterning une vaz.e and advise i: Tener s 1lolC. That did mat occuc beet aid sl yedannable eects Ter tnat failure, on the parc of the When the applicants sulucitors sent in reply suudvesting shat further omypurstes ver' being wits overseas but, as LT faryl, Customs weer mliroiy fabcer paveuy ceL ue all the vernrel2; 19 questiun! acteng Sausevely, 1 to theley that anactiet was the pett coa.ee. Vhere tTheual. have yercn a determination of value anil aiv1ca Lo counsel, Wever.reless, reo as a tar aren trom chat to not whet the clearam 2 a tae three veblcle mst 1G Pe AM solGbpee, determinatian sf vyal.2 cannvt, in aercrai, be qer,awec, flat 43 tnapplicable in tunis veuntoy bicaus of =.261b. Tn cter ws Tan 3 case lays down any be Arcguei Ca ASSitsi cho appuaicants. a ) a ALGTS3tanle Preeruse bt expressly apwlies nly {oO anstancet on which the areor been achieved witneut the maxing of Tule stalemen* » a5 19 valuc TRANSPER OF UWTERS ir There was seme debate as tr tne legal ecfecc of securrance of furfiaiture under 5.779. un the ciundinvs Tf haves made, the gocds vere unlawfully imported within the weaning of s.229¢1)(a) and they were also guts in cespect of which falce representations had becn made, within tne meaning They are thus forfeitid to tne Crown. It was argued Fs only effect was that an the otcurrectce of rppeupreate prewteariys ownership would pass. Tha rTrk 2 at an the for 1f 3.,27% 18 elf -rreturting, iv aoems te vreeide w. comrte answer to ali the cumplaints apout eirurs of vehicles. amd Tar detention, the ainswer oelng ctlar WEY CL eu md 2 detained by or on behalf of teeir pro sent ownek, one Cecven. In Fyonen ve. G Tonner vurccr act... 25 May igit. Noecheo J. remarked cthat: "Those pecwv1e i ons the 2 part oa sc ownership Joo operation cha court aorler." Has Hoanouk Nahe > (1959) 1O2 1 .T.P ge ab p.dS3 an hich Watto 7J., as To ead his aonvur s bemeer wa, Let open the question «xhether 3 228 transfers wemerchip to the c_cw immediately on *h2 otcurrence vf sucn a Il uation us 1s tw mw 9¢1 ali 3. Corm3ssic J. also reference ~tS own ial c Te. subject of 165 Provisions. The besalt oan that the umocrter whose tax affalrs wer? Mm istuo was WIeie bo clain deeresiarrod under the Income y.omroateeemint wice Rats J., I would ve content te despite tne fact that counsel contrary view. The matter a5 warrant some urzref explanation. Te Le mh e1es that fT am cound mv the decision of tus Pull High Court Burton vo Homan ¢15f2) OF c.L.R, 64 nro helu 'hat urlawtull, aaportea goade are, boy The very fect of tnere winlawful iumpertation, fosfeirter ta the Crown - 1.6@. vested in tne Crctw forthwith. action for damaves prought by a SUL Chaets car which hal been selzcd as forfeitesn oie slant re the provisions of the Customs Act. The defendant denied the lesality of the seizure and ultimately the matter was yeferred to the Full Hist Court. There the defendant arguia that there was an automatic forfeiture withcut the necessitv of sny Lucther proceedings and that the cead, was unconst1butional, Upposing counsel subrission as fu the Fime at which forfeiture sccur: under the Customs her, 35 consideratian was nar . TE was nevertuelsss considered by Dixon C o., with whose pudyment oualj the obucr me wees cf tne cr Court agreed: "On authe:2ty Lt 1s 4 at 3.2249, peovided tr forrezrtur3, th that vmler tive preavisions aeToS Le at tis TuUstliy a acudgs weFtsS Jn Lhe q Crown wher kez5 place in consequenc: o ct the Facts. No further ¢rc. a "4s uo mare citie, althougsn «|L heeuellinys may be nevecsa Y "Lf title of the Urawr Ob Pooenelude tho craim ow some EtYs0n Qea@etiry a ragki to the goous" ww.i7s). T agree (with resocctl: with the vie. of Putn Jd 1a che Bort Needham case 'suprad that the ctaramere 7 have Wwetea F2 nov merely a odictum, ae biz Homes por el oc, hve vetevant provisien cr the Custems Art was rcaud waitin 'sith che aperatioyn as there stated" Pyar if the temark- of "Savon Cl "Pe TOL part of the ratio, Io owevid, or course, be very celuctant to wgnoce the unanimous, and deliterately cupretsad, view of the Full High Court as to the operation of 2.729. To should adi that tne awendnmenes to Ene Act sance 1952 do not appear to me to affect the matter in question. Cong derataicans of conve nicne:, and indeed Timp le justice, weigh aqgainst une constr ketlanm or 9.22901) laid Jown in Purton v. Aonara ('.sover; these Tartiurt wee,t, wovwever, "aken unta aceeunt in the discuosien oof The cotnt ay Dixon C.d., especially at pp.i78-1a5. Ztocras oargm.zd Ly Ae Crenes oon nehalit of tnt applicants tnat, cones cCuratad by Cuasicna, omportel mods part into the commian stitk, suc detcco to oteare To 5 Thcot veey arg ament was plainly reyecfer in Darccu v. T thee for > oasli that L passed until the swnersmip cf The owner shir. Counsel for whe applica ats co uptarmed oi the oc een son ef decuments allesall; optained. Uluwevet, Ch) agplisarr nov se an wreder fur che eecuknm oF ary focument st reel that 15 because the orients ars Fe te way at 2) te ana ¢ peoceedings. 2 oofeve poracad, hey wor. eae 2 2 2 bors wave, aecording 190 the vidence, betaine dtd copi 3 al uation cuba documeaits whith hoe .e merusre oF CG wlt i 1 ute, roact why that has oeeurre), oof oovitusls sucn oirades "hot be hand. bo the applicant. we Ac wilt m7 'incings, These reasers rely 1a substantial part upon the ve ac.tr of tie eviernce of My and ov published reasons to. dering sa mnelui 1 daireortiar evidence the subgect further consitercseatiun Tne aaratos. vl the 2tnvsstbibo ow oer thos evidence on 'he applicants' cinim tor a Je lracation, urscussd aLove. To otave, an vertlectlon, delided that oF shoaulbt ue Che evidgent2 im question om "he ciarp fos aeoclaratacy e2.1et - to pur that more fuliv, ot 'the questica hetero cle vehicies were ve Fact imported aim creach wl tre aet, ay pecald ve VELLCN whethe> the Custome peasanibiy mheught sep. Or biel rma rer taking that course apnpeat in ¢asr' woo fhe qrbaclociten adtgment of 24 Tune la8-. In widltionm. Fooms. Pent > Aeeradt frat "* 39. there appears to ke ro eersen whatever ts doubi. the accuracy vf 24a by that a7 kW G. Hume: ayidence which 1% Vitzgatrick's nck, andced, was any uttempt mad- ee cholledde Ticvzpat-1cr 3 assertions 45 to what observed Gn Hong Wwonds either DY evidence or crvse-exar appears whey mtn 22speet ta any 12sue 15 yetree 3 boo WET TS saad that the deriat perfused. iL nave given conpiderat-«n t5 the ques declaration nyould Le nade im 2 contrary Auees amor a ag the pesponaents.- Nore Was saugnt Hawevec, Por Goee rhe making of such 4 declaration aepeae tS be mecosaary Leani siede erp latte are aT ZT sumnarise the (ad bye anformant mush (hb) A vequiremert in [orm 6] 18 snvalid unjiess 1t sets out the date of the matter conplaincesd of. us me * cr i oO o) c a Q . La i) > "3 rh cr bet a Cut ag fe se1zure of yards need not comply with 4, 'Mere Le 2 discecetizn even in civil LYUcSOa in ge ty s2dmit, or tec eycludc, cf previsjians of tne Cycecms is Mhe casarance of gx9g13 yu Customs officers does not, im general, czrsate an erloppel as te tac valuo oof imported goods, at jeast where there nas been a False pretence with respect to their purchase price. &. Terfeiture under 5.224 ol the Custcms Act cccuce by vperation ci th: Acc, chere being no necessity for A Court order to aun eve In the cesnit, FT Lstd rhav the applisrants ure noe enéitled toe any of the relief "hey s-oK and the avplication wil the history = the matter, I will 'near counsel on costs. Poh ee th cs dre 2 fpr by 7a ate cle re be oe t poe ag payer bs bl wgur Wir Sat te PF ycas tae r at f- /s 7 AEWCl S