Trade Practices - Misleading or deceptive conduct - "ts Restoration of classic car on 'do and chargs' basis - Zstinate a n a) oI an Oo fs] cr ia) of cost furnished by respondent to applicant - 0 embark upon restoration project induced by estimate - Actual restoration cost exceeding value af vehicle - Recoverability of moneys paid for work terformed to date. Trade Practicas Act 1974 53.52, 82, 87. a NSW G.197 of 1984 RONALD ADAMS v CLASSIC AUTOCRAFT (AUSTPALTR) PTY LIMITED Webcow 7. IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF ANSTRALTIA IA SOUTH WALES DISTNICT REGIStpy n waren PE a a I~ Pre)A Fh ro) 1D co th GENERAL DIVISION Tr, BEENWSEN: RONALD ADAMS es ew Anplican ' AND: CLASSIC AUTOCRAFT (AUSTRALTA) PTY LIMITED Resvondent CORAM: WILCOX J. DATE: 15 AUGUST 15385 PLACE: SYDNEY MINUTE OF ORDER THE COUT OFDERS THAT: 1. Judgment be entered in favour cf the apolicant agsinst made, and delivery taken, hy the applicamc the said motor vehicle and sach and every usable art thereof, whether original cr whether purchased by the ressendant on hehalf of the applicant For use in such The cross-claim be dismissed. The yvespondent pay to the apelicant his costs of th at ay ceedings. pr is) AND THE COURT DIRECTS | That the exhibits be handed out at the expiration of 21 days unless in the meantime a Notice cf Appeal shall have been filed. Settlement ard entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 ¥ Federal Couct Rules. 6 La : fees TERERSL OOUTT OF AUST oS" ~ i ,"TE FRETA ATES DLs Tey Pea rare . "a. FPR? (F754. WTR ESTOS ' SEYUTEN: ROHSLD APG ANTE CLASSIC AUTRCRAPT (ALSTRALIA)D FPY Neepor der. COW IMS WILEOK 4. "iE: 33 §UGUST LIPS TREADS SYDNEY WEseote POR Tit tMR = ai res aorat 5 1966-1907 Beru 398 SE raupe motor tar. f vehicle Wien tPF Foltegin tart. & - me ryooatg Ms [RTS EMD wh Loe ot - E LeateAcy ote TBs - ee ry owslue wits The fas "ef Sows rare the oar fem = y - oe .4N IaTIeoFr cian aw ut oft Tayi. 2 SB Csr ate rf wp 224. "eo bee har N.neetio roe. oye TB CET eee TE L, Le gfecepved by bath value af the tee Lak an VLE er condition but there ma the aaier.or -Tiive ancrunagemeal s oF the two wen ned same Toca Olaes20 Auboesat- Cau wmren TTBS! ar ou He yeare "es a ere oscar 4 AF f° ugar' Appl sreny . - Es reyes Tar uchieving 8 ver : we Oy Garry oe 27 SS4LS row its) ct consideration given wae snouk 87,900. srice, Reo ocar roy Adalside ic tne none ci St Hubert's Island meses tay Woy an 1 7 Cost o-c nr Fast Lee -~- deceldeo +2 2 advica sha tole ty faret tlass @o.dzssso7. Tr SUT e4enputlis sore Aro ete anaPe - < nat = % 2 4ptcrpifi inom several aura = ' etoile 7 - "4 zoel Jaa. et er lt FB... ZaBSLE Tate. ba - glandard 22 3 Sugeeet ot thas 2 - ' 1 * = - 's @dams and Ar bs: coor + ar o$2 the grswises 2° "Lede.c Auterpaf.- toe 2aes afl reteliie Sots yleeirgse dsbe of thie avant Buy sto was gromsils in lute January i982, They met lis Stapher Suite. OE 9S marsgans al Clasaie AuLocrseft. M2 Suite sneaetted ite vehinis, Tiare 14 ~ dispute between the parties 35 ti the entest or whe inspection. The taree men had a conversstran 38 2a result of which the vehicle was laft with the respondent to ke restoran. The terms of 'that caonmversetich 328 an dispuce. 4~ AdaMS yhleaes ist elass condition would mat form camtrack to da thal Tor that grice. Fe 'hat Taft the vahicls waite Anco reegaiudecs om bre berets chat savh eculi be sesfeorwec cn 2 'ae ard of asee? ne 23ys that ite Sepeceenzsteo- eongbityted pisiesting G> ieczriive TM Dats aventasn ef s.73 of tha To Ss 45h Ha BG SB¥E Lat toe reoresentaticon LO WSRIMUM Tost was meae maglicenviy ceoty 26 toe gliternsiiva. supe Tir ore "LSS yhatlacta "i the. hs Pagers oa 31-,290;, an ate cro Pisute sy gra, agacritinsie. tts -pepar dest cei Bat Tpumtiaiy a kava whe task ot oe . tSe cribicel Iueeric- TS' wd FIs 32 re 4 ee - oot bes Siva Abe ve7Ss10on reSviG wey YF stil -siure wa hts im Cue Sours, "% 3S Toman aroun weal, at 4 Luleirsl prep yiss Mr Adams 3 ko forward ta ficoacrafl t4@ fay cl $2,000 each wanth en feeoiuni of 4ne sast of Ing uth. ¥r Sulis" says that the monthly. paynents were ta be made at edvanee, Fe makirg ~t sigsser iret worry tould te cnagracsed anti @eges payment mad obser expended ara thse! week would then ae any time to berminate the arrangement by taking &%ne csp away, "4p Adame denies Eat ' Lo a8 wade 27 BIVaMnCE « He save thet be merely sgreel ta send $25,990 month. - a : Ta tS fever wore oot car eperced oan gitlsnoe Tl beins mage. HED.T0G instaire aie 19R2. Bu List iias, fo gob. FISS Loc Thess credit to l4 0 Rarlri LASD shen ice sa Sn oo made. Ns pavrent was cp Mey Fab 4,009 0. readora To Jara Ifo, Wo iP pla wiat cua ae ie Pe vol bee, . . aro oprsae "5 Ung latie. tere: sc ' eragty 22 vb, F5l.50 serms arrcre Ti eabed Bs 27 by Fa that, wher thee Tune to B gerriu of Tm oat saet ita oe 27 CET LTE. 25 0 Noe ot o 'uring chese month: sc that, even sccerdins ta ihe srilt uncarrected ledger, crere wes bLhean 2 suall credit walancs. Tne August payment brought the catel emount whith fac paid to $14,000. Mr Adams said snstoim dune 2982 he hac visited Clsesic Avtecrait an company wilh Hr Lee. They spate the wWornehop an = according te rir 4dame -- was much metier anformes Lhanm hameal? on technical matters, had 3 long ! ' ' 5 taleur uf tne car. Agcoarding Lo mir Adams, Sy POUT That tra ig Wes beine gared by Classis Autoorstt soeeity che 1% WAG CBP 4S to ES regulsatea, Fowrstlnc sfyar wha Sune Vigth, on Mr Adams' Varsicn, TR mopiretes avy blue ane stiver, aga Ther geben te 2t3hi an art tag el oy colau- er. Tnere 22 3 ta flit. in tte am 974 ovr a7 re Ceptember visit but 25 26 leis inet, s2 his 'nawlescs, ohe a. J2E stril amtonsletle; mmdeed, toe cet Be haf Et. U2 SE5 sarditicr. wrei Peace, art wae. bL2,000 sd 5 Seo, Gala, UT -GEME corctmle mr 8 Ll ouom lei - &- GAYMENtS« Sukaer 7% tTeceiesd Four mare cigh cS t2.000. rerorctively ro 1962, 75 Deleber I9f7, Th Noventer 1982 and A Jonvary 1923. Mr Adaus ,47G 2m evidescc 4b. & af t'e paymento, like theee before treat werk wes va He boak Turthes dets2] 23s usually aivan, althoush thers 2s sone OCleputs 2 ta eter'. Mp Agen s ales Vass he WES aiven several assurances thal the car would be fanished by Coragbmes anc chet, on the strenctlh these planned nas holidays in Tstusry upon tha basis "se the car. . . cor7 Boanl werut Sme Lit saab rol "cody. Me appe@er ote VE poe i ath the. time fut Se aad errrzsk diseattetsction seme Laue 67 "4e8 Jandery or a@ssly i¢52. tr : Sutin weoye him = letltiar FAYE ln ef a "13000 Pee sue. Loe shee stbustion: "or Saug LT pSesparee "5 7t wet}aged itelo une pes 22 vol Pacreret ame tas: te Dnt st oF ihe poste cr -> wr wiesk qegorlben ote vere aghich mad ssen dane smd rectarrvad ta ne Aeat LO Ge tala Pa Gy ge ea yh Lema wee tf jaya ul nk mu at 7] My bry Va bow us { & hes g rene ar fa Loely corsden, pointed sui ta fPh 2Par1s QPester on of 'et wrth = cr wese resiartzr 2 seactlio Plocr and ave maesemh panels have been dard total 1S under primar. ° c As Par as mechanics] ucrk 25 canceerned, 3.1 the susrenesi.on ctomberants that needed reolscing, 38 well ss 3 totel stris, ced plete and regzint where secessary, 21) srmyensnis tg1c) are peesently cesdy For peactibttics, The molor smd gearho-' as 88 yet untouched end uc are waiting on your instructions regardins whISs ered. Tee cert step, should vow wieh be TOnLinne, would be te decade on eclaur, srg psini ihe body geclrons necessary ta the refitting ef TI Suspensian assemblies, loom, smd engin assembiilies 1f you are wishing to leave 1 in Ph's prasent sonditian,? Bri a fT « PL i nad -<T us aes =r -27 => ~~ s . -- a - Srarét, rf gr the sicel.r. ie ar asta: -f "SB lst =F 7+ 25 lleee goth 3 sawed a a --s3- 3s wie -- - 4 > srr 2 = ' gos tose . r EL SO4qUTI BL am sctleses lta tee, - Cok aes _ a - WVlevl te cakaes geem the Cougar' suatpely, tm UNS kl he hag bGocome wnvwolvea tio ihe rerminmg ol tre fas .cei- lnztaglily ne camPined fis acti sities te financial ane a matkbarcs bub by early 1993 ne appears 25 have Laver Over Teepomsiartivy Cor the guctevisron cf eB rumtiar 3f the restoration jobs on 4and. Mr Goodare sarees that ne .a5 = "J wa L rary i wi eo mod tasne Or the convaeny 8% this meebirga Mr Adams said that he complained .o Mr Goodare about che Party that toe warl wes nob eompletec rotustending Lagi (sh Get .eta 22,306. ne lel He "Sgofdare thet Me aqucbed o4e plus $6,000 3f tne molor moeded to ne come us. 4 teld m Suocare, We Says, tos. wf the cases "al bees, sires woe thse Se would aot heve Pad the work gone ap eft the car wach Dlacriozt fubtecraft. Mp acswe seh ae nut nmomey vit Ww : A * 2 i a i - wv wi x fa I> TT {4 u rd = a Bil i I ri ia] " ~ 1 = J ? rd . iat . w a7 vt Set Ge & Ht . Th os ot L ra fa DY ci ry tot al m cc 3 ba] gi > my mot ~ a3 wt od rm rT mu my bal Rr mow a . me ny = t g Lo wim ti L in m1 - ty ed | el oel wt I hl 2 a Au lore om ha = tt 7 rh ae at me ul rt FY J ie m " tC. 1 4 mR a a bas rs c J ua " u bs u bd te at et ard [a m - fl fur TG +" = = " a° tw. Q Lh at aq far n wt uF . Pu aa A nt vr "r i tr Ms * = en Lal) a tr rl m a c wt toa et Ga ' u 4 w el - ort o moles Ea W 73 oY . rt = vl an c m tt a os " nm I i] a a nm i WW " u a = + & i at , ia] it) i m td en m at si Ag, oH iy uA uw aa wt wn "a + J tu 4 a av "4 wt ot oO wi Cc Ww im . Ra = ut 5 % ia su Wy a ut m rt m Tr = a thy iad aq el ~' a rt at fe a fag L a m i Pe iu a5 Coal tl - ta Ba wt ue at rt aa aL "t wey Hy ify at ~-* at ~ an w ao o ot w ci ut 7 1 ct 1" Fa g = » fr = be > wu va = w Ww a ae et il Wi e r-1 u i) u ir =z o a a) v a ct u An rl tt rao oa wu ou c aM a Q uo , La DF rt m vt 3D a wi Pay u i o In Wot ry > ah mw Eo mn o [An a bal to wv us " cy ", " Feoaes cube c ci a 73 = L im We ni tr a Ww 7 he uw > Bet wl au ba ia] ao cl a by os u or r Gr et Me may Ct ty £ c ar Lad) c " a i a awh un ho. oy Oa oo gc Q iu) a 1 ig mo 4 a ° = - ae Lat te bd a em ar = a Ce az ae 7 ia] t ze Ev) - . Wi te te int ra di Kc Lis ut im rey Fug 1 mn oat wv tH > -' . 3 > wo ad _ " iL m "4 . o ve uc u a' i] 5 ty c roe a ay fit : a mot th "1 be a - et moO ey be oOo > 4 » et Pott . Pot ors w i i fea wh ot e u ue ca uv mn ce & wu - ae = Cy 4" ny a i om BH a Di) aw ry a a Ea im at ~ teruracy of Pre gsatkliin's WOOT THES EyErerese fe a a eo a Le a nm Cc A % ra] Pia n o. icr a Tg al un " ay i? wy the css Mr Jackianm s ub a few weeks before the hearing. gzid that he did mot thank thas ¢@ ee —~ 'a -3nh erperég ir Tacehe venucls a per z ac = =," we ae ee "elms - ad = Hane, Sree gt srs Rely -a4eu if lat PROVING he vehicle eircet. ral BS oF COmar rat Se eovaluae eft deooe From Ww ry at rd ch t i ut ut rr 1s i Le "ut HL 1p be pa ie] i) ou so ae 4 ' 1 bash, sou SS D439 berar gees Pisersec ~= : a4" oA 4 = sara typed wedier amt saray pernte> wha worked 2 bane? testo "nich tine he oad evpestanie mn tre t = c, sant cr ol al -ae\ Ma 2b - restoration of saorts wares, ClyuSSlLc Talis. fe ine4 nas carried an that occupation 26 his oun business for the 1isl 5 years. T formec the apirien bhet "re Turne- nianiy experienced and . Se was sleec very faic, being reaty tao concede "2g iunsbalsty to mare aenurzina ay ib cards fept by Classic futocraft ain relation to Mr Adams' vehicle the letter of & 1992 ziemistra ine were pe.ierned. FTrow *oss ¢curces re ai a work wich ha estimaced Fan meed@c ta be par as4 . br PE Pespdadert's crevisegs, tat 15 = smelowaork vsy te be 2B ev, ain "Nese grocesedines. an . wed 2B -beszs cf port, atetiv bests the rar6iecl sae Tegricaacabk af lar gcr.s cf the sehicle, gee aware S135 => PPine 34 or the old agsmr amid the regprayi us af the varisis. 'hs tiicutated Lact clade acelc aavelee TEST pours a2 Taber. lz val the i ay 202 29: cnn -- a pane a or i ws 'sido ristes t2 Me afece -- ani rocthe? necessary te add che cost of vepsirang ans further dente cor rusts of which he was mot aware -- he was nol seare of sny damage of rust to the interior stricture -- and sisc ine cost af replscing interior trius 2nd « Tm relstian te the replecement 32 aots te gssured that alt r meeeesary parts would te available company; he made ma sllawarce fer bhe Labour involve sn Fabricating paris, suzth as body penels, on tite, He said Liat to make up panels dies have to be pressed "and the cost atpit}d sue. pur away evortataaed.*. fie wat. ten €landard of fair lah ahie t me har seas 225 aT Re visit £8 expected anos Laxaiiyv eds bugsa Ne tas wnt sctegy Shc guch = atandised would be lees than wpas toeprigrzate lor : a eton " Tne "ames FlLllb ea my Ar Tacs es Jom tts src ise Lens were, he se.e, FTE". BOT € ir gne ise : ST4hougn oo corallenca was made 'S "Pe Tupner's gecera' . evperpiance on te mig iniegeraty, tre rc¢epcnsent oid 22523 7 The lL Ato "outs, FE ter - &fA 2 ois tri f. 3 s toot wv ut at ul et oa ' L ' Hom 7} mut - . unvealved .%4 PEstering = 2 "y ut uf @-ner ge 9ech Wil esses Lhe resyondert elicsied aS Mr Turner conceded at bhe begimnang, he feat made sa allowance for internal rust because ne did mot vynoaw of ary. He alan conteded the Lhe scme Pim C2ua?* which tagy te: various 2teae in Hie rq which gal zle 3 a es iibel. Lo be required. tose wale, tt $24 nar "zur, woutd tarsi ele,i?? ar Labour costs, ('To this Fissure wcald mave ic ws matearszlg ena parte. woo DSPL MOE Ilse 4 zt et Bye Slo arvey 2s bnec wre ET .2Paawus a.ete ehsep mp Turnar fed bead wiecle to Pstiwsaie Tuy chery ara exqmifaserit dilferences in ef aime: Fo- aSnrr ome yen a3 wede at, attrmable., Altrsnes 2 aaseere treet cw fr: Mr Turner 's fosures me, be Pow. Vogw Fi Froar riinetie* ia - BEM Ssc ads tte a ant BL om@ 312 won iO in gndacation of the sort of time ar toe sort of epersticies . + thal are actually anvolved'. He said thst ii wes '2 sample only? of the total work; he gave mo indication of what ver', atner than that ancluced in ghee list, fad been sone o> woulc be requires to be come fefore the job was completed. Looking at tne list, end a Ww uw mearimg am mand thet at iy weny Er] c mm cL " be ut = c a rity I pany m rh my i a iD nt ul dismantles and al} rust © oO wi uy wy fod ax wi ~ wl = ce o =r rt a Lit Ke in what may be miszaing feom it or even wee lasted ooose.7 ceretisvut st Flewt i°? Pals eo bhe paole, thea us Ta guesses: woz fue titil ea: enwired arti te eaour1 1350 . #orrrdscs ip ote umeure bo the lette- of & Pebruary CO4 naurs |. "gen epee oO Car3 Euy tris 1 Ls zl : Loe work oe@ded ta cape with the rust troluci7e tne aapLfeciure o7 verrons tec, penmeis. It saz % fe-agsseninle af bag velo ary" . fut vad ) @! 124 per Roger, 590 hours lsbour would gecguret amly Fe, $U0,207 of 22 no 720,300 scet aueted in tue dct? er cf a} ekruncy 1783, Pr Galan claims ti hae .ipsedy ey csadec 27, TARAS tad Eth aud. Fh the 1S + "24 15 16 fBzay wy Sulis' recent "estrmates" ave more to calculation and with the' opinion that figure, although toa low an estimate a i faat nome suiadames 43 to the labour cast uhisn s estimator wreht have atbribulsd to the rms pectran, dreds Fro ate nee et He oetused + ty tts sists snorily meferea tre heaping. He ta1a tnat Shoeeugtte arte the lesd Leaht eae 'sow Ger te betlem?™. lo arapere. 3 tilane AL Sun Blt cF tee permet WOT hod teen done on the vengele ue to whe lte Jigb -- which unzluces the wibine us sf re ruslLed goriiens oP eyo urd tk + + totais pee Panr, SP, GUC. He lo te onie + t ty LL nm on et "tt a ' rh C i ey, o ") a ia "7 4.3. m4 arte 2 ac INE! we yee atl ~ oaeseps val a Me rT Ay we ~ i 'a lure uy- ly imE ch "+ d tk W leern musongsed, T wuss favourably impressed with ihe evidence of Ar Rays He has tad conmerderable experience an carrying gue mar ir <ul mt oh Ww < aT Lal "S a 3 We me 22 RANE ailawad Limel 1a tesrect ct mi davbilll susas. Mr Eaves = roa f Headley, & esant so of 8 fray 5° fosfoved. has 'ied e@lstitic care. MF Bo TY ant = thd 1. Sor 4° gua ar tha Soars sc ow tlia| 2nVadved wy rans Leis man . Whe spetide "ust tanec ard oti tig pec lire ot Feenpe of tray its PU Le evide- ca 13 gay what.) was. trapested the Venitle =) the srearste = Last oP the pristine mated Lhe oumhzer of hours © oat aoa Soupe: 25 524 gar regard to independent axperil va Tn tee ras Have. Re Beagle sr i ' Of t.2 ~saserah)}a - QQMPE, FF lacter a* 2 Febuuar Tiiawl TD repit. af the -figr at reira grmicezl wast ayvalved a, tne -leee Bot ~MSGL re hou a, ule, gdeirg tegethe> tne Be ti nat wf 2oMs Mere.e., 2. douls sapeas tye: Be ia 2 Linh 3D Fis Ba, Zine 12 te a fo S24 moues cli floTe mm ote f I98F, St S24 fer Sour, le + -- eo $10,956, The job esrds relsling i Were gel arbo Byiseaie Intl Aten a ne Weev amd the fours said ta hsve beer 3 Vo a Sornabion 1g a1ver 32 otc the actyal oucc Have been pesfarned, ine work sheets upon which 43 VATILOUS wor' men te paar a0 nave recorded a2 bl sh thro wtr: sesforsse 22 ttect ls "Pix Cody and panei?l Tt ss Lmpoesinls 3ar Pred = ~ ° wt ooek = | rd —— - ae conmt.der le. from che ect cards sme worl she ' LBo MaT ley GM Mans Henin If -aE geassl of une > "Ser opurpant gobs. by s pasty ta the arieeedin - ~ + -t re =) fs, "ws Ts el = , -F fife TEerirs oe ee "328 Fret 1b «ss =F Sfmt Pint ote ae tt fp at ms tt u ka fa rt wee 2c sugsestian is teli-founted, there want 'Ook. Weigle either vton ¢ a a a w WG ut rae w o i rk o cy ~ fe) c "i wi ~ wwby Q a Ht cl 7 ave rer relation to hours worked. I Pe ul mn in the af the Lhe Lsbour done or 2 D Metorkeotorn cine mt. "abtwitrstenciss, by = ras T nH at so for two ressans, wnispe@ftted rlst ar danage -- upae The Lireliveac oval tr F4ios -3uld Pas GS 8 ev 2. Doewt Four Fle 7a far bomywtre grid iets. Serandle. wf w4e c3° ur shoutd te neached *rat ime noupher oF Sours ece wo @2 thet «hash See so fer been game 2 aarrvecly Tomer tire 16a rmuamker in tion so wnoich eR ed by cur ae 2 toiz fase wus effecc- mys tezdrt is peieatisr ts ce -¢ roa Loe oc: - re ee a ae ref wden Mie Gf54 bo ihe ee 32408 20 OF mipweene tt ty vas Drak tse and "a ose yere ¢ - Lhreushow: te tshang 4 Leaerng Pole ar guards tast s2111 and wcrc nee py = le be Fes - to beak = NOre Specis but that the car was certainly mob in any st 'Seat ats cri vorth gotta. Tress was furt> sp "iseLeitioe betagern fr Lee erm Ms Julss. ue Sadan euetlrer 1s seit Bai: Loe ite t af rescare tse venisle to Farsr olses teanzttiar SLs tae aniy av Posst class ucrb* e.a he rricowlet.aets an pr ares adacteens te fie off. sr ooftueds TlowO@ula Selig PR fr fBpe.ss 12 0 SOS Dt DE GO, sale fac the 2 ' 1 Pe comple. - . EL! Legs. eu re bossaaynm beth that ate Pe tnuestor cub that dose rst on we H 4422 we. oat. tl bre sy Stems tke toss ae te ae lay; ni tu ee Hw Bey r ot the -bonne, uw mn "a ti Fk ve n tar) Le -! Toth end a weerust Braund the sed t4aspecticn ste of repair saeSac ogi Las wet i os TEDREIG Lf wen < fame 2am . : ce arr 4 Bab Buea. ee tis - Bie, eneessza, za Pre thes wire , a a Me c racalci fr ots + . - ore . -~ 7 ~ 32 - woloer, af Sy Were mereieany, sod he seebred burt cf GMs Cm ire 5 ta te Fuily ree wk - itp Ded. ore axcege oF $4,000, Mr 7 aal toat prices, me Leib' iat with ihe recterz.ian Todd mos Luy agevss thet would be as mice 35 thas for sroumd tnet price, hoo 633d? "Rather than tuy s Helden or scmething like this fos 470,000 I feel that T would be peepared to speni un te $40,000 cn thie car and than T sould bney To wcuid have 3 rmiee@ yericle", bub me = thet Ge wOulTd diccese soe war ar with his wi2e and let Mr Sulis vraw in a feu devs. Hs ther is = = enguired how lang the job weuls already 3 quate fram anothers firs, whieh aqugied about the same figure bist would mot give a time to da che job. Ke 32 l1io73 7 , -bth *3 petanstsd sie ta sighs riae 7S sn 7 im ary weil 3 Tasietets, Tress as "a & Sornvete eto: abacy toe Sod bye fe near » Me &4gams ssid that thev were sr une tee gad 2g hut Souss. 2 Paw days ap back te the wertehap end ielt 2 OD, "r "Ziate fr 45205 Bereet tos. oe oF Jooker te Mr Suits om tue ter Pas St vise wo Loe '2 Gen FERL Thovas con ay Last Int ars Lite canversetsc: he tp Ee mz. ont pry aR ay mR trol eB 4 gm Lf ihe repRtt oct "lane. 7 aa ue ano og eeatansbly Pre. este af geosrese" and that he rpeetagsd (tet this 23s his antention, Me Adags sqreed Linas he had fad during the eqye@ec that Mr ugor an "ourly rales aod Wiat thts was because ef ira wubures of *he work whith wae involved- Ye gare thet toe rl w4iq tar ra i o m oo w a ce 4c i b " fo] or > ! i am ic a ok a Q mm) El a. ® n fe me W ¥ danied that Mr Sulis Ped saad: *My cnoly guarantee 1s inat adiftece> Prim teat oof Mp Sda.e tm feyvarsel respecte. Wea rF woes difterssces eMC TS SQNeANnuIAl Ta Dell atce .us Olaee! noon tre Pact thil Mr C7 LB INF te Taster eatet ess leat, at , WT Eee Lewin es oe Fe TH wane tar: for 2 2 2 orc - Bl) SStaMaLET Tet 253s "se bo fe sul mite ire rer vey oF fo Pull versrer, 17 4.5 &ftt zee Ho Liss art asvad 4m ult PIU 1s STi 42 SET Ll ps whe "ah Lb 1713 seivinr fiiks 7Frre0 tlese¢ Soped ag aopounbmernt.« sort af wort nenbaoaned & After worl , H iste} odvwork, reverence money asked ham 'the sort of ceemuelng th. Yr Fat ete 7 oe BUDS TENE ST 8 LD eige 1 pout at zh oan s2be*, Mo Sul2zs sBig ha nado wuly 3 "tuv gary Voareg we ttt at tu = w ct rr Ly ed he . [ea cr "y . al oe ~ uw youn 36 2 Sour Mere San ad be rt - - * - a rxuire of ane ak wis Ur] se] wai on <u ip -] eot - + did not 4242 42 E for ubich Sse caomgany would sarry x! at gk > rt ft te Ng we y ut a a gi n Ue a ta . figret wu Oo iit further amended Ststement of Clair filed during th ck % if]mabt i ta CT1] yehicle at Lhat tame, the reasonable cosy of mw rR] oa ef the vettele ¢ e. Tur Ris wc. led fe hap vo otarg tha race siinin he Fortetice: fete tae 8 - sos and om : eA 4 tf "won me mena Tamr.ted » GF A Lsawies 4 SO Avb.F. T40 esreer . 729. The apniiesrt pz esde = UGE . whee Bat ty - te ke eee eet et met og P ~RIS TE 2d, 2MBl 6s 20 Le 8 eM. Oo wOl- ioe "ote 73sh 92 wes mcrs that sroaocg SG 280 21a I fila: 7, WT EU Ieiets bhe sense af specifying = prees ba bay rv] Lt mous 5 = - trae aoe i - tole Woo ourese . ' ed LZ : - TE aS ' a - z am i --, - mali =~ 3 ef jstacon 7 poziiism., If cose ws vsiz 42 —, ~ - on =7 i- =a 6 that, upon toe reorande it's oage, iS fs grogerct. at <= Zz _Wl - ya r H rt) ey i psesanzule emgunt g«cseden 422,000 for $20,000 - te? =f ray agplicant does emocotce bro taal : yoo such 3 gross discrepancy mares at much more ds have besn given in the farst place, Lherefore, 25 content ta put the matter upon & br peaspeabls coset oF tae work ls ther ow. fnB- ge-aeel flt Tee tar frl - --+ . — : "tr ~ 4 -b-a - Ps Di-5 9 OLE BO LPAPMIe VTaws 21.7 . ' - F Ls. sn fic omg: Peye Tate LSE oGins3 larde> Lie P ut Th TIGR VLA, Oo eo - ac leooanmg €3,7 i "3 ster wT ott ot, Tut ate ee fe 3 Bar 2.3 Barn! 8 Sue VLA FS x In a GS x RR yon 7 Ingo eye ee ; eo SU4 > iT i ' ok 2 TEMe ete ide tre ae tc z Jowt 27 CF -) : me Comr laws or. Saac- ay oa: . ee Cea ee ere " — 4 TITDry, i% 2E € thet wr Adams tise ee % -- ctr epee —_ 7 - coe 3 - ad L rktene Sure wernt ets raek. Mr GlLtlLE 83 ¥ . ptals os: | o me tr rw ee nw 7 Mr 4icane vaead Ter um ft 0 @ LNktin fe - nonvercalre sn. Ag. Mp oO cowl mol voer g2ve an Lact bets contrary, he referred t m Te Sulis' own Foecount. Fr - = . ehig ' q rt L prem.1eas rn wie Leliaf ¢ "wt es seeps aoe ae ose oa ran }TLee wnepeetiar. LE 28 Nr wes uh c Mm ct guest rost ee ot "A . Tt be argecisiali, fis F't - LT Sto cut Wye set fez uoic) pes catty cP rt ae best aie oii: PLant we ac gre@zt 52 F4P,000. Suer = Laplies am a> omsL ce hr Adaws, wtb amiezel Burenasa price. 2? eTiyeeo: and bhis far 2 venzcie wract M> Gat' lan tras Nout be vor ws ne wars vor 424,¢ 1 Beet gccinds Uo Mr Sata: Se ewahitiie. Tal7y RoLS . - ete BPD, TBA 4l0 00%, Thre tae e Fatt owe Ti2tt sal inal peanuts Pe upte ihe reetasalrgy al tt Wars Tata . war Voormaype "ova 4s, Paerhest they m9 9 deiilLiriee|l. rack rae | ena aa 2S2Re ofete rrbo ost "x Dales a der ae m fa ry rt . et -2 ne a a3 HE ut fe 7 47 ak "1 cal "7 rm tr tr Po re HT) an © a ay it w ri m a at fr im] fs + Tl n fhe x al at d wu tyig re Qf rt te = a ru Sal m a u as rt a 1 c 1 ri <I" c ar) m 4m "a ea at a £ & it G m fe Le] mr pea a? m << fH on a a Ga a aM wi wi ranas Ps a "4 a ra ' La Al cn . cy 7 tay ut us 4 - wh ws ay Mn va ast 7 we - Jt ua "1 uw ee ra "1 ws AL ' 1 bs - " x at um et at 1 m . St mW ae com uu "4 7 rl at wa Lt u iy uf uw ae rt ey " wl Lap] ht , w! *be ur ' = Fy a " rl vit Pa a < 4a an mm ry "1 nm u J oe at rc ~ wt = a Fl a be ir al nas at nm rou -a e ia] on g rn r al iL La te f of the tikely total cost. Far $47,000, af course, tost rate sitter nen "ould nave beer sony szout treat s-aresa eo omiid at atres serve 1G it estimate, an 3 range and axpressiy diselsiming #2 farm orice, the " mnge terns 2 sum whach -- st tre egses- rate -~- woud O33 ursnis 2 maximum cf 7 to Ld months, danending upon i whe extent of mechanical work required. Although 1t is now Qleer tpat a Figures of $14,009 for 620,600) was an gees zstin of terror TT SD TR rirt 27 ive ~ roa ~4 - - ~+ - a -- 2 is mu Te|e eis ct 17? TS Tees F eit) ogee bed - = heqan cat! i2yar 27 : ~~ - _—- a o- - = Pe "~ - Dv eR4e7 Gest osrat 4 z Peutup, | aml Wer Fi Fobrusrty 1983, Sy that L202 PS 'ret cara 9,779 acre fan Upe haches: fieucee in tYe sileadd c eimre 2° 4F trem thal ne job wae suatl irprcurlete, Tio wns - His Ereument sf a gawerful sme. Tt 73s caused mec to mesitate im seceating the sapplivcant's evidence. Hs zourse of conduc. use sdd. 1t would bhaeve oser Itercz. fer Mr Adams to have slowed his payments, and camplaing2 24 an Parlier sta9e; one would Fave Lhought that he would mot have gore shove $29.000, Buz, whatever nis eapzeity tn , 2 cED a°fsi.s, lo 7ave Sarced tie yobt tri toe wii lieen. 4 .ffees 09Cn Fame Fc sastete Bc 2 st x" w2lfeornticenc> ahen it tpt panarabicn. Th Seas 25 Prob ees .ofermadc spen the lesan a) ple owerm Vr bes eho «ss met > SVE BP Ite *PsBl sl tk wetter ot *demet Wet oneserea. bo serene zh sac "eat isete is. - eseocr den! ty cave eucsedea tne 33° Re. Doom oar 4 anounk represertirg te oret afl meu mans snie iS, outa are gsmal omterepebavcenm oF pts Fer avitenct, AY wlalec teaser edo a Ste! bret be2e arab alto re mato: iF le v | es)l ' ne SB. pomlioiay way TENE povirttioe ac 27 gy ititae PeyYSlilL aaa gee FL Pewee ir] ot Se oP Seti Arse roc Blom eeeted Babe Oui Ie PEPLAPr sera malts ao. FS 245.50 . thace ee! hye Pase ene to m@ an harest pester, He 3s boer Fhuste hes Pase aod Tou ' £ t . © « . 7 . 3 to ~e ' y gol Lassa' anst ae would have tet. re 2 eae eee Pras pete key, soathouwt farsh abisinang frem Ne Suiis 4q0™ understanding of the Jabely totsl cost. 4nd had ne heer ro. _ Lee oT et Dothaink thet "Mp Lae -- whoa Fo ipa. inclinad t a al =e aleo te be an honest wiirnges, but wach ar yiowledagatie ta bys ares -- Raye Gaer cre. a repair the omissian. Notwyaithstandang inn Acums' = ~Ee - i LyG ik a bheneviour, tT am ssitizfieg that an e¢ BRS Sive' ia mislead mz ote stave ' SE CELA aml tl cast Ite 172 pargnss of mebirg & - ot whe her LoS ahear's ero vpel., Jamero och Bisewmetances Tas hor is furnieh- even imnaecentt,. 3 eot~yablr wePicm wis 225 y lon Was to angeee LF COMMEr os. on ci tog "", = -aeR Tat fe , ev¥inence te met scseib 's b> oe orecs vied ut Yar' umes 7 mrs 4 "s wyees - = same - - ifs. 1B wel. t SEL zy t - : - Le | * tert Dot 7 Veg 7 To ooave 6c gars teres oat SS elisa TI Dw ti odale city Viowae Tisures, The Lowy tio dale, 5 - nae 32 Flt, "G0. BSaraciei . no ze abou: P16,7% cfirmecg atl t Ol ue ntab 2 One mlrae, FY the godywar' os tl seagcmaole eB svterr af vac 3 Cn ae necessary ucrk, was of the order of $20,060, Buy tae nrecase Figure 4 matter; it 16 cleerliy "ell Brave a Lh] m mw rh we @ ut * "UE = ueir ral i y in c rary w In " ah + By = ut > H t it'a x oY v t es rm a oo Pal "ou at ain of Mr-Adame to embark upon restorsilian, The claim o ere rengy VVLt 7 :"a ut n a] < a r wv ts mm rm " ia Ti "Gi "3 mw n% wh in re ve atw "cals vat c AL, oe nf 08 wea 2 ue : wi EO we Srerey Ee Va 7 rege cme money February 1 . . ~ 20% ath m2. gd ae Bea o£ t at uw el 2amapee - "eS Las 4. etiata : tate. a at Lity far Ret she LFOoCl aN x eed nol so Taicant S525 appear. TiBims a7 ,7E Ps - - cci.e rl - Brune rismentlad candisiac, He Se? 20k) cf Sire eet wots "IGS BT FR eG fr2lotlaen. chai. rf &2 UDR. woh rt ade fo ott -* Tat Adams arte ss 7a gall ero%. Shirase 7 ato olL: awe Te "7B itr. ocie ary ney Ay Ween a i) m to15 proper to allow the ful vi wn c ctc c ee myst Jagu Pa) aw c a s Lu] accuralel L 2st may na thant i 2cle. veh Lhe uv an mn UU ' fo ed wi u mw cel ba ail ite if wt of m a r onduck ce ' Blewe oem va " Se L . cl i . we 7 . i r? _ 1 Lay ron ' mv J " le cv mw , 2 i ! fa it ' a rr - fu ! a' ' Did 4 a ™y at = at se a ' m wT on 4" re rt , 1 ny us oe uy in Vt Fa mt -0 rr th cal ie ' - 1 r b * w al ' ' 1 "1 "1 oe a ta c ah fs iy ™ * & wi ay ms. te ' , my ' - 24 m oz work dore ky the date. Fursuanit to .s.87(2)¢c} we 3m re r ma x drehesed b erase-claim will T certify that this and the preceding pases dre of oo Lhe Seszans ldemei 3st pr EFsraw Mol Justrec wala: " ate f BO ; f . Set - a a ane Tare, pape LVL Zt - i " -ounsel Por vhe asclicachs Sion Solileitars far the agpplicierst Testes K F Ione & eCite@l Tos LNs resparcd ' tot Sclwsisers Jor tis peesander ot 'lene "ane(s) of hesrinar ih ae "oor nae at-o2 ells eae as ee n '8