Duff, J.W. v. McCulloch, D. & Ors [1985] FCA 679

CATCHWORDS

TELECOMMUNICATIONS (INTERCEPTIGN) - es and transeripts obtained as result cf authorized interception - Tender to a court in proceedings other than proceedings described an.s.7i(6) of Telecommunications (iIntercertion) Act - Whether admission into evidence in those proceedings of tapes and tranecripte

constitutes breach cf 5.7.

TURIGDICTION - Application for prohibition and injunction agains Commonwealth officers - Power of court in those proceedings to make orders against other respondents - Power ef Court to make injuncticn réstraining breach of statute.

(Interception) Act 1979 $3,7,29,22 Polite gations of Misconduct) Aet 1972) «N,S.4.)

2 5.598

Austealia Act 1976 5.22 Phillis Morris ine v7 Adam P. Brown Male ited 41332) 148 ¢.L.P 457, Fencott v Muller . S7C, Etack v Toast Securities (Ne 9) Pty Cire L.R. 261, vy Ku-rin-gai Municival Council £22, Duckhez: of Avavle v Duke of Aragyis (1367 on v Wells (1985) S2 A.L.R. 245 applied. divlines of Mew South Nales Pty Limited 7 New Scuth Watess 6 li94) 112 C.n.P.1, Sankey vy Whitlam 11948) 142 C.L.R-1, Rk wv Iorlano 11982) SO A.L.R. 291, Lamb v Moss (1983) 49 A.L.R. 5272, Chaos "heng Kui v Quinn (25 September 1934, unreported) raferred tr.

DUFF f McCULLOCH AND OTHERS

IN THE FEDERAG COURT

OF AUST

Ms]

F,

LTA

NEM SOUTH WALES DISTRICT PEGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISTON

TDGE MBNING OSDERs:

note Of GREERS:

GREPE MADE:

MINUTE CF ORDER

BETAEEN -

weve

Pd

19385

C ball

wTrp Ta CURS rLLTi4 CUPS

AND:

COMMIESS

es

Nahi ScvT

WALES

THE

OGMMTSSres yor

Peer rs PT x5

parva TOR

see

|e

Fal m mn

Nod

ta

1.

to

ATE

a] Sy iH) 's t2 ts ar m u) rh

IN THE FEDERAL COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTPICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISTON

No.

JAMES WILLIAM DUPE

Applicant

DONALD McCVLLOCH

THE POLICE TPIRUNAL

G342 of

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

THE COMMISSIONEF OF

POLICE | NEN

anpert NEW SO0TH

WALES )

THE COMMISSIONER OF BOLTCE - 3USTPARTI FEDERAL POLICE) Respondents CORAM WILCOX J. DATE 21 NOVEMBER 22285 PLACE: SYDNEY EM TEMPOPR REASONS FOR TMIPGMENT On 22 March 1985, pursuant to 2.20 of the Talecommunicatians Interrerticn: Ark 1375, I issued a warrant authorising perzeons