Kiejna, R. v Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs [1986] FCA 341
Federal Court of Australia
Full text
Select any passage to save a personal note with optional tags.
; Phinccgar REST
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY NO. VG 301 of 1986
GENERAL DIVISION
BETWEEN: RYSZARD KIEJNA Applicant
AND: THE MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION
AND ETHNIC AFFAIRS Respondent
THE COURT: Sweeney J.
DATE : 8 August, 1986
PLACE : Melbourne
QTE hE
REASONS=FOR JUDGMENT
In this matter, an application has been filed by the
applicant to review the decision of 23 July 1986 that a
deportation order of 10 duly 1986 in respect of the applicant be
affirmed. The applicant is aggrieved, the application says,
because his deportation will cause him and his mother great
hardship. The grounds of the application to review are that the
decision was an improper exercise of the power under which it
purported to be made in that it failed to take a relevant
consideration into account, namely the humanitarian and
compassionate reasons why the applicant's deportation would cause
great hardship to his mother. Q -
oa ee
TT Vr en
t
some es
fi .
vf
as
Sacer oo
ee ee
ny 2 :. ae oa
2.
The applicant claims by way of interlocutory order that until
further order; 1, the deportation order be stayed; 2, the
applicant be released and by way of principal relief that there be
an order that the deportation order be quashed or set aside. As I
have said in the course of argument, this court is not invested
with some general power which enables it to look at the merits of
individual cases as if it were itself either the Minister or the
Minister's delegate. The power of the court is limited to the
powers which have been conferred upon it by way of judicial
review. The applicant has sought to bring himself within the
breach of those powers by alleging a failure to take into account
the relevant consideration, the humanitarian and compassionate
reasons why the applicant's deportation would cause great hardship
to his mother.
In my opinion, no sufficient case has been made out for the
grant of the interlocutory relief that is sought, or any of it.
It appears from the material which Mr Little has placed before the
court that he has, on behalf of the applicant, forwarded to the
departmental authorities a statement of the humanitarian and
compassionate reasons why the applicant's deportation would cause
great hardship to his mother and that those matters have been
taken into consideration and weighed against other circumstances
and rejected as a reason for the change of status that has been
sought. Those considerations, I think, appear clearly from a
reading of the whole of the document which Mr little has put
before me.
Under those circumstances [I refuse the grant of any
co
" oe
Voy - aw ey eer. wae
a eee - se :
poms cae
Related laws
No related documents linked yet.
You've got 21 of 22 free Acts left this visit. Sign up anytime for Facts, Related, and study briefs too.