Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union v. Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd [1986] FCA 587

ERPr

Giz

f $

x d cr aytey ettd Or oF a Fue Fl aw} oO a } tl Ut $4 6 wo sto " oe ' » foo a % Gur; + be am cy . a . " au L4 w 3 Hoon . it iy UO +f a o He ge r at rm uy majyp et i) aw HH ty a4 " ri Ey. ow u § p qt © ig ha ° wu u 'o Cio 4 oo [P) a n ' am Flom "i a rte at PAO Ts 4) 1 beets ' " Gs ix Sa ; ' a om yo I uy oc @ ¢ fae t E bled [A] Fon J Oye tt ak a) Un) Het wip Lt i" 5 Fy 0 oe Bote s . 3 ov Ww al ae | my Se + ri CAs I of Ly bb) 8 is Chie 2 wre) i e.ee oy of >

a) Sane)

et et ee

Teneo i

NSW SCUTY WALES DISTRICT RECISTRY Ne. G 244 of 1995 No. G 294 of Lass GENERAD DIVISsON ' BRAD COUT oF AUSTPALIA BETWEEN : 3 SALASTAN MEAT INDUSTRY EMPLOYEES UNTIN Agpellant , and MURGINBERRI STATION ETY LIMITED Respondent MINUTES OF CPDER COURT: Fox, Woodward and Buschet-: IT. DATE: 15 December 1386 PLACE: Sydney The appeats be dismissed with costs. HCTS: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in ¢.74 of the Federal Ceurt Rules.)

IN THE iS CURT Cr AUSTRALTA

) ) No. G )

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY Neo. G 244 of 1995 234 cf 13285 ~ we ~ ~

CEN SIVISTI

N APPEAL Fe AD SCURT OF AUSTRALIA

SETWEEN :

AY ASTAN MEAT INDUSTRY EMOLOVESS CUNTON Apra@llant and

TH PI STATTON ory crupren Raspondcent

SOURT: Fox, Wecedward and Surchett JJ.

Dare: 15 December 1396 PEACE: Sydney

REASONS 32R ITUEGMENT

THE court

j

this is an appeal against the impesiticn by the Court of a fine of 3100,990 fcr breach cf certain of 1¢2 orders. The Teourct

,tonstituted Sy Lockhart J) had found chat che arscellant Unicn

"WAS instrumental im and yvrespcnsible Zsy establishing area Masntaining" a sickat tine at 'the vescondant s Mudginberr: aAmacteours. Th2 ma

tJ '

srders sreviousizy made by Morling J.

The substantial ground cf appeal which was relied uren by counsel for the appellant was that there was no evidence befor? Lockhart J upon which his Honcur could oroperly finc 'chat the Union .wtself was implicated in the maintenance cf the oicket Line at the ralevant times - that is to say between the service cf