Printing and Kindred Industries Union, George Donald Anderson, William Banks, John Leslie Becus, James Albert Benton, Bruno Broesel, Ronald William Broom, Laurie Camenzuli, John Charles Forrest, Gregory Maxwell Hayward, Maxwell George Hayward, Ronald Hill, John Jenkins, John Grenville Kemp, Chan Yew Leong, Alwyn Mallitt, Bruce Ronald Marheine, Donald Drew McArthur, Malcolm John McDonald, James Moir, Robert Francis Nicholls, Denis Powell, John Stafford Robertson, Rayner Ruditsch, Charles Roy Smith, Nestor Tan, Roy Edward Walker, Kim Wilkinson and Barry Raymond Winmill v Vista Paper Products Pty Limited and John McNamee [1994] IRCA 133

INDUSTRIAL LAW - Proceedings for enforcement of reinstatement award - Application for penalties, including daily penalties - Whether it should be accepted that employer was financially incapable of making back payments required by the award - Relevant considerations in determining the amounts of the appropriate penalties - Applications for orders for payment of underpaid moneys - Relevance of other income of employees during the material period - Computation of appropriate amounts. Industrial Relations Act 1988, ss.178, 179 PRINTING AND KINDRED INDUSTRIES UNION, GEORGE DONALD ANDERSON, WILLIAM BANKS, JOHN LESLIE BECUS, JAMES ALBERT BENTON, BRUNO BROESEL, RONALD WILLIAM BROOM, LAURIE CAMENZULI, JOHN CHARLES FORREST, GREGORY MAXWELL HAYWARD, MAXWELL GEORGE HAYWARD, RONALD HILL, JOHN JENKINS, JOHN GRENVILLE KEMP, CHAN YEW LEONG, ALWYN MALLITT, BRUCE RONALD MARHEINE, DONALD DREW McARTHUR, MALCOLM JOHN MCDONALD, JAMES MOIR, ROBERT FRANCIS NICHOLLS, DENIS POWELL, JOHN STAFFORD ROBERTSON, RAYNER RUDITSCH, CHARLES ROY SMITH, NESTOR TAN, ROY EDWARD WALKER, KIM WILKINSON and BARRY RAYMOND WINMILL v. VISTA PAPER PRODUCTS PTY LIMITED and JOHN McNAMEE No. NI.104 of 1994 CORAM: WILCOX CJ PLACE: SYDNEY

DATE: 14 DECEMBER 1994 IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT) OF AUSTRALIA ) No. NI.104 of 1994 NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY) BETWEEN: PRINTING AND KINDRED INDUSTRIES UNION, GEORGE DONALD ANDERSON, WILLIAM BANKS, JOHN LESLIE BECUS, JAMES ALBERT BENTON, BRUNO BROESEL, RONALD WILLIAM BROOM, LAURIE CAMENZULI, JOHN CHARLES FORREST, GREGORY MAXWELL HAYWARD, MAXWELL GEORGE HAYWARD, RONALD HILL, JOHN JENKINS, JOHN GRENVILLE KEMP, CHAN YEW LEONG, ALWYN MALLITT, BRUCE RONALD MARHEINE, DONALD DREW McARTHUR, MALCOLM JOHN MCDONALD, JAMES MOIR, ROBERT FRANCIS NICHOLLS, DENIS POWELL, JOHN STAFFORD ROBERTSON, RAYNER RUDITSCH, CHARLES ROY SMITH, NESTOR TAN, ROY EDWARD WALKER, KIM WILKINSON and BARRY RAYMOND WINMILL Applicants AND: VISTA PAPER PRODUCTS PTY LIMITED First Respondent JOHN McNAMEE Second Respondent CORAM: WILCOX CJ PLACE: SYDNEY DATE: 14 DECEMBER 1994