Veterans' Entitlements (Attribution of Income) Principles 2025 The Repatriation Commission makes the following instrument. Dated 19 February 2025 The Seal of the Repatriation Commission was affixed to this instrument in the presence of: Alison Frame Mark Brewer AM CSC and Bar President Deputy President Gwen Cherne Kahlil Fegan DSC AM Commissioner Commissioner Contents Part 1 Preliminary 1 Name 4 2 Commencement 4 3 Authority 4 3A Repeal 4 4 Definitions 4 4A Purpose 4 Part 2 Determination about excluded income (Act, s 52ZZK) Division 2.1 No double counting—both members of couple are attributable stakeholders of company or trust 6 5 Application of Division 2.1 6 6 Sum of distributions is the same as sum of attributable income 6 7 Sum of distributions is less than sum of attributable income 6 8 Sum of distributions is greater than sum of attributable income 7 Division 2.2 No double counting—one member of couple is not attributable stakeholder 7 9 Distribution made to partner who is not attributable stakeholder 7 Division 2.3 Investor makes genuine transfer and receives distribution or credit 7 10 Application of Division 2.3 7 11 Genuine transfer of capital 7 12 Excluded income 8 Part 3 Determination about excluded income (Act, s 52ZZL) Division 3.1 No double counting of attributed income—general 9 13 No double counting of attributed income—general 9 14 No double counting if ordinary income significantly diminished 9 Division 3.2 Distributions by companies 9 15 No double counting of attributed income—distribution by company to all attributable stakeholders 9 16 No double counting of attributed income—other distributions by a company 10 Division 3.3 Distributions by trusts 11 17 No double counting of attributed income—distribution by trust to all attributable stakeholders 11 18 No double counting of attributed income—other distributions by trust 11 Part 4 Determination of derivation period (Act, s 52ZZP) 19 Derivation period must reflect typical income 12 Part 5 Determination of attribution period (Act, s 52ZZQ) 20 Attribution period must reflect typical circumstances 13 Part 1 Preliminary 1 Name This instrument is the Veterans' Entitlements (Attribution of Income) Principles 2025. 2 Commencement This instrument commences on the day after the day it is registered. 3 Authority This instrument is made under section 52ZZZQ of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986. 3A Repeal Schedule 4 to the Veterans' Affairs (Legislative Instrument Re-making Exercise) Instrument 2014 is repealed. 4 Definitions Note: A number of expressions used in this instrument are defined in the Act, including the following: (a) attributable stakeholder – of a company or trust (see section 52ZZJ); (b) Commission (see section 5Q); (c) company (see section 52ZO); (d) member of a couple (see section 5E); (e) partner (see section 5E); (f) trust (see section 52ZO of the Act). In this instrument, unless the contrary intention appears: Act means the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986. attributable income, in relation to an individual who is an attributable stakeholder of a company or trust, means income that the individual is taken to receive during an attribution period of the company or trust. distribution, in relation to a trust, includes an amount credited by a trust to a beneficiary of the trust. 4A Purpose This instrument sets out decision-making principles with which the Commission must comply in making the following determinations: (a) a determination under subsection 52ZZK(2) of the Act that, for the purposes of the application of subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act to a specified individual and a specified company or trust, a specified amount is excluded income; (b) a determination under section 52ZZL of the Act that the ordinary income of an individual does not include the amount or value of a distribution, or a part of the amount or value of a distribution, to the individual by a company or trust; (c) a determination under section 52ZZP(3) of the Act that a specified period is a derivation period of a company or trust for the purposes of the application of Subdivision G of Division 11A of Part IIIB of the Act to a specified individual and to a specified company or trust; (d) a determination under section 52ZZQ(1) of the Act that a specified period is an attribution period for the purposes of the application of Division 11A of Part IIIB of the Act to a specified individual and to a specified company or trust. Part 2 Determination about excluded income (Act, s 52ZZK) Division 2.1 No double counting—both members of couple are attributable stakeholders of company or trust 5 Application of Division 2.1 This Division applies if, in respect of an individual, the following circumstances exist: (a) the individual is a member of a couple; (b) the individual and the individual's partner are attributable stakeholders of a company or trust; (c) during a derivation period of the company or trust, the individual: (i) may, or may not, receive a distribution from the company or trust; but (ii) is taken to receive an amount of attributable income during the attribution period that relates to the derivation period; (d) during the derivation period mentioned in paragraph (c), the individual's partner: (i) receives a distribution from the company or trust; and (ii) is taken to receive an amount of attributable income during the attribution period that relates to the derivation period. 6 Sum of distributions is the same as sum of attributable income (1) This section applies if: (a) the sum of the distributions mentioned in subparagraphs 5(c)(i) (if any) and 5(d)(i) is the same as the sum of the attributable income mentioned in subparagraphs 5(c)(ii) and 5(d)(ii); but (b) the amount of the distribution mentioned in subparagraph 5(d)(i) is greater than the amount of attributable income mentioned in subparagraph 5 (d)(ii). (2) The Commission must consider determining that the difference between the amounts referred to in paragraph (1)(b) is excluded income in relation to the attributable income of the individual mentioned in paragraph 5(c). 7 Sum of distributions is less than sum of attributable income (1) This section applies if: (a) the sum of the distributions mentioned in subparagraphs 5 (c)(i) (if any) and 5(d)(i) is less than the sum of the attributable income mentioned in subparagraphs 5(c)(ii) and 5(d)(ii); but (b) the amount of the distribution mentioned in subparagraph 5(d)(i) is greater than the amount of attributable income mentioned in subparagraph 5(d)(ii). (2) The Commission must consider determining that the difference between the amounts referred to in paragraph (1)(b) is excluded income in relation to the attributable income of the individual mentioned in paragraph 5(c). 8 Sum of distributions is greater than sum of attributable income (1) This section applies if: (a) the sum of the distributions mentioned in subparagraphs 5(c)(i) (if any) and 5(d)(i) is greater than the sum of the attributable income mentioned in subparagraphs 5(c)(ii) and 5(d)(ii); but (b) the amount of the distribution mentioned in subparagraph 5(c)(i) (if any) is less than the amount of attributable income mentioned in subparagraph 5(c)(ii). (2) The Commission must consider determining that the difference between the amounts referred to in paragraph (1)(b) is excluded income in relation to the attributable income of the individual mentioned in paragraph 5(c). Division 2.2 No double counting—one member of couple is not attributable stakeholder 9 Distribution made to partner who is not attributable stakeholder (1) This section applies if, in respect of an individual, the following circumstances exist: (a) the individual is a member of a couple; (b) the individual is an attributable stakeholder of a company or trust, but the individual's partner is not an attributable stakeholder of the company or trust; (c) during a derivation period of the company or trust, the individual: (i) may, or may not, receive a distribution from the company or trust; but (ii) is taken to receive an amount of attributable income during the attribution period that relates to the derivation period; (d) during the derivation period mentioned in paragraph (c), the individual's partner receives a distribution from the company or trust. (2) The Commission must consider determining that an amount equal to the amount of the distribution received by the partner is excluded income in relation to the attributable stakeholder. Division 2.3 Investor makes genuine transfer and receives distribution or credit 10 Application of Division 2.3 This Division applies if: (a) an individual (the investor) makes a genuine transfer of capital to a company or trust of which the investor is not an attributable stakeholder; and (b) during a derivation period of the company or trust, the investor receives a distribution from the company or trust. 11 Genuine transfer of capital For section 10, a transfer of capital is a genuine transfer of capital if: (a) the investor receives, as consideration for the transfer, shares in the company, or units in the trust, of a value that is equivalent to the value of the capital transferred; and (b) the investor has a legal or equitable right to a share of the capital of the company or trust; and (c) the investor has a legal or equitable right to receive dividends or distributions in accordance with the constituent documents of the company or the terms of the trust; and (d) the investor is over 18 years of age. 12 Excluded income (1) This section applies if: (a) an individual who is an attributable stakeholder of a company or trust is taken to receive attributable income in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act; and (b) the attributable income of the individual is taken to include additional ordinary income in the circumstances mentioned in section 10. (2) The Commission must consider determining that the amount of additional ordinary income worked out in accordance with subsection (3) is excluded income in relation to the attributable stakeholder. (3) The amount of excluded income is worked out by multiplying the amount of the distribution mentioned in paragraph 10(b) by the income attribution percentage of the attributable stakeholder. Part 3 Determination about excluded income (Act, s 52ZZL) Division 3.1 No double counting of attributed income—general 13 No double counting of attributed income—general (1) For paragraphs 52ZZL(1)(d) and (e) and (2)(d) and (e) of the Act, the Commission must have regard to the ordinary income of the individual received during the relevant attribution period and consider if the individual is an attributable stakeholder of: (a) more than 1 controlled private company; or (b) more than 1 controlled private trust; or (c) at least 1 controlled private company and 1 controlled private trust. (2) For paragraphs 52ZZL(1)(d) and (e) and (2)(d) and (e) of the Act, the Commission must also consider if a company or trust mentioned in subsection (1) has derived an amount, directly or indirectly, by way of dividend or other distribution from another controlled private company or controlled private trust. 14 No double counting if ordinary income significantly diminished (1) This section applies if: (a) a company or trust makes a distribution to an individual who is an attributable stakeholder of the company or trust; and (b) the individual would, but for this section, be taken to receive an amount of ordinary income over a period of 12 months in accordance with section 46A of the Act; and (c) the ordinary income of the individual derived from the company or trust during an attribution period has ceased, or is significantly diminished, because the company or trust: (i) has been wound-up or otherwise ceased to exist; or (ii) has been subject to circumstances adversely affecting its profitability. (2) For paragraphs 52ZZL(1)(d) and (e) and (2)(d) and (e) of the Act, the Commission must consider: (a) whether, in all the circumstances, the application of section 46A of the Act would be unfair or unreasonable in relation to the individual; and (b) if section 46A applies unfairly or unreasonably in relation to the individual, determining that the ordinary income of the individual does not include the whole or part of the amount or value distributed to the individual. Division 3.2 Distributions by companies 15 No double counting of attributed income—distribution by company to all attributable stakeholders (1) This section applies if: (a) during a particular derivation period of a company, an individual receives a distribution of capital from the company (the distribution); and (b) the individual is an attributable stakeholder of the company during an attribution period that corresponds with the derivation period of the company; and (c) the distribution made to the attributable stakeholder is part of a distribution to all attributable stakeholders of the company (the total distribution); and (d) the proportion that the distribution to each attributable stakeholder bears to the total distribution, expressed as a percentage, is the same as each attributable stakeholder's asset attribution percentage in relation to the company. (2) For paragraph 52ZZL(1)(d) of the Act, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during the attribution period does not include the distribution if, but for this section, the amount or value of the distribution would be included in the ordinary income of the individual for that period. (3) For paragraph 52ZZL(1)(e) of the Act, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during the attribution period does not include any part of the amount or value of the distribution if, but for this section, any part of the amount or value of the distribution would be included in the ordinary income of the individual for that period. 16 No double counting of attributed income—other distributions by a company (1) This section applies if: (a) during a particular derivation period of a company, an individual receives a distribution of capital or profits from the company (the distribution); and (b) the individual is an attributable stakeholder of the company during an attribution period that corresponds with the derivation period of the company; and (c) the distribution is made in circumstances other than those mentioned in section 14 and paragraphs 15(1)(c) and (d); and (d) the individual is taken to receive additional ordinary income during that attribution period in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act. (2) For paragraph 52ZZL(1)(d) of the Act, if the amount of the distribution is less than, or equal to, the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act during the attribution period, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during that period does not include the amount of that distribution. (3) For paragraph 52ZZL(1)(e) of the Act, if the amount of the distribution exceeds the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act during the attribution period, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during that period does not include so much of the amount of the distribution that equals the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act. Division 3.3 Distributions by trusts 17 No double counting of attributed income—distribution by trust to all attributable stakeholders (1) This section applies if: (a) during a particular derivation period of a trust, an individual receives a distribution of corpus from the trust (the distribution); and (b) the individual is an attributable stakeholder of the trust during an attribution period that corresponds with the derivation period of the trust; and (c) the distribution made to the attributable stakeholder is part of a distribution to all attributable stakeholders of the trust (the total distribution); and (d) the proportion that the distribution to each attributable stakeholder bears to the total distribution, expressed as a percentage, is the same as the attributable stakeholder's asset attribution percentage in relation to the trust. (2) For paragraph 52ZZL(2)(d) of the Act, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during the attribution period does not include the amount or value of the distribution if, but for this section, the distribution would be included in the ordinary income of the individual for that period. (3) For paragraph 52ZZL(2)(e) of the Act, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during the attribution period does not include any part of the amount or value of the distribution if, but for this section, any part of the amount or value of the distribution would be included in the ordinary income of the individual for that period. 18 No double counting of attributed income—other distributions by trust (1) This section applies if: (a) during a particular derivation period of a trust, an individual receives a distribution of corpus or income from the trust (the distribution); and (b) the individual is an attributable stakeholder of the trust during an attribution period that corresponds with the derivation period of the trust; and (c) the distribution is made in circumstances other than those mentioned in section 14 and paragraphs 17(1)(c) and (d); and (d) the individual is taken to receive additional ordinary income, during that attribution period, in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act. (2) For paragraph 52ZZL(2)(d) of the Act, if the amount of the distribution is less than, or equal to, the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act during the attribution period, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during that period does not include the amount of that distribution. (3) For paragraph 52ZZL(2)(e) of the Act, if the amount of the distribution exceeds the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act during the attribution period, the Commission must consider determining that the ordinary income of the individual received during that period does not include so much of the amount of the distribution that equals the additional ordinary income that the individual is taken to receive in accordance with subsection 52ZZK(1) of the Act. Part 4 Determination of derivation period (Act, s 52ZZP) 19 Derivation period must reflect typical income (1) This section applies to the determination of a specified period as the derivation period of a specified company or trust in relation to an attributable stakeholder of the company or trust. (2) The derivation period must be a period that is determined having regard to the following matters: (a) the ordinary income of the company or trust for a derivation period referred to in subsection 52ZZP(1) of the Act; (b) the ordinary income of the company or trust for any other period or periods that may reasonably be regarded as typical earning periods for the company or trust; (c) any circumstances affecting the company or trust during the periods referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b); (d) whether, having regard to any circumstances referred to in paragraph (c), it is appropriate to use a derivation period different from the derivation period referred to in subsection 52ZZP(1) of the Act. Part 5 Determination of attribution period (Act, s 52ZZQ) 20 Attribution period must reflect typical circumstances (1) This section applies to the determination of an attribution period in relation to: (a) a specified individual who is an attributable stakeholder of a specified company or trust; and (b) a specified derivation period of the company or trust. (2) The attribution period must be a period that is determined having regard to the following matters: (a) the ordinary income of the attributable stakeholder for the derivation period; (b) the ordinary income of the attributable stakeholder for any other period or periods that may reasonably be regarded as typical earning periods for the attributable stakeholder; (c) any circumstances affecting the attributable stakeholder during the periods referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b); (d) any circumstances that may reasonably be regarded as likely to affect the ordinary income of the attributable stakeholder.