TROMPP V. LIDDLE 19/1941

WL J. Green, Gort, Print, Melb.

Ao se Vien C7

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA.

Keble Cle

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT.

Judgment delivered at Loe of

t

a

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA)

) No. 19 of 1941. NEW SOUTH WALES REGISTRY )

ON APPEAL from the Supreme Court

of New South Wales

BETWEEN: ELEANOR SUSANAH TROMPP (Plaintiff) Appellant AND:

THOMAS LIDDLE (Defendant) Respondent BEFORE : Their Honours the Acting Chief Justice Mr. Justice Starke, Mr. Justice McTiernan and Mr. Justice Williams. Wednesday the Sixth day of August in the Year of Our Lord One thousand nine hundred and fortyone. WHEREAS on the Fifteenth day of May one thousand nine hundred and forty one the abovenamed Appellant filed a Notice of Appeal to this Court from the whole of the judgment and order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales given and made on the First day of May one thousand nine hundred and forty one setting aside the verdict and judgment entered in favour of the abovenamed Appellant in Action No. 2325 of 1939 AND WHEREAS the Appeal came on to be heard before this Court this day WHEREUPON AND UPON READING

the Transcript Record of the proceedings transmitted to this

Court by the Prothonotary of the said Supreme Court AND UPON HEARING what was alleged by Mr. J.E. Cassidy of Kings Counsel, with whom was Mr. A.C. Wallace of Counsel on behalf of the Appellant and by Mr. W.W. Monahan of Kings Counsel with whom was Mr. L.C. Jordan

of Counsel on behalf of the Respondent THIS COURT DOTH ORDER that this Appeal be and the same is hereby dismissed AND THIS COURT DOTH FURTHER ORDER that it be referred to the proper officerof this Court to tax and certify the costs of the Respondent of and incidental to this eal and that such costs when so taxed and

to his

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA} NEW SOUTH WALES REGISTRY )

TROMP v. LIDDLE 6th. August 1941 Judgment of His Honour the Acting Chief Justice: