GROUT v THE COUNCIL OF THE SHIRE OF WARRINGAH [1993] NSWCA 127
NSW Caselaw
Full text
Select any passage to save a personal note with optional tags.
GROUT v THE COUNCIL OF THE SHIRE OF WARRINGAH
SUPREME COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES — COURT OF APPEAL
MAHONEY JA
16 August 1993
[1993] NSWCA 127
Mahoney JA. This is an application for expedition of the hearing of an appeal.
It appears that a judgment was given by Cole J on 20 December 1991 in which,
as I understand what has been said, the plaintiff failed in an application against
the Warringah Shire Council based on negligence and perhaps other grounds. It
has been contended by Mr White, the applicant for expedition on behalf of the
plaintiff, that the Government has given notice of a proposal to gazette a manual
at the end of two months from the date which he specified, 12 July 1993. He has
contended that if a gazettal is effected that will, or may, prejudice the rights which
his client is seeking to enforce in this appeal.
The contention is, as I understand it, that the effect of the gazettal of the
manual will retrospectively destroy the rights which he is seeking to achieve. He
desires to have those rights crystallised in a judgment of the court by the hearing
of the appeal and the making of appropriate orders before the date on which the
manual is gazetted.
The matter has not proceeded, at least on the face of it, with all the speed that
was necessary. I do not mean by this to criticise the parties involved. I do not
know all the facts.
I think it is a matter in which, taking the argument that has been put forward
at its face value, expedition should be ordered. Nothing has been urged by the
respondent to this application to suggest that there is not an arguable case at least
and if the appeal is not heard before the gazettal the rights may be lost or
prejudiced.
In the circumstances, I think it is appropriate to order that the appeal be
expedited. This will involve, if it be possible, that the appeal be heard and
determined before the expiration of two months to which I have referred, or any
longer period that may be granted by the Crown having regard to the pendency
of the matter before the court.
I will direct that the hearing of the appeal be expedited. I will refer the matter
to the Registrar to fix a date for the hearing, if possible before the expiration of
the two month period, and in such circumstances that the court may be able to
determine the appeal within that time.
Costs of this application will be reserved to the Court on the appeal.
Orders accordingly.
Related laws
No related documents linked yet.
You've got 21 of 22 free Acts left this visit. Sign up anytime for Facts, Related, and study briefs too.