Select any passage to save a personal note with optional tags.
PACIFIC POWER v JAY
SUPREME COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES — COURT OF APPEAL
MAHONEY AP, PRIESTLEY JA and HUNTER AJA
14 August 1995
[1995] NSWCA 347
Mahoney AP. This is an application for leave to appeal in relation to a matter
to which, as counsel have given the Court to understand, the Dust Diseases
Tribunal Act applies.
Counsel, on coming before the Court, have informed the Court that it is the
view of the applicant that there is an appeal as of right under s 32 of the Act. Mr
Joseph SC for the respondent is of the same view. The terms of the section are
somewhat unusual in the sense that, as the Court has been informed, it has not
been the subject of consideration by the Court. In particular, as the Court has
been informed, there is no ruling as to whether leave to appeal is necessary in
relation to an order such as the present made by the tribunal.
The Court accepts the view that there ought to be, and this is not opposed, an
extension of time for the filing of the notice of appeal. The applicant before the
Court today may then pursue an appeal to this Court against the order that has
been made.
The Court will stand over the present application for leave to appeal to the
hearing of that appeal. If it should be that leave to appeal is necessary then the
rights of the applicant will to that extent be safeguarded.
A question arises as to what order for costs should be made in relation to the
present application. The Court is of the opinion that the costs ought to be reserved
to the Court dealing with the application in due course. That will mean that if the
application is dismissed then of course, the present applicant will pay the costs
of the application, including inter alia the costs of today.
Mr Joseph has referred to the possibility of expedition. This is not a matter
which the Court can deal with at the present time. If a case can be made out for
expedition it should be made out in the ordinary way.
They are the orders that the Court proposes be made. Time for filing the Notice
of Appeal will be extended to fourteen days from today's date.
Orders accordingly.