HORROBIN v AUSTRALIA & NEW ZEALAND BANKING GROUP LIMITED [1996] NSWCA 252
NSW Caselaw
Full text
Select any passage to save a personal note with optional tags.
HORROBIN vy AUSTRALIA & NEW ZEALAND BANKING GROUP
LIMITED
SUPREME COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES — COURT OF APPEAL
MAHONEY P and PRIESTLEY JA
24 June 1996
[1996] NSWCA 252
Mahoney P. In this matter the Court is minded to grant leave to appeal against
the order for summary Judgment. It will direct that the appeal be prepared as on
the basis of a short appeal, that is, as a matter that ought to be dealt with within
two hours. In the preparation of the appeal, detailed submissions should be
prepared, on that basis.
It is minded that the costs of the application be costs of the appeal. The other
orders that have been made are not of course the subject of the leave to appeal
application, so the Court need not consider those further.
The Court is minded to grant a stay, but only upon conditions of the kind
referred to in the letter from Norton Smith & Company dated 21 June 1996. That
is a letter addressed to Messrs Heidtman & Company. It is minded to grant the
stay upon those conditions mutatis mutandis. It has not had the benefit of any
detailed summary of the financial condition of the — I call them — Horrobin
interests, but it is minded to grant the stay. (The present stay extends until 1 July).
It will allow the Horrobin interests leave to appeal for a variation of the terms of
the stay by motion filed prior tothat time, otherwise the stay will be upon the
conditions set out in the letter of 21 June 1996.
It is appreciated that the terms there set forth may require some elaboration,
and it will therefore direct that the parties bring in short minutes that give effect
to the substance of the orders which I have indicated. I indicate again that if the
Horrobin interests contend that they are financially unable to meet the payment
of the interest component, which I take to be $14,038.36 per fortnight, liberty is
reserved to them to make an application for variation of the terms of the stay in
that regard. Ordinarily an application would be necessary for them to establish to
the Court's satisfaction that inability, and perhaps other discretionary matters,
before any variation of the stay would be granted.
The order that the Court makes then at the moment is that leave to appeal is
granted in respect of the order for summary judgment; it directs the preparation
of the appeal as on a short appeal basis, with written submissions accordingly;
affirms the order for costs to which I have referred, and it grants a stay on the
terms which I have indicated, but subject to the leave to which I have referred.
I will initial the copy of the letter to which I have referred and place it with the
papers. The parties will bring in short minutes to give proper effect to the terms
of the orders that the Court has made.
In the matter 040221/96 the Court will make the same orders mutatis mutandis
as in the matter that has just been disposed of.
Orders accordingly.
Related laws
No related documents linked yet.
You've got 21 of 22 free Acts left this visit. Sign up anytime for Facts, Related, and study briefs too.