WILSON v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES and ANOR [1997] NSWCA 347
NSW Caselaw
Full text
Select any passage to save a personal note with optional tags.
WILSON v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES and ANOR
SUPREME COURT OF NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
Hunt CJ at CL, SMART and JAMES JJ
30 August 1996, 12 February 1997
[1997] NSWCA 347
CANCELLATION OF PERIODIC DETENTION ORDER — NO PREROGATIVE
RELEF
Hunt CJ I agree with Smart AJA that the application to this Court for relief
in the nature of certiorari and prohibition should be dismissed, and that (in the
circumstances) no order should be made as to costs. I agree also with the reasons
for the dismissal of the application which Smart AJA has given in his judgment
in the related matter in the Court of Criminal Appeal, Wilson v Department of
Corrective Services (60650 of 1995).
Smart J For the reasons contained in my judgment in the related matter in the
Court of Criminal Appeal, Wilson v Department of Corrective Services
(60650/95) I am of the opinion that the application for relief in the nature of
certiorari and prohibition should be dismissed and that no order for costs should
be made because of the unfortunate bifurcation of jurisdiction, the difficulty of an
applicant knowing what course to take and the essentially criminal character of
the substantive issues raised.
James J I agree with the judgment of Smart AJA.
Application for relief dismissed and no order for costs made.
Counsel for the appellant: TA Game
Solicitors for the appellant: TA Murphy
Counsel for the respondent: PM Strickland
Solicitors for the respondent: IV Knight