HCCC v Dr Alex Simring [2010] NSWMT 7

New South Wales Medical Tribunal

CITATION : HCCC v Dr Alex Simring [2010] NSWMT 7 TRIBUNAL: Medical Tribunal PARTIES : Health Care Complaints Commission Dr Alex Amadeus Simring FILE NUMBER(S) : 40019 of 2009 CORAM: Ainslie-Wallace, DCJ - Anderson, Dr P - Sammut, Dr J - Ettinger, Ms G CATCHWORDS: Child pornography convictions - Failure to advise the NSW Medical Board of criminal convictions - Professional miscondict and unsatisfactory professional conduct - Reprimand - Conditions placed on practice - 'In the practice of medicine' - relationship between conduct constituting an offence and the provision of professional services - "prohibited person " classification places restriction on the practice of medicine which is conduct relating to the practice of medicine - good character - defect of character Medical Practice Act 1992 ss 127B , 39(a), 64(1)(c), 36 & 37 LEGISLATION CITED: Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) s91H(3) Criminal Code Act 1995 (Clth) s474 Child Protection (Offenders Registration) Act 2000 (NSW) Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 362; Diretor-General, Department of Community Services; re Sophie [2008] NSWCA 250; In re Dr Abraham Stephanopoulos [2006] MPBV 12; A Solicitor v Council of the Law Society refer to judgment of the High Court [2004] HCA 1 @ para 33; Ziems v The Prothonotary of the Suprme Court of NSW (1957) 97 CLR 279; HCCC v Wingate [2007] NSWCA 326; CASES CITED: Roylance v The General Medical Council [1999] UKPC 16; Marten v Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' Disciplinary Committee [1966] 1 QB 1; NSW Bar Association v Cummins [2001] NSWCA 284; In re James Benedict Anton Provan [2005] PRBD (Victim) 3; ex parte Tziniolis: re Medical Practitioners Act (1966) 67 SR(NSW) 448; HCCC v Karalasingham [2007] NSWCA 267; McBride v Walton (unreported NSWCA 15th July 1994); In the matter of Roderick Doyle Motum; Medical Tribunal of NSW 4013 of 1999 DATES OF HEARING: 22.3.2010 to 23.3.2010 DATE OF JUDGMENT: 29 April 2010 G Farmer of Counsel LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES: R Lewis Solicitor - Health Care Complaints Commission G Butler D Brown Solicitor - Browns Legal and Consulting ORDERS: 1.The respondent be subject to a reprimand; Practice Conditions; 2.The respondent's registration as a medical practitioner be subject to the following conditions; (i)the respondent must not attend, treat or perform procedures on patients under 18 years of age.; (ii)The practitioner may provide treatment to a person under the age of 18 years in the event of a medical emergency and where it is not possible or reasonable to have a patient with a serious or life-threatening or urgent condition treated by another medical practitioner or transferred to the nearest hospital. If any such even occurs, the practitioner must notify the NSW Medical Board with 7 days and provide details of the event to the NSW Medical Board and any other information as requested by the NSW Medical Board; (iii)To obtain the approval of the NSW Medical Board prior to commencing practice or changing the nature or place of practice; 3.Within 14 days of these orders, the respondent nominate a psychiatrist with expertise in sexual offending and dysfunction and will attend for treatment at a frequency to be determined by the psychiatrist. The respondent to authorise the nominated treating psychiatrist to notify the NSW Medical Board in the event that the respondent fails to attend for treatment as arranged, terminates treatment or if there is a significant change in the respondent's health; 4.The respondent to attend a psychiatrist nominated by the NSW Medical Board for risk assessment prior to any Board interview or as directed by the NSW Medical Board. The NSW Medical Board to bear the expense of the respondent's attendance on the psychiatrist; 5.The NSW Medical Board may notify the respondent's employer/s of any issues arising in relation to his compliance with these conditions; 6.The respondent to authorise the NSW Medical Board and consents to any exchange of information between it and Medicare Australia where the exchange is necessary to facilitate the monitoring of compliance with these conditions; 7.The respondent authorises the NSW Medical Board to provide a copy of the Medical Tribunal Reasons for Determination to any treating practitioners and any reports that the NSW Medical Board considers appropriate; 8.The respondent provide a copy of the Practice Conditions signed by his employer within 7 days of these orders and within 7 days of the commencement of any employment; 9.The NSW Medical Board to be the review body in relation to these conditions; 10.The respondent to provide a copy of the Medical Tribunal's reasons for Determination in this matter to his employer and/or employees; 11.The respondent pay the costs of the hearing