Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Hollier & Ors [2001] NSWSC 805

New South Wales Supreme Court

CITATION : Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Hollier & Ors [2001] NSWSC 805 revised - 27/09/2001 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division Commercial List FILE NUMBER(S) : SC 50098/98 HEARING DATE(S) : 7/8/00-10/8/00,14/8/00,26/2/01-28/2/01,1/3/01,5/3/01-8/3/01,12/3/01-15/3/01,19/3/01-22/3/01,26/3/01-29/3/01, 2/4/01-5/4/01, 9/4/01, 3/5/01, 5/7/01, 18/7/01 JUDGMENT DATE : 13 September 2001

Commonwealth Bank of Australia (Plaintiff) William Edward Hollier (1st Defendant) Janifer Lee Hollier (2nd Defendant) George Smith Holliday (3rd Defendant) George William Sanders (4th Defendant) Stephen David McCloy (5th Defendant) Cancarra Pty Ltd (6th Defendant) Cloudgard No 43 Pty Ltd (7th Defendant) Ninot Pty Ltd (8th Defendant) Miltup Pty Ltd (9th Defendant) Walenora Pty Ltd (10 Defendant) Stenoak Pty Ltd (11th Defendant) Ian Allibon Plumbing Pty Ltd (12th Defendant) Bruce John Sanders (13th Defendant) Ian Paul Allibon (14th Defendant) Caron Grace Allibon (15th Defendant) Graham Erland McCloy (16th Defendant) PARTIES : Jennifer Joan McCloy (17th Defendant) Reginald Patrick Flannery (18th Defendant) Victoria Boyd (19th Defendant) James Mercer Anderson (20th Defendant) Yvonne Lillian Anderson (21st Defendant) Matthew James Bliss (22nd Defendant) Catherine Margaret Bliss (23rd Defendant) WE Hollier & JL Hollier (1st Cross Claimants) GJ Leonard & Leonard Consultants Pty Ltd & CJ Sneddon & CJ Sneddon & SN Roxby t/as Maxim Consulting Corporate Advisors (Cross Defendants to 1st Cross Claim) WE Hollier and JL Hollier (2nd Cross Claimants) Cancarra Pty Ltd (Cross Defendant to 2nd Cross Claim) GS Holliday, GW Sanders, SD McCloy, Cancarra Pty Ltd, Cloudgard No 43 Pty Ltd, Ninot Pty Ltd, Miltup Pty Ltd, Walenora Pty Ltd, Stenoak Pty Ltd, Ian Allibon Plumbing Pty Ltd, BJ Sanders, IP Allibon, CG Allibon, GE McCloy, JJ McCloy, RP Flannery, VBoyd, JM Anderson, YL Anderson, MJ Bliss, CM Bliss (3rd Cross Claimants) WE Hollier, JL Hollier (Cross Defendants to 3rd Cross Claim) GJ Leonard & Leonard Consultants Pty Ltd & CJ Sneddon & CJ Sneddon & SN Roxby t/as Maxim Consulting Corporate Advisors (4th Cross Claimants) S Madden & Madden & Associates Pty Ltd (Cross Defendants to 4th Cross Claim) WE Hollier and JL Hollier (5th Cross Claimants) Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1st Cross Defendant to 5th Cross Claim) S Madden and Madden & Associates Pty Ltd (2nd Cross Defendants to 5th Cross Claim) JUDGMENT OF : Brownie AJ