Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Nutricia Australia Pty Ltd; Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Michael Speare Hocken Sharpe; Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Toni Lee Brendish [2008] NSWSC 1382

Reported Decision : 74 NSWLR 148

New South Wales Supreme Court

CITATION : Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Nutricia Australia Pty Ltd; Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Michael Speare Hocken Sharpe; Tumney (NSW Food Authority) v Toni Lee Brendish [2008] NSWSC 1382 This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.

HEARING DATE(S) : 1 December 2008 - 3 December 2008

JUDGMENT DATE : 22 December 2008

JUDGMENT OF : Simpson J

2007 Criminal Proceedings against Nutricia to be permanently stayed. 13664/07, 13665/07, 13666/07, 13669/07, 13670/07, 13671/07 2007 Criminal Proceedings against Nutricia to be dismissed. 13672/07, 13673/07, 13674/07, 13675/07, 13676/07, 13677/07 13678/07 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Nutricia to be permanently stayed. 12711/08, 12713/08, 12971/08, 12942/08, 12974/08, 12945/08 12977/08, 13042/08, 12950/08, 12980/08, 12953/08, 12983/08 12717/08, 12742/08, 12739/08, 12736/08, 12811/08, 12927/08 12847/08, 12846/08, 12930/08, 12841/08, 12956/08, 12870/08 12959/08, 12871/08, 12933/08, 12837/08, 12822/08, 12962/08 12965/08, 12849/08, 12890/08, 12936/08, 12968/08, 12874/08 12939/08, 12820/08, 12857/08, 13646/08, 13647/08, 13653/08 13654/08, 13655/08, 13656/08, 13658/08, 13660/08, 13666/08 13667/08 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Nutricia to be dismissed. 12733/08, 12728/08, 12808/08, 12895/08, 12903/08, 12826/08 12848/08, 12864/08, 12893/08, 12892/08, 12836/08, 12906/08 13668/08, 13670/08, 13672/08, 12731/08, 12725/08, 12898/08 12876/08, 12899/08, 12829/08, 12855/08, 12888/08, 12819/08 12840/08, 12851/08, 12896/08, 13669/08, 13671/08, 13673/08 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Brendish to be permanently stayed. 12707/08, 12715/08, 12719/08, 12735/08, 12738/08, 12740/08 12809/08, 12814/08, 12821/08, 12824/08, 12828/08, 12835/08 12845/08, 12850/08, 12854/08, 12860/08, 12863/08, 12877/08 12880/08, 12928/08, 12931/08, 12934/08, 12937/08, 12940/08 DECISION : 12943/08, 12946/08, 12948/08, 12951/08, 12954/08, 12957/08 12960/08, 12963/08, 12966/08, 12969/08, 12972/08, 12975/08 12978/08, 12981/08, 12984/08, 13702/08, 13703/08, 13704/08 13705/08, 13706/08, 13707/08, 13708/08, 13709/08, 13710/08 13711/08 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Brendish to be dismissed. 12722/08, 12724/08, 12727/08, 12730/08, 12812/08, 12813/08 12817/08, 12825/08, 12839/08, 12844/08, 12852/08, 12858/08 12861/08, 12867/08, 12872/08, 12873/08, 12885/08, 12886/08 12889/08, 12894/08, 12897/08, 12900/08, 12902/08, 12905/08 13712/08, 13713/08, 13714/08, 13715/08, 13716/08, 13717/08 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Sharpe to be permanently stayed. 12709/08, 12716/08, 12734/08, 12737/08, 12741/08, 12743/08 12815/08, 12816/08, 12827/08, 12832/08, 12834/08, 12842/08 12853/08, 12859/08, 12862/08, 12865/08, 12868/08, 12882/08 12887/08, 12929/08, 12932/08, 12935/08, 12938/08, 12941/08 12944/08, 12947/08, 12949/08, 12952/08, 12955/08, 12958/08 12961/08, 12964/08, 12967/08, 12970/08, 12973/08, 12976/08 12979/08, 12982/08, 12985/08, 13674/08, 13675/08, 13679/08 13681/08, 13682/08, 13684/08, 13686/08, 13689/08, 13690/08 13692/08 2008 Criminal Proceedings against Sharpe to be dismissed. 12723/08, 12726/08, 12729/08, 12732/08, 12810/08, 12818/08 12823/08, 12830/08, 12831/08, 12833/08, 12838/08, 12843/08 12856/08, 12866/08, 12869/08, 12875/08, 12878/08, 12879/08 12881/08, 12883/08, 12884/08, 12891/08, 12901/08, 12904/08 13693/08, 13694/08, 13697/08, 13698/08, 13699/08, 13700/08