Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council [2017] NSWLEC 1746

NSW Caselaw

Document text

Land and Environment Court New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Universal Property Group Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council [2017] NSWLEC 1746 Hearing dates: Conciliation conference on 18 & 24 October, 4 & 8 December 2017 Date of orders: 22 December 2017 Decision date: 22 December 2017 Jurisdiction: Class 1 Before: Bish C Decision: See (4) below Catchwords: DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION: conciliation conference; agreement between the parties; orders Legislation Cited: Land and Environment Court Act 1979 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Universal Property Group Pty Ltd (Applicant) Penrith City Council (Respondent) Representation: Counsel: Dr J Smith (Applicant) Solicitors: SWAAB Attorneys (Applicant) Mr Campbell, Penrith City Council (Respondent) File Number(s): 2017/173680 Publication restriction: No

Judgment 1. COMMISSIONER: In this matter, at or after a conciliation conference, an agreement under s 34(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (the Court Act) was reached 2. The Court Act also required me to "set out in writing the terms of the decision" (s 34(3)(b)). The orders made to give effect to the agreement constitute 3. In making the orders to give effect to the agreement between the parties, I was not required to make, and have not made, any merit assessment of the issues that were 4. The final orders to give effect to the parties' agreement under s34(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 are: 1. The Applicant is granted leave to rely upon the following amended material: Drawing No. and Issue Drawing Title CC-0000 (Rev 06) Cover Sheet CC-0001 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Notes Sheet 1 of 2 CC-0002 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Notes Sheet 2 of 2 CC-0003 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Survey Plan CC-0004 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Site Layout Plan CC-0005 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control CC-0006 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control CC-0007 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control CC-0008 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control Details CC-0009 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 1 of 3 CC-0010 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 2 of 3 CC-0011 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 3 of 3 CC-0012 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Sections CC-0013 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Typical Road Cross Sections CC-0014 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Pavement Details CC-0015 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 1 of 15 CC-0016 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 2 of 15 CC-0017 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 3 of 15 CC-0018 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 4 of 15 CC-0019 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 5 of 15 CC-0020 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 6 of 15 CC-0021 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 7 of 15 CC-0022 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 8 of 15 CC-0023 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 9 of 15 CC-0024 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 10 of 15 CC-0025 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 11 of 15 CC-0026 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 12 of 15 CC-0027 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 13 of 15 CC-0028 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 14 of 15 CC-0029 (Rev 03) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 15 of 15 CC-0033 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 1 of 3 CC-0034 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 2 of 3 CC-0035 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 3 of 3 CC-0036 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 8 CC-0037 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 8 CC-0038 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 8 CC-0039 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 4 of 8 CC-0040 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 5 of 8 CC-0041 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 6 of 8 CC-0042 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 7 of 8 CC-0043 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 8 of 8 CC-0044 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 2 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 2 CC-0045 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 2 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 2 CC-0046 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 5 CC-0047 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 5 CC-0048 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 5 CC-0049 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 4 of 5 CC-0050 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 5 of 5 CC-0051 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 4 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 1 CC-0052 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 3 CC-0053 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 3 CC-0054 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 3 CC-0055 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Setout Plan CC-0056 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Setout Table CC-0057 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 1 of 5 CC-0058 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 2 of 5 CC-0059 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 3 of 5 CC-0060 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 4 of 5 CC-0061 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 5 of 5 CC-0062 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Catchment Plan CC-0063 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 1 of 5 CC-0064 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 2 of 5 CC-0065 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 3 of 5 CC-0066 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 4 of 5 CC-0067 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 5 of 5 CC-0069 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Calculations Sheet 1 of 2 CC-0070 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Calculations Sheet 2 of CC-0071 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 1 of 4 CC-0072 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 2 of 4 CC-0073 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 3 of 4 CC-0074 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 4 of 4 CC-0080 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Pipe Support CC-0085 (Rev 01) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Sections CC-0090 (Rev 03) Stage 1: Residential Development Retaining Wall Details Stormwater Management Strategy, South Werrington Urban Village Precinct, Revision 8 dated 30 November 2017 between the parties as to the terms of a decision in the proceedings that was acceptable to the parties. As the presiding Commissioner, I was satisfied that the decision was one that the Court could have made in the proper exercise of its functions (this being the test applied by s 34(3) of the Court Act). As a consequence, s 34(3)(a) of the Act required me to "dispose of the proceedings in accordance with the decision". that document. originally in dispute between the parties. Prepared by Date of Plan Aurecon 20 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Plan Sheet 1 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Plan Sheet 2 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Plan Sheet 3 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Embankment Longitudinal Section Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017 Aurecon 30 November 2017

Read full text →

Official source

We try to embed the page this law was scraped from. If the site blocks framing, you still get the link and a local excerpt.

Not checked yet

Last checked with source on —

Open official source

Checking whether the official page can be embedded…

Study brief

Plain-English simplify of this law: a short summary, key points, and both sides of the argument. Generated on first view via Replicate, then cached. Vote on what helps your study.

Unknown

No study brief is cached for this law yet. Sign up to generate a plain-English brief.

You've got 21 of 22 free Acts left this visit. Sign up anytime for Facts, Related, and study briefs too.

Document text

Land and Environment Court New South Wales

Judgment 1. COMMISSIONER: In this matter, at or after a conciliation conference, an agreement under s 34(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (the Court Act) was reached between the parties as to the terms of a decision in the proceedings that was acceptable to the parties. As the presiding Commissioner, I was satisfied that the decision was one that the Court could have made in the proper exercise of its functions (this being the test applied by s 34(3) of the Court Act). As a consequence, s 34(3)(a) of the Act required me to "dispose of the proceedings in accordance with the decision". 2. The Court Act also required me to "set out in writing the terms of the decision" (s 34(3)(b)). The orders made to give effect to the agreement constitute that document. 3. In making the orders to give effect to the agreement between the parties, I was not required to make, and have not made, any merit assessment of the issues that were originally in dispute between the parties. 4. The final orders to give effect to the parties' agreement under s34(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 are: 1. The Applicant is granted leave to rely upon the following amended material: Drawing No. and Issue Drawing Title Prepared by Date of Plan CC-0000 (Rev 06) Cover Sheet Aurecon 20 November 2017 CC-0001 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Notes Sheet 1 of 2 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0002 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Notes Sheet 2 of 2 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0003 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Survey Plan Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0004 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Site Layout Plan Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0005 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control Plan Sheet 1 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0006 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control Plan Sheet 2 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0007 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control Plan Sheet 3 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0008 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Erosion and Sediment Control Details Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0009 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 1 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0010 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 2 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0011 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Plan Sheet 3 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0012 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Sections Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0013 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Typical Road Cross Sections Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0014 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Pavement Details Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0015 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 1 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0016 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 2 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0017 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 3 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0018 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 4 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0019 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 5 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0020 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 6 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0021 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 7 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0022 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 8 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0023 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 9 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0024 (Rev 07) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 10 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0025 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 11 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0026 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 12 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0027 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 13 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0028 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 14 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0029 (Rev 03) Stage 1: Residential Development General Arrangement Plan Sheet 15 of 15 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0033 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 1 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0034 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 2 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0035 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Longitudinal Section Sheet 3 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0036 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0037 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0038 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0039 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 4 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0040 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 5 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0041 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 6 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0042 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 7 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0043 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 1 Cross Section Sheet 8 of 8 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0044 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 2 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 2 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0045 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 2 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 2 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0046 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0047 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0048 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0049 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 4 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0050 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 3 Cross Section Sheet 5 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0051 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 4 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 1 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0052 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 1 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0053 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 2 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0054 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road 5 Cross Section Sheet 3 of 3 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0055 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Setout Plan Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0056 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Road Setout Table Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0057 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 1 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0058 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 2 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0059 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 3 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0060 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 4 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0061 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Intersection Details Sheet 5 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0062 (Rev 06) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Catchment Plan Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0063 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 1 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0064 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 2 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0065 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 3 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0066 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 4 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0067 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Longsections Sheet 5 of 5 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0069 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Calculations Sheet 1 of 2 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0070 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Calculations Sheet 2 of Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0071 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 1 of 4 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0072 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 2 of 4 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0073 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 3 of 4 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0074 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Drainage Details Sheet 4 of 4 Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0080 (Rev 05) Stage 1: Residential Development Stormwater Pipe Support Embankment Longitudinal Section Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0085 (Rev 01) Stage 1: Residential Development Earthworks Sections Aurecon 30 November 2017 CC-0090 (Rev 03) Stage 1: Residential Development Retaining Wall Details Aurecon 30 November 2017 Stormwater Management Strategy, South Werrington Urban Village Precinct, Revision 8 dated 30 November 2017

Read full text →