Queensland STIPENDIARY MAGISTRATES AND OTHER ACTS AMENDMENT BILL Queensland oh STIPENDIARY MAGISTRATES AND OTHER ACTS AMENDMENT BILL 1999 TABLE OF PROVISIONS Section Page Hn nA ff WwW NY PART 1—PRELIMINARY Short title 200... 4 PART 2—AMENDMENT OF STIPENDIARY MAGISTRATES ACT 1991 Act amended in pt2 .......... cee eee ee 4 Amendment of s 3 (Definition). ..........0... 0.000.000 02 cee eee eee 4 Amendment of s 5 (Appointment of Magistrates) ................000-5 5 Amendment of s 10 (Functions of Chief Stipendiary Magistrate) ........ 6 Insertion of new ss 10A to 101... 6... eee eee 8 10A Establishment of judicial committee. ..............0.--.00005 8 10B Function of judicial committee ............... 0... 8 10C Composition of committee ....... 0.0... eee eee eee 8 10D Request for review... 66... 8 10E Powers of committee on review ........ 2... eee eee eee ees 9 1OF Procedure ..... 6.0... ccc eeeeten eee 9 10G Stay of operation and implementation of determination pending review... 1.6.66. ccc eee ee 9 10H Magistrate to give Chief Stipendiary Magistrate notice of application ..... 6.6.6... cece eect eee 10 101 No further review... 2.2... 0... cee eee 10 Insertion of new s 18A... 1.6... ieee eens 10 18A Magistrate may request transfer determination................. 10 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment 8 Insertion of news 24 1.2... cee 11 24 Transitional provision for Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment Act 1999... 0.00.0... 2 eee eee eee 11 PART 3—AMENDMENT OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 1992 9 Act amended in pt3 2... 6... eect tee eee 12 10 Amendment of s 11 (Act not to apply to certain bodies etc.) ........... 12 PART 4—AMENDMENT OF JUDICIAL REVIEW ACT 1991 11 Act amended in pt4 2.0... 6... eect teens 13 12 Amendment of sch 1 (Operation of other laws) ...................0.. 13 A BILL FOR An Act to amend the Stipendiary Magistrates Act 1991, and for other purposes sl 4 s3 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment The Parliament of Queensland enacts— PART 1—PRELIMINARY Short title Clause 1. This Act may be cited as the Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment Act 1999. PART 2—AMENDMENT OF STIPENDIARY MAGISTRATES ACT 1991 Act amended in pt 2 Clause 2. This part amends the Stipendiary Magistrates Act 1991. Amendment of s 3 (Definition) Clause 3. Section 3— insert— ' "Chief Judge" means the Chief Judge of the District Court. "Chief Justice" means the Chief Justice of Queensland. "committee" means the judicial committee established under section 10A. "reviewable determination" means— (a) a determination of the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate under section 5(5) or 10(2)(a) about the place at which a magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court, other than a _ temporary determination; or 113151820 Clause s4 5 s4 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment (b) a refusal by the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate under section 18A(3)(b) to make a determination requested under section 18A(2). "temporary determination" has the meaning given by section 10(6).'. Amendment of s 5 (Appointment of Magistrates) 4.(1) Section 5(2) to (4)— renumber as section 5(6) to (8). (2) Section 5— insert— '(2) Before making a recommendation to the Governor in Council about the appointment of a magistrate, the Minister must first consult with the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate. '(3) The appointment of a magistrate must state and has effect to determine— (a) the place where the magistrate is first to constitute a Magistrates Court appointed under the Justices Act 1886, section 22B(1)(c); and (b) the period, not longer than 5 years, the magistrate is to constitute the Magistrates Court at the place. "(4) However, the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate and the magistrate may agree that the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court at another place for an agreed period before the period mentioned in subsection (3)(b) ends. "(5) Despite subsection (3) and before the period mentioned in subsection (3)(b) ends, the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate may, for good reason directly related to the magistrate, determine that the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court at a place other than the place mentioned in subsection (3)(a). Examples of good reasons— . the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate has disciplined the magistrate under section 10(8) and a transfer is necessary to maintain community confidence in the court BR WPF ont nwn 1114 1619 2124 2630 s5 6 s5 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment + the magistrate's incompatibility with the local community + the magistrate's incompatibility with another magistrate at the place is 2 detrimental to the efficient functioning of the court.'. 3 Amendment of s 10 (Functions of Chief Stipendiary Magistrate) 4 Clause 5.(1) Section 10(2)(a), 'section 22'— 5 omit, insert— 6 "section 22B(1)(c)'. 7 (2) Section 10(3)— 8 omit. 9 (3) Section 10(4), "(3)(d)'— 10 omit, insert— 11 "(8)(d)'. 12 (4) Section 10(6), "(3)'— 13 omit, insert— 14 "(8). 15 (5) Section 10(4) to (6)— 16 renumber as section 10(9) to (11). 17 (6) Section 10, subsection (2A)— 18 renumber as subsection (3). 19 (7) Section 10— 20 insert— 21 "(4) The Chief Stipendiary Magistrate must not make a determination 22 under subsection (2)(a) about the place at which a magistrate is to constitute 23 a Magistrates Court unless the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate— 24 (a) first— 25 (i) consults with the magistrate; and 26 s5 7 s5 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment (11) gives the magistrate written notice of the proposed maximum period that the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court at the place; and (b) has sufficient and reasonable regard to the magistrate's personal circumstances and all other relevant considerations. "(5) The Chief Stipendiary Magistrate must give a magistrate written notice of a determination under subsection (2)(a) stating— (a) the place the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court; and (b) the period the magistrate is to constitute the Magistrates Court at the place; and (c) the reasons for the determination. "(6) However, subsection (4) does not apply if— (a) because of urgent circumstances, the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate makes a determination (a "temporary determination") under subsection (2)(a) about the place at which a magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court; and (b) under the temporary determination, the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court at the place for no longer than 3 months. "(7) To remove doubt, it is declared that subsection (4) does not affect a condition of appointment or agreement under section 5(3) or (4). "(8) The Chief Stipendiary Magistrate may discipline by way of reprimand a magistrate who, to the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate's satisfaction— (a) is seriously incompetent or inefficient in the discharge of the administrative duties of office; or (b) is seriously negligent, careless or indolent in the discharge of the administrative duties of office; or (c) is guilty of misconduct; or (d) is absent from duty without leave or reasonable excuse; or oO TDW ND ns WNe Se Se Ne eeu DAns w ile' on Ne cow NNN WNe NN ns Nw Na NN 'io @ $6 8 $6 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment (e) wilfully fails to comply with a reasonable direction given by the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate or a magistrate authorised to give the direction; or (f) is guilty of conduct unbecoming a magistrate.'. Insertion of new ss 10A to 101 Clause 6. After section 10— insert— 'Establishment of judicial committee "10A. A judicial committee (the ""committee") is established. 'Function of judicial committee '10B. The committee's function is to review a reviewable determination on receipt of a written request from a magistrate aggrieved by the determination. "Composition of committee "10C.(1) The members of the committee for each review are— (a) the Chief Justice or a judge of the Supreme Court nominated by the Chief Justice; and (b) the Chief Judge or a judge of the District Court nominated by the Chief Judge; and (c) a judge of either the Supreme Court or the District Court nominated by the Chief Justice. '(2) The committee may be constituted for more than 1 review at any time with the same or different membership for each review. "Request for review '10D.(1) A magistrate aggrieved by a reviewable determination may request the committee to review the determination. BR Wnye Cc oN nDwN 1215 17 19 21 23 26 $6 9 $6 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment '(2) The request must be given to the committee in writing within 14 days after the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate gives written notice of the reviewable determination to the magistrate. 'Powers of committee on review "10E.(1) The committee must consider the merits of the reviewable determination and either affirm it or substitute its own different determination. "(2) If the committee makes its own determination, that determination has effect. 'Procedure "10F.(1) The committee has full and unfettered discretion to determine its own procedure when conducting a review. '(2) When conducting a review, the committee is not bound— (a) by the rules of evidence; or (b) to conduct any oral or public hearing; or (c) to permit a party to the review to be legally represented. "(3) The committee may conduct a review solely on the basis of the written materials it considers appropriate. "(4) The Chief Justice may issue directions for the procedure for a review. 'Stay of operation and implementation of determination pending review '10G.(1) The operation and implementation of a reviewable determination, other than a refusal to make a determination under section 18A(3)(b), is stayed if a magistrate, the subject of the reviewable determination, requests the committee to review the determination. '(2) The stay is effective from the time the magistrate gives the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate a copy of the request under section 10H. wn CM ADM Bp 12 1416 18 20 22 24 26 28 Clause s7 10 s7 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment "Magistrate to give Chief Stipendiary Magistrate notice of application "10H. A magistrate who requests a review under section 10D is to give a copy of the request to the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate as soon as possible after requesting the review. 'No further review "101.(1) A determination made under section 10E— (a) is final and conclusive; and (b) can not be challenged, appealed against, reviewed, quashed, set aside, or called in question in another way, under the Judicial Review Act 1991 or otherwise whether by the Supreme Court, another court, a tribunal or another entity; and (c) is not subject to a writ or order of the Supreme Court, another court, a tribunal or another entity on any ground. "(2) In this section— "determination" includes— (a) conduct engaged in to make a determination; and (b) conduct related to making a determination; and (c) failure to make a determination.'. Insertion of new s 18A 7. After section 18— insert— "Magistrate may request transfer determination "18A.(1) This section applies if a magistrate has constituted a Magistrates Court at a place for at least— (a) for a magistrate appointed under section 5(3) or given a notice under section 10(5)—the period stated in the appointment or notice; or RwWN 2022 24 26 Clause s8 11 s8 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment (b) fora magistrate who constitutes a Magistrates Court at a place for a period agreed under section 5(4)—the period agreed; or (c) fora magistrate who constitutes a Magistrates Court at a place at the commencement of this section—S years. '(2) The magistrate may request the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate to determine under section 10(2)(a) that the magistrate is to constitute a Magistrates Court at another place. "(3) Within 28 days of receiving the request, the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate must— (a) agree to make the determination; or (b) refuse to make the determination. "(4) If the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate refuses to make the determination, the Chief Stipendiary Magistrate must give written notice to the magistrate within 14 days of the refusal. "(5) The notice must state the reasons for refusing to make the determination. "(6) To remove doubt, it is declared that for subsection (1)(c) the period that a magistrate constitutes a Magistrates Court at a place includes any period that the magistrate has constituted the court at the place before the commencement of this section.'. Insertion of new s 24 8. After section 23— insert— 'Transitional provision for Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment Act 1999 '24.(1) This section applies to a reviewable determination made under section 10(2)(a) between 31 March 1999 and the commencement of section 6 of the Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment Act 1999 (the "amending Act"). CO IDM BW NY eS eK Oo See BRWN eR num Nee SOonMN 2225 2729 Clause Clause s9 12 s10 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment "(2) A magistrate aggrieved by the determination may request a review under section 10D as if the determination had been made after the commencement of section 6 of the amending Act. "(3) The request must be given to the committee within 14 days of the commencement of this section. "(4) Ifa magistrate requests a review under subsection (2), the magistrate may not— (a) seek a review of the determination under the Judicial Review Act 199] or any other Act; or (b) challenge or appeal against the determination or ask for it to be reviewed, quashed, set aside, or called in question in another way before the Supreme Court, another court, a tribunal or other entity. "(5) Ifa magistrate requests a review under subsection (2), after starting a proceeding mentioned in subsection (4)(a) or (b), that proceeding is terminated. "(6) This section expires | year after it commences.'. PART 3—AMENDMENT OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 1992 Act amended in pt 3 9. This part amends the Freedom of Information Act 1992. Amendment of s 11 (Act not to apply to certain bodies etc.) 10. Section 11(1)(g)— omit, insert— "(g) the judicial committee established under the Stipendiary Magistrates Act 1991, section 10A; or'. ao ND WAR WHY \o RP Re NRO Ree nan BW e a 18 20 2225 Clause Clause sll 13 $12 Stipendiary Magistrates and Other Acts Amendment PART 4—AMENDMENT OF JUDICIAL REVIEW ACT Act amended in pt 4 11. This part amends the Judicial Review Act 1991. Amendment of sch 1 (Operation of other laws) 12. Schedule 1, part 2— insert— '5. Stipendiary Magistrates Act 1991, sections 5(5), 10(2)(a), 10E and 18A(3)(b)'. © State of Queensland 1999 Como NN Dw