» i? Cn on Cte MON, ; - CATCHVIORDS ' ~o, i ' ' on . , . TRADE PPACTICES - Exhibition of talev21 tembination ct vroducts sinliar te the arolicant - Pessibility of 71avwers 241 cffer was maadé on Dehalf of applicanc question co be triad as to misleadins respondent. Farkdale Custom Buiic Turriture Pty Linited v7 Puxu Po. Eamited (13982) 149 C.L.R. 131 applisd. SOFYRISHT - Test to be adopred in relatisn co surficiency of case to sueecrc grant of inte:rlocutery say aaccian - What @2saliigs consultute infringement of ctreyright 11 fila - Tafscingement of copyrighce an film scrisc ALL script - What coms tarutes reproduction o iz Australian Taar52 Grain Pool Pty Liawiced Ecard of Suestsiand 113282) 16 A.L.B. a. Fey Limited v Peanut asketing Boarca wilt, Hayden (1921) 55 A.L.R. 72. Exitoma Pty mie "eak Industry Emplores = Jnien (192+ f1 ALL.R 720, Agpl> Computer Inc v Computec Edge Pey Srmrt2a (it94) 55 Alo.F. IDS. Ladbeske 'Football! Limited v wWilitae Gill + Fesctkeali = £1354] 1 W.L 272 apolied. Applecir Faciss racer Pty bx 2d 323) 50 ALLA. 420, Dee oi eltv Studics c ¢ 46 2.0.R. 13 Ask e £135 . 723 refers Act 1lasd Wilcox J. LD Tuly 13385 Sydney vp ee u a oi at [>| nm J my A o . rm oF irl Cul 4° ub Et w Uk 4 0 ar Oh 7 =) te tho ua vd C37) wot Ls) -- ttl rr ' td tt, tr 44 tin tte Patel an i ot Rta rg okt alts i ee fo i nf wn Cole | ee | nm 4 + Wns ' 1 oh ! rey Ld fol bid 41 Ht a 5 fiers bi wm ott {1 an [jie . in {c] 1 cy vate Ftd . set 1] Fi ia) qr] Q fen [an | yl 4 wit Ls SIE Tae 3 ay] ert d djs al? roles EAs CHE OH ebay Oy € arty) (ra) Fae] ralin acl 4 Oy fu ey 2 a, ria ei I m wi ay isK Ma bi 1] a 53 a is cD ty Lae i HI rt el an f4 2 be fl me +t 7 > H Ly we ry a ** [a 2, ss Ec fry af hyp 5 mm) FL ey id oO; amy 4 a conor a Py a eA Ltr lene — ie Sete el U3) bay uw roa ch oO et G Q ae Lt u Oy chy a) qs Ey ra) " it aD] ny ooey ") D ww r) zy te ey mation, - che c25pect of 1ni I] " Wy ee Neen OFA ree ne en me te IN THE FEDERAL COURT JF AUSTPALIA NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY flo. 0.345 oF Uidd GENERAL DIVES BEDWEED; TELMAK TELESrcovors ETVY 2IMrITeab TOOL CORPORATION AND * TERNAT Pxth TOTN MEBIA LIN FST LIMITED DIRAM: MILCIZ F el 4]28 ONS Fon TUDSHENT = - oe - - ~ a amet on -- a Eo purchase by telephone order "three in one" packs Linctaining power sc:ewdriver, a hand nail-driver and a seb o stores, for many years. However, in ce befeses the yen L257. the 1de&a was cunceivec, aprarsntiy in the United Zrates. rf geiling tne three components in combina For ar aeévectisemenc incended ts be Shean on Amer otan television. in Cures 19393 he mad) a celavisioo aavert.:sment assignment executed by h2m tn April 13385. whats a Dy w uw i) rs tH ue] oc o a] pars =] iy f i] ct hae ny iL ry fa I-ra)wo 1B \ i ye te FE ine., a Florida corporation and the seccme applicant om tals ~S yt Par ~ =: es = ee - = - . - wsecesedings. Gull Advertising, if would aesear, acted cL: menalio oF Slital Tool Cciparatiin, 2172 a Fil laa role ilaiocr co Che contrary. Io ase me Toe the Oiagtlles 22 ee ee te eee ma Bh me yee te ne We. Fk international P:otection) xeyulasiscns. fhamited, the Cirsc aoplicanc, prpade an agreement wich Gllt Teimak''s production house. The yvoucs-over scrist wan alalst adentical to the Ant soviet. Toownt acs camilar usvenc manner, the Austyallan vayelon being louder ani evan moc? kesathless chan the Ame:icar. The visual mot Cee Fuse Mas tye G Chas 22a ede monreritls fimo it has seen sacwn, ana ut on Australian commercial television channels. fc has, a pparently, been succe "three it one" pack, which nas sold well y the is a - : 84s mn t7.7 - TOGl:, My BR GO Valounger, joLac Tntez:nationai, set about the oraduccion of a nev ceseondern® tc refer to this corpacy. ASpLLlLaGTS Eur their clanm fir relief ones - ffeat, they cclyp ares dyes tiseient, Lao-- isn esaduc. les a. Qdaceivs., Fear lly, rasl ~OnSb lu Teas an infringement of the coreyeight in one or more af the American seriet, the American film, Telmnak's Australlan scec.it or Telmak's Australian falm, » 7 ~ wa Wale a New Seuen WaLes te ltab © tion b demonstra decisions to suggest that, if thees be a f.iference. Tis Beecham Crour test 15 tO be arpl1ac ta cases cf antellic between the pactzies and that the Cormula is mct ts re canstrued o: applied in 2 .igia wanner 32 45 Tf it were ta ts t ul ie] rh feb) rs fu ui cr te ir i ia iH I We] Gs aa be ra) fo TT fe u be) vu4 in ty i T a im) abe mn tu a Trade Practices Act, if may be Shostly aise vsed 35. Ne nas pesn made out Justirying the giant of aa questicn to ce trisd in ralation te tue coaslarat thot showing of the film const2ztutes misleating or decepruvye . eo. . -~a & mh, rae — =-JTee 4 = rar . appaicants pointed to the fact that, altnucugh the soe se of the «s2o¢ttive "three in one" sackageas wars ack wadividueally available, tne revporicent had cnosen i252. the name theee rtems for tale in ree Lune. ad, at be ee - wen ne + p= gy ce Vee neg soap a sactaéage cy similiar veans and to a tiealas cele. lear ct. Beet =. aye fhe roe eel wee ea ep He ee gee Muaig@l Austapted THAD Tae mocks i e.2 ilk TIP Tl lus wal aet iT r F rs ry Wy C? re th al tn il ye ur th ts tw ut 2. Similar proacuct vas lasurficiens to constitute misieaiog a. ey eceptive conduct: see Parkdale Custsar Suilt Fusnwture Fee Limited v Puxu Peoy Limited (1942) Lit C.L.R. 132. Fe nded, however, that tne cho1ie by the resounaenct of a ve oO al a af peecisely similar combinac viewers into the belief Tace on = resoondent's advertisement was an otfer being wide cr benalt or Telmak, whose advertisement had been shown con televisiis over a consiGerable serind and had become well knosn. IT ds net think that this contentira can 3.57175 2 consideration of the Film and of the sctip v ust watik 2t 1s based. The vespondent's advertisement 15 aiifs:eat ts that of oh -- and advertises. The First mention in bue voice-over s2llet SF tas mare sdues = fanbaatea: win eons - - . — taceoduce 4 fantastic ¢cres.drives isventisn -- BD Re el Supa Drill". The statement is Leo tak sl 1S2 Thal ole Leolemenc was not Srevisisly "unoimn us a 'Supa Tl.l. 143 at ut Tao net tuind chat anyone wnhu Lal a clea Oa LY) mn 2 no "4 a 4 rt %y way t ao ' . | 3 uy Oo et or : "y ty rt a 4 ah ' Di rd my ed ty 17 . a ta ! I " 4 4 I 1 im ws ' wy Ly Na 4 n a ! ty is) i] 4 1 | "y wy ua Dn ra ny iY a v) od oF om yt ve " "3 Sa it ny S ' my q ery Sy ra 'Sr rm ut fh W ' rv : ' 1 '"D . w on) at Ip Ae ' ra) Ls ', nN ie) ivy vu rt n ad re 3 ot € yy 4 ua iz n 1 on ut a on ot ot bg 4 y "4 te I ' mu 3 ur 13 wi ty = a m ray a al isi 4 i ay > an f % a yu a4 ray mh - al a Ht " a 3 a oh 4 { 3 Sey dow an W 1 12 7~ 4 ma wa % wr m4 2 fe) Lb 42 'LD ran "19 Us) 3 Ca ") 3 mn td al ng "y "4 cs al bos y a4 L _ Q a Hh ra) vy ny 4 4 ly a) n yf a rl ia) m™ ty Ip ua iu "a ft i= "% L rd ray J bad Q a on ala ef ts o 11 fio a he pa] ™ ofa tc) * 4 ol ma goo . wa a in GW os a oF] o &i rt a u . 7] re tay rl oO "ny wy Fo WD 4 oy ts Vv ot at tot . i) ° q vj . vet 44 m rt Io u ur at = bea 4) ez ua noo "4 Ew a) ue dd i) ' tr, ad Wy n es) a tt pt iP ed OS Wu iP) i) 4 pay tr al bad yor a] Cr ac m1 rr 2 sf Oo) a a wD ot c O13) rp ne ny Q ay ye m 4 a) ed i) QO Qa ? ni sl - a 4 blr im La Qo sof Ua el fa) 3 Oo my -t 0 ay ny w 4 2 ' Qa 3 a a "t 4) tm ty vu wa wen LY " Ay av " 4 of 3 aod $? hy mo% ty 4 tw t 3 moet re) rd EF ot rf oi] 3 a tho ae La mm a cs yy m uy yy Na 1 a wy In 3 hoe "4 it is o fa) M s Sa u ) most iD) au most s By orl a et ww Dad ui . n . we as! mom rt Qo Qu ' vy ra SI - o aw oa) ie] wo 4 Jd 9 oy 4 c pea c ad o ed uv & 3 v & ung esl ap my mm od 9 0 % S oOo a3 qt 3 ron] Na "4 ie) 4 rd cal 3 d U3) in 'y 2 ong n mug "% 't LP vp y ny yaa Na 4G -t Poa aa) Da WW " ua i) tt a is] % n a iQ at rl os] ut " 1) 4 coo i wd vy ia nA ~ - a) a mom J [s) ri Qa 0 mo ry mt in) . " Q 3) ag dd . . ~ ~ ~ foot - GG 3 > 0 ba wy ue Ae) wy e s 4 a aoe i» 'Db G&G oo ou al 2 o cl ay At Re G Oo ob 4 4) Hd iS 4 in /* 3 38 4 8 - Ga ra) = wi & th ba is a) "} 4 te By] at i) Pl fad Wor4 Ah 40 oc m™ 4} ba " p ot | Ma Vv a yong 3 Ba ie wt dq 4 m oO a 4 " tl es ng gt Dv uy iB] "ha Md mn ta u " antes aliecs, Subsecticn (1) praiv2zdes that, subject c2 che Act, "a copyright subsistiag by viccue of this Fasec 12 infringed by a werson whe, not being the oemer cf "hs and 35.192 and 1S2 deal witn scre 123 own agenis. Wnacsver the serlet sf tlhe fila ray have owed to the films of the avplicants, the cloves vent ad... 12 make a "cooy" of sicher if tns applitance fFlleo. Tro tar "sooy" acs defined in 53.19 cf the ead .Flabicr ca a Fils, a5 meaning Bl SOURCS meh Comretanass mak ke n voor ttt orn at 7 ep ee Anca souneas hich togyscaec make up the 2.127 tbigvag.. 22l.s r2 7 > =—""6 s-wt soe Wooi of, Uwe 2204 Ll 05n09 De) Wy Lae ! ad Na 4 y 4 " - Ly fT ay ee VW 1 I aa 5) J if oe] pr 4a Wa di . a oy mtg AS "a wy 1 m my wh oan ry fe Ma ds ' 9 . a " ' 1 ry " my 1 t v4 " n : Ly " iD oa oe] my 4 nm i a) te H " Q so yt ay a 4 'yn d mt 4 at nd 2» "5 yy Ao Ya im) 1 i d at ut Za ut 4 ae w q) ey i nm rip] 1 fo ha wa te 3 a i ry et " ' 3] a dr 4 1 qe nm wu n Hee " . 4 ae vy t 2 re rd a a) uu af " ry re yy ba ra ' ot wy th . or d w vhs ad vt c Cal "i d ry Ls | as J c WwW i ot wy} ta Lo Gg 4 rl au 1 al uw Da i w rd 2 cl pa fa pa Ed ou S De) m yy w tha ur ' 43 i aod s im) ua et u \ a wa 20044 my dy Ss o4 rod . By) z a) is] 'S 3 Sa u a) i rd "y e do wm 40 rd woot i) . a vy m BN] et qt 4 a S Dl ny Wa 7 a2 b ra a) Sul hs) "a 4 3 ny fy ry mw a 43 | <a uy a oc ' oa a wom Ma Lm rt re] fe) 3 ie 3 By Cu ' b oc dU ay ie) "4 , wn W4 iy >} ord a et Ut dd 4 , my hed a) m ff ") 4 i ul Th fed v mm od is a ' i "4d es) Woh yp cl ow ta) a oa se¢ 'y "5 re . i . a a) oO A Ado tu 4 My 4) Dm In sy . 3 n wa ' iy if 9) 9 fa) n ce a 13 w z - v 2 + ' od ty rc) ad a wo ay] s4 'y > et Ray ny m Dy] ay Pl rt rh Qs Q a nh tT] ie) . (PR) a] 4 art ae) 4 - at ) 7) + ma wy MS aor w oP) 1 he uv 7 ua if | ou oo go 4 sa ce | Oh Os a hoo B ip 1 -4 wD my 3 a q oy ny yod cd i LY 7 9 Pay nm ba ", t Oe 4) t wy te On) LY St m . i= rt "| 3 a a3 m7 r4 J Sa rt Ur) nt 4! wv DF] a ct Lay ia) Dy Lv) 4 y o rd 9 w at 3 d & Du & 42 ay qe iB) er w Dy uy per) ty wt wy bey u 7 q mR 44 OW 43 or) uv uot 3 wot b . 43 t on > ka 1% v b 4) dt at n) yt v He) bell . n DH en oa mo iy a poof vy oof Ne fia st a4 "a ri 2 gf OO mM 4 a i os a4 [el bY 1) - wd be xt a a) ad ar oq 43 rf ™ fan) oO ) a wl 4 By ae) o sod Et 4 D Sa do op w W is) ey Sa ie) ne] ul fey d ris ba " PB oo cd na thy Ce da WwW a u . n) fal Pr mB RP Yt <i » a a so Ro St ) s 3 o a) 4 fe] . Na b ia) fs) " dod > a rd Sot 4 7 oO wood bt) a BD n a 1 a fs) 4 > & > oO g . nq et ie Pa we Us) u ny a uy ao el By nm 41 wooys od ay p ' Po oO al gy a bs Dp as) -! . u fis] wu i ty cot y n . ia ce OF] "y a cy au a4 n 4a ia] mH a) is) ra) 3 nn a LY) w Ei a n yw o 13 g et wu " al t "4d fm) hy yp d 3) Ed "s 43 4? Te) wi ¥-4 a rity Ny d a) b ny ' r4 fe a dd ES) vw 4; 4a od . mG 13) if) wv as W a . rt 3 ~ oka in WW cial Qo vp ns as at ay aa] ity t Oy u La] y ny Ls) S wu rt ") ~ ie] qe a - = ry 4 co G3 gq fal d a od ir org Sa 43 ort pol G > Ke i od Se ry "4 ry a fi] et Sy ue uy uw DP) rd Se an Q uw iv wy rm OQ wm nay bey fa] no Qa Dd 4 ty S pel Jom m it yp oMN uw Q p oe hw ow ' mo nt) mm Oo a uu ta re) ay 1) ord td ie) ag rd Ray 3 Pa ct u fe) a . bp G@ 4 a 7 nS) 4 mn 4) mf ~ ne es | - u? n % u oo wk "y wv 3 7 '4 ny 4 ef wd rz) in) ' wu he " t me G} 4 io ' at 3 ' M4 ws my ud 1 a wf cay n 1) 8 tf a 1 wd " ay J In A 1% ry n an rary ia] + ni ' 1 1 wd e D Wa Ma ny 1" g Ad ne ' , 4 nm ut u al uw nig Ean re at ? rh ed -t We i i} t? t ry at 42 ty y ty L' . i tb Sa "a ' 12 ca et t "1 a - t* ua ie] 1 "a 1 if 4 wt 4 iy 4a ? ny uw m m4 £. ? ay fat : i fa) Es "4 a " a 1 ur y a iP) Sa 4 i 4 ' - . twa i * ay ™ i ed ia) ut = , 1 . he Ny gi 45 Pan ad rr] ce M4 a A ny ? 4a it wt it et 4d aa ie) at 1 tr 4a nf a Skt ug 3 3 ng ia wr at ca f 7 ut c a3 tet Ov 'S be i M4 2 y ia] ys od wi fa] mH wd 1 Wa - es "s mn nd 4 d ") cl ai n 1} " el a i? t rl al tr 1 Ley We 1 wg coy "4 it ery any tt bi 2 my 3 3 i) mya 12 ha tka rs) moe ca Ni ad ary ay itd 14 m n z 4 fay 4 d fe vb ari 9 1 43 a) L n uy > 15 a n wD a rd a "y or 4 7 n Vy wW "tt a) ad rd 4 rel 3 w Se cy ps a rT iad g, iz i . - at a 4 woo yw ad i t ' Bd n - oH a v ot o R ct "di a3 42 re) Le) 57] Ww a my bn a = " en) { ce] iy a a L 12 5 mF H im ny fi a ir rt tl 7 Nt ct fy] wa 13 12 W rf a a) a Ww rd wa 3) LP) Ler hm . Ne Na oO ray ay u . . Na my . Ae bs fal i) q fu baa Ly ar Pe) hy a v 43 1 iy Wy a al ny ad D oc 43 " O14 m i] . 4 ca Py ey am 3 v 4 aA is] 4 { 4a a is Q % is | Sa ha ca oy "a i] Mog. 4 Boy " S& 3 O (tf ow og ob ed ty fai Ww rl "I ay Ww mn ba o 4 a3 mn qo et n u o . ty ! ie] Dh 43 u a w Na may Oy st 4 " 11 5 : i "4 a + oad tr] ™ cs) oy ba oo ay a 43 )y oy uy Pay fy] Ou wu ih Th 1 ~ " = os rl pe Ns oe fe) d a "ty rt 3 ay ww wy ") o <6 ogo ad ot a s* i) ul wat Q te et au <4 al sa 7 & al u Foal LM ay Dal fe] ct m sel 12 . Ww isi " Sly on ny nS ot u rt p "y fe) am) oa we - Wy ba m 44 wt Ma a 4 m Tyas wu at ay al m ey 'h Wr uy in ae) d a mn ay in . al c Ww at) uy 42 uy Ww d a) De iy nt gy - 4a 406 4d vo Q, tu Pay wa Pa Sore | fom spt bay 43 fal Shy al Ww a > ba thy Sa ia) ut fon cd ay ha ro pars n) La yy ON d fal a 3 u Tred pay rs) 03 a Qo 1 a u ay n t) " d ia r ny at 4) 1s - 5. aaildriver and "drive" Foe "deill", the 'Oa and thez¢ 15 an addition oF mail seder informaticn 427 cone Lamated £19643 1 W.L.R. 273 anc Avple Uoouress In- (1334) 52 A.LLR. 225. Ir 213 encuen, Fac sra8ant vurkiges, ct. £ T2oT.s - Tort eflinciplas emergang .som WES Sle TNT Lockthars g. at p.258 of his weraaic i irai.z 2 Wo The and be lw eof aLLi and fa] Ea ee + sfogiraLt + c t 1ec835a £ fe 4 ist ce 1 ae iy Ma al to 13 oo 2 ca) a , ul eLoory ite . 1% a 4 hy wt ") ow con te a Ae] Y ni) on oy 5 os faa tr) rm Le La] 42 ray QW ay . wy Ne un . in if ga 1 3 . 1 ' t rd | . th ny rt ie) ry) Le my hy tJ uv' fh ae] 4 Rei ) wt ' H a a ed at 4 . tho ng a oa od by " ay y Na . 1 Ny rd Ww tt qt y "4 w 3 . ea Me 1 Ny oy 4 dd rd Ww > Wd "4 at D4 13 ay { L . .! ny 1 qt w rd t) "r ul 4 2 Ou gy ' { 'nh m at 1 : ? FE ! a = at 4 dd FT ral i] faa vl . at 43 "y rey qy or 5 td fl 1 ct 3 at ri a] Pd wv 13 ad "ed *y a ) Ui) up er a a rd 1 fA gt It y uy aa Re} rH t) an et aA eal q 1 N4 % i) fa 1) c tt R 4 fui 13 my a ot f Ny v ft Ing 4 4s rd St rt " « UG at i 4) sl} Dal a ce] Ia ' a w iy 73 4 at ad og qd "a Bom Oo my YVooQ wa F ye Fs ce) ny} et) i) ® 1 4) cy n 3 | uw 1 J NS 4 d iw ey rd he uw is) rd t" ia 5 aa) : "4 a 1) 4 oad tt 2 a) "3 a ae) ry p Hy ny 43 (=) <4 ty) ry ve wt my Q m 4s n rq ha oor S aot sf GD mm oP) on in Sa tS Eel iv) ef n ay wv " a nd io] iG is) Doo. ny 3 ars nm m iS) Lo) Sa a iP) oO wy a] 4 u ino a vat Ww ar) m wv Na G q . aa rt 04 a Ww a > a Dd fly fea 3 aj dD By is) bast 7 oy " too GS 4 toy ose . st Dr 3 + bs) nyo 4 ord zy d 2 a 3 ra] 4 £8 " I ty Lv "9 3 fd rf D "3 u "1 "4 ny Wy WO 7 oC M4 vy ws wa a " ") 2 " tr 4 UD fac] 1 we 4s ad gy 4) 4) irs] z wD nm if wa el "ys <1 ut wa 0] ui fet . m qd m 4 I" m at a oO ) im cS ae re a fo 4% fa uy . a 4 ay "4 d Wy y 4) FA a ard a Yoo wt m sa 3 Sa el 4 rs) a 4 a Om, 73 i) an m " is] 43 L> ay iy . a Ya Ne au oa = el ot ty ul at oO , f= ig 'y mn) v . Fe ae p cf kn au y uv uy 3 Na i a Qi Ls) Das $3 43 a 42 bau Se rd cu "y m 1 Wn id dy MD 4s u 1 cr "9 ba oc nS nu wed "e a mm oO { at Na { OF) to iP) | io at ue ap te 1" g v 14) a tort ond i Bet Wa Ea) 7 9 dd gq be ford 4 xB c sy a) m Gy Py a Pe) fal ae] al Qa d tl tay Ls oO at . >a fo op a Db @ GS Mm & one) stom 2 G Bey n « mM pay mn 5 uy ™ yp 43 <i tom col % u v Dod a a i) % DO, w of ua] wW a x4 vb at rl wf] QO yp so rol , | . q wi 3 ri tA fie) a] ar ww ol oO 47 u ay na ay ye) m & Se rar Q u 4? We ood 4 0) 13 41 ow hi fa o ~ 4 = d a ot 4G caf ) 4 t4 Bl pha ay a ) 0 4! cy = 4 a ia "ny e wry iJ 4 Si uy Lo Me a ra W eel Qce "At Ww i] "a 4 on fo a ty Bd lo | a Qe Al o it n ny a we 1a re m ad mn oo iP od rs) n amy Ft o Sa pe] 2 ts oO Ea ad sas u ba a oO fn Se 9 Sa n Cu my a rt Sa g el hr a Sy be dd et in Sat ay aod ie) Li a4 BG mn aiam rd rf is i is oO! Ladhr goon ou og go SO 3S Bale nop ww a ~Udo sp 'ot Oo Og 'Soa rap er goounm dita ge mm saa cs oO og wm SOU ce 9 MC WAT ay ly wd is) Q mea raed Ma uid m 4a oO tn ca ast Ly a {53 "10 i ur 4 i] Saat ow % ci m ay LB) yw 342 O us) med Dy cng Ova 43 g a Cc & gow a ao DO P s$ oO Demby Agari Ao Ga mM ' Om y eta) 4 Es cacen mm ca) af cl a creer 3 whic ar Fa uty uy Uri r4 ai] ") ny J a] ay ny ea o ts vee ',.. Chere is a dist iwhickh ar@ not clpy uncidents which may cg. in Fees v Mely . 'tn order to CSONSTICUTe an infringement 12 wat nov "ecessary cnat The of 2 dialocus sicula Le = S8NE? tia situatis tnerdents., 2% LM Whoa 2 were = uw f8fountss cans 4al suction who he court must have dzamatic vaise and a wnat af anything was ta4wen, even alchoudg che portion might in Fact be sme and the x ence col cn the a undanent idea or lav. might b2 the sacs. hun 1e rhed out separisely ota iunéependent Lines baey might 3c different as to bear no rsal resemblance to one anothac.* One must, howev2r, 2 1 nak to a the conclusion that beer c mozely becaus2 cf #1 fo sco incidents, oc cf ine ch ast Found in historical, ay i FLotiosenai iiceratuse Fa HLSsvoly, 1.) ' s-man-t- a ag ear at ecee whey Tatass jf ote something to ths apoarcint fuclese ful ust by Tilaai vt This = : betes ween wee att Tey yon eas : bechnisauco. Io thar twat it vw. alte Lakely Dat the cp gy 2eegciei¢0e 2 in & AUTILSUL Snel, oa a i " a ey C ~ ' a 3 a q ry ra "7 a ny na 4 : 4 a3 3 , rt dd vf q m" mt ' ny 3 my ma nid nm 4s s 1 is ue 4 4 t ce id Qo ad a 4 ms io wv i ? uy - r oy ' DP Sh rt w 1 y i nf us 1 a c n un 3 | oan {-1 WY 5 1 ay 1 2 vt ie) D c "4 i ' ' ' " a) - Ly ry qe 4 d al t) a ry at e* cl 4 ' dd iN nv bel) sd wt Bey Ti iy vr NY 4 t le Ve i tay ne oi 3 ' orn on os oEd nN re) ow 8k di Mo =! " w uy ead ny S v c ay ") ' YW ay i 4 . st mh u ny mn he ad ' wd ay . ey Lt ? a J 34 4 . n wf ay "4 a ' er 4 Ac ut mn om ue] m a 1 wt wd fey rm nm a t 1) nr my qs ! nn be ss 1? ry ay cd qh rh Uy) iz - 7 taal m gy iy n J 1 el ag "2 fel rt ' nn w 4 a] es a Mt re 7 1 1 { 4 " brood H ' ct i ny "1 a i u ae) hh rd Wy 2 , cal —n n ed 'a Y au ce d at v Nt : i on Lv r, m1 z Is mi y re ey ny m 3 1 DU 4 y "r ath Jd ? eA 3 q a] id " . th xr uy Po w a . st 2 uy al " a oq "3 Wy 4 cl ? ao re Y wy hig id wy u il > # ay uo d Lay 5 ia) z a wu O8) od el 4 a ay nm a id oA d on} F Wa cal a Ww 2 "y y mn Ra at 44 "y ev ral oe] in a w vb Oe] } Hi b a 4 t "q ") stl mw b r w ng u rd >] OL ") | 1 2 kn o} . "y io] ny oy imi w 4 eS ny . uy v v4 rd ry cq ul aa wt WW wt pel Wy a mW ' uM Meo at " a ON al % * » +4 ° 4 2 ho rt "s uot "a Fr ha ao . w ot vb u n at ha Pa N at Bg ix] Ea 0 mp ' ut "4 an rt - on = m Q u §) > Surf a) ny GQ oay a od Sta si rt ur ad = ag ot x uM md fe -1 ay t o ct 1) m . 4 1) . vt "D id nd yo m MA ms ny wu i) tr pt i 3 a " o wd m vp ay Sa te] Vv vy oO a aa Ww Ws At mt fa) at w Gy dd ay 4a rf ay 1 OQ a sy pen uy a ae W st Ws 7 q "5 Gq o oy wt da wo I " pa "y 3 7 12 12 tt nm 4 th ad " 1 re 6S ie) vW a wv ae! 3 a fA ct ' a : y is) 3 Mm Aa bu A uO nid vow goo: rd fe) he 41 n fa a ug vl i) nm 4) i at 1? it) y yp No i] in Ee mi Na yy b n oa) fl Le '1 on ' 1) ") by Da 3 u a fe) o . q ra) be) > is) On »v & 3 fay be by) m ft ar ¢ 9 es a 33 1 £ Wy ca) a ES] G 3 aa Hd r-t P| Cs oe © fe © On ) i © a < 8 P Poo [cs i: ee m 4 s ql "a z Ka mm a i) m d 1$ BM 'd ia] Ei m a9 wv a £. is) u a a a nt) +? a hm & Po i v a) soy a ha n vu Q vy a i) GS OG s §& ovo © GF 3B DBD B&B DB tho 8 ou ico > 3 = wou aw 4 7 QQ ba gy pb a d @ 4 Ma el " u 4 mn fA a4 iw] mi . LT] Sa ay te} Pe] Me Oo yn 1 "4 by dy Ww 4° cl oe 1g ay a) 4 a ~ ws fa n 9 1 ie) hm Ww wy wo St 1] y a d 5 ity ort oO fit) a yp «i mY PS) Ba) oO Wy m 3 £4 uw 2 5 cr et u Ww t bo tht > wt d 4? Wom q Ma n ie) mn pe o 42 m a] i u et dd pv Be 4y th vA v hy i) ED) "4 1 ml W Lal Dy S DS on 3 3 S iP) Sq i) i ge oOo wv a bos . rr re 1S m 43 rf md ct ie] ny rd nD " as c Cd 4 a rt cB) 9 c; : Al . m 4 ct ' ut De) rt 1G rf Ee "9 3 oO "a is ran . ) re a 43 . HE nH a aA [rs on rn) 4 0 2 YF FP ) YB SB wo yh S S "] cd mh a ov vom Ea oO W md by ord ny d ry ot n na wn at fe) Sa n Na bP] el g rt cS) Ww ba 3) & 2 nj Ve v a 68 dd iy ba 5 o @ v oO sh rt a) a +s a YU ug Q fey wooo bs f= ar Q) w 1 e 1 ha 4) iv] ne DP] u tly A By uy a ng ao ord u | g 4 a Di te) 3 4 is) . " 13 iD (e)) ut Diy ™ ba 2 r mn mo ood oo Hw VP OO Bw OU 6 SR eh ta "4 cal Dp ou Aid 0 aI n & 7 fs nD rf rA 1) ") ie] > mw OEY ny ny ia) at " Ly 5 my {ne mnie thle nt yn ALS RN AEE eer re NR an nN te gant tn il Wl '1 ae n w =] nn i) i] n) Mm tt ce in rd m oe oh ie) ot Llafr Lt vign R ny py a et njunc a) Wh } . ' t y " me iad r 1 itLD or Ne i] a ny iP] We ny » a wore watt 2 ee TY eee ny a C wo gE y ved t Z Ca without sient pus c nm Vv A rt ou as Fa. al od =ce D tat mW Qh Wy " J LS) 1?) Pa m dd = oO iy a y aa) F4 Le n {3 Peake Li) u pe) rr ? Y u FREE red Lo | Ae