Ether Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors v. Cut Price Deli Pty Ltd & Ors [1985] FCA 427

woe ;

. /, IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ' aa NEW SOUTH WALES DISTPICT PEGISTRY a Q WwW ra) ve] o Fh eZ

GENERAL DIVISTON

BETWEEN : ETHER HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED First Applicant

GREGORY RAYMOND LILLINGTON

Second Applicant

KEPRY ANNE LILLINGTON

Third Applicant

Fourth Applicant ELIZABETH MARTIN HOOD

Fifth Applicant COLIN EDWAPD EMANUEL

Sixth Applicant

ROBYN MARGARET EMANUEL

Seventh Applicant

AND: CUT PPICE DELI PTY LIMITED Fespondent AND: OUT PPICE DELI PTY LIMITED

cross Claimant

AND: ETHEP HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED

First Crass Fespondent

WILCOX J.

12 AUGUST 1985 SYDNEY

(2

GREGORY PAYMOND LILLINGTON KERRY ANNE LILLINGTON GERALD H90D

ELISABETH MAPTIN HOOD COLIN EDWARD EMANUET

ROBYN MARGARET EMANUEL

Second Cross Respondents

MINUTE OF ORDERS

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

tJ .

NOTE:

The Cross Claim is dismissed,

The cross claimant pay to the cross respondents any

sasts incurred by them of the Cross Claim including

any reserved costs.

lement and entry of orders 1 > of Fhe

s dealt with in Federal Court Rules.

'NOTE: Thia judgment rela

tea

predominantly to its own facts and

us not of sufficient general interest to justify circulation)

IN THE FPEDEPAL COURT OF AUSTPALTA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

BETWEEN :

AND:

No.

ve] i) ra 'D

of 1984

ETHER HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED First Applicant

GREGORY PAYMOND LILLINGTON Second Applicant

KERRY ANNE LILLINGTON

Third Applicant GERALD HOOD

Fourth Applicant ELIZABETH MAPTIN HOOD

Fifth Applicant

COLIN EDWARD EMANUEL

Sixth Apelicant POBYN M&PGARET EM&aNVeEL

Seventh Applicant

CULr PRICE DELI PTY LIMITED

AND;

Pespondent

cur PRICE DELI PTY LIMITED

Ww

AND: ETHER HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED

First Cross Respondent

GREGORY RAYMOND LILLINGTON KEPRY ANNE LILLINGTON GERALD HOOD

ELIZABETH MARTIN HOOD COLIN EDWARD EMANUEL

ROBYN MARGARET EMANUEL

Second Cross Respondents

TORAM: WILCOX J. DATE: 12 AUGUST 1985 PLACE: SYDNEY

EXTEMPOPRE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT