Deltuust 27 Many Gee Ancona Judgment - Edwards V_ The King My brother Starke and I are of the opinion that there was no weng. decision of any question of law or any miscarriage of justice within Section 6 of the Crimkinsl 4ppesle Act, 1924 for 'whion the aouvietion should be set aside. My brothers bixon and xvatt are of the opinion that upon the twi itema of eorrobération upon which the Chief Justice relied the evidence wae insufficient. to submit to the jury and that, because of thie, the failure of the Ghief Justice to direct the jur} as to the purpose for which the evidence of the eventea at Victor Harbor might be relied ujon, the sonvietion should net stand. In thia division of opinion the decision of the Supreme Court must be upheld and the appeal @iamissed,