IN| THE HIGH COURT GF AUSTRALIA « THE QUEEN REASONS FOR JUDGMENT Oral Judgment delivered at......2.-...--. Tuesday 8th Dec ORDER Application for special leave to appeal refused. DUGAN Ve JUDGMENT BARWICK C.J. (ORAL) DUGAN Ve THE QUEEN Mr. Vizard has put before us, very fairly and very fully, a number of criticisms of the summing-up of the learned trial judge and on those has based a submission that the trial miscarried. However, having listened to all that he has said and having read the judgments of the Court of Criminal Appeal, the summing-up and the passages in the evidence to which reference has been made, I find no reason myself to doubt the propriety of the conclusions and the opinions to which the Court of Criminal Appeal came and which they expressed in their judgments, For that reason, in my opinion, this is not a case for the grant of special leave to appeal. UDGMENT McTIERNAN J. ORAL . DUGAN Ve THE QUEEN I am of the same opinion. DUGAN Vv. THE QUEEN IUDGMENT ; MENZIES J. (ORAL) THE QUEEN I agree. JUDGMENT (ORAL) DUGAN ve THE QUEEN WINDEYER J. DUGAN Ve THE QUEEN I agree. JUDGMENT (ORAL) DUGAN Ve THE QUEEN OWEN J. o THE QUEEN I agree.